Rachel Maddow is at it again — eyes to the heavens, voice quivering, as if she’s about to narrate the final act of a Ken Burns documentary entitled “America: The Dark Years.”
This week’s cliffhanger? “We have a consolidating dictatorship in our country.”
In Maddow’s latest monologue, she painted Trump’s America as a police-state nightmare — “secret police” supposedly prowling for immigrants, civil life grinding to a halt, the entire nation undergoing a “profound” transformation in just six months. If you closed your eyes, you’d think she was describing Venezuela with better lighting.
Now, I understand Rachel’s job is to frighten the MSNBC faithful into thinking every Trump policy is a page from the Authoritarian for Dummies handbook. But here’s the thing: none of what’s happening right now is a surprise. Not one iota. In fact, it’s exactly what the voters — you know, the people in that pesky little thing called a constitutional republic — elected him to do.
Tariffs? Promised.
Deportations? Promised.
Tax relief? Promised.
Law enforcement actually enforcing laws? Promised.
Booting gender ideology out of schools? Promised.
Supporting the military, telling Iran to sit down and shut up, standing by our allies, creating a fair playing field for American products, rooting out corruption — all promised.
That’s not authoritarianism. That’s called “keeping your campaign promises.” It’s just that in Washington, where most promises evaporate faster than a TikTok trend, actually doing what you said you’d do is treated like sorcery.
But Maddow’s rant was only the appetizer. The real main course of absurdity was served in the comment section.
One person lamented, “It’s not just the leader. GOP Reps, senators, and Supreme Court judges have made this all possible. They are enthusiastically complicit in this.”
Recommended
To which I replied, “Because we the people put them all there.” That’s how elections work. Shocking, I know.
Another commenter asked, “Where are our elected officials!? Why aren’t they fighting for us?!”
Well, they were replaced in the last election. The people in majorities gave us the officials we have now. That’s the beauty — and the occasional comedy — of a representative republic. If you don’t like them, vote differently next time. This is Civics 101, folks.
Then came my personal favorite: “Vote BLUE on all tickets!!!!”
Do you mean ballots? Because no one votes “in a ticket.” You can vote a “straight ticket” on a ballot, but you don’t vote for tickets. That’s how you end up in the wrong line at a concert, wondering why the opening act is Congress.
One pearl-clutcher declared, “Along with Russia, the USA is the last country on earth I would want to be visiting these days. How can it just collapse into this dictatorship so quickly? Mind-blowing.”
Relax, champ. It’s not a dictatorship. Rachel just flunked civics and took you with her.
Then there was the historian-in-training who opined that the “crazy part” is that Americans aren’t protesting in the streets because we’ve “accepted” this. I responded with the simplest truth in the whole thread: We’re not outraged — we voted for this. Trump increased his vote totals in every single county in the 2024 election. That’s not a coup; that’s an endorsement.
This is where Maddow’s entire premise collapses under its own melodrama. In a dictatorship, leaders don’t need elections — and they certainly don’t increase their support in all 3,143 counties through lawful votes. In an authoritarian state, your ballot doesn’t matter. Here, your ballot is the only thing that matters.
What we have right now isn’t a “consolidating dictatorship.” It’s a thriving, loud, messy, and gloriously frustrating representative constitutional republic. A place where voters make choices, live with those choices, and then decide later if they want to make different ones.
Rachel Maddow’s greatest offense isn’t her over-the-top delivery or her gift for imagining jackbooted thugs behind every traffic stop. It’s that she refuses to direct her ire where it actually belongs: not at Trump, but at the voters — the millions upon millions of Americans who went to the polls in 2024 and said, “Yes, more of that, please.”
You want to be mad about the policies? Fine. Be mad at them. Be mad at every county where Trump’s support grew — which, again, is all of them. But don’t insult the intelligence of the American people by pretending that delivering on campaign promises is the same as dismantling democracy.
Because if keeping promises is authoritarianism, we might just need more of it.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member