One of the reasons the October 7, 2023 Hamas terror attacks in Israel were so effective was that Palestinians who worked in Israel provided the terrorists with detailed maps of cities, streets, and other geographical information. Because of this betrayal, Israel has banned Palestinian workers from the country, and rightly so.
But the American Leftist media wants us to feel sympathy for those Palestinians, as this sob story in The New Yorker attempts to do.
Israel’s ban on Palestinian workers has left families hungry and parents unable to pay for their children’s school fees. Still, the ban is being justified in the name of security, and shows no signs of abating.https://t.co/s8n7Kz5bhP
— The New Yorker (@NewYorker) June 27, 2026
Before October 7th, a fifth of the West Bank’s labor force was employed in Israel, earning more than double the prevailing wage at home. Palestinian workers were required to obtain permits, but a 2007 ruling by Israel’s High Court awarded them the same labor rights as Israelis. After October 7th, however, the number of Palestinian workers entering Israel each day fell from more than a hundred thousand to well under ten thousand. (Another thirty-four thousand maintain permits to work around Israeli settlements in the West Bank.) Unemployment in the West Bank surged to twenty-nine per cent. A World Bank report on the state of the Palestinian economy described what amounted to an economic collapse.
The decision to ban Palestinian workers was originally presented as an emergency measure, but as it continued, many business leaders and economists came to oppose it. According to the Times of Israel, a proposal to allow some Palestinian workers back into Israel, in late 2023, was supported by representatives from the Israeli military; from Israel’s security agency, the Shin Bet; and from COGAT, the agency responsible for implementing Israeli policies in Palestinian territories. Senior figures argued that job opportunities in Israel helped stabilize the West Bank, reducing tensions by providing income and a sense of economic mobility. But some Israeli politicians argued for a permanent shift. “Israel can and must advance alternatives that will provide a different solution to the economy,” Bezalel Smotrich, Israel’s finance minister, said. “We are leaving the old conception behind: stop employing Palestinian workers,” Barkat said, in 2024. More than two and a half years after October 7th, the ban is still in effect, and it no longer reads as temporary.
Recommended
This is toxic empathy.
The definition of suicidal empathy. Hamas had such accurate maps and information about the neighboring kibbutzes because Palestinian workers drew them. And they used the information to perpetrate a massacre.
— Bethany S. Mandel (@bethanyshondark) June 28, 2026
The should never be allowed into the nation again.
This is an insanely dishonest take and you should feel shame for this post.
— Fusilli Spock (@awstar11) June 28, 2026
They have no shame.
Palestinians are not owed jobs in Israel. If they want jobs, they should go to Jordan or Egypt. You know, the nations where they didn’t help slaughter people.
— Dan Gainor (@dangainor) June 28, 2026
Egypt won't tolerate this nonsense.
This is legit INSANE. Israel offers 1000s of work permits to provide economic opportunity to Palestinians (whose own gov doesnt)—thousands then massacre Israelis (incl their very employers!) on 10/7 starting a 2-yr war, & the complaint is Israel isn’t giving them jobs?? https://t.co/R2txfWYIDH
— Jonah Platt (@JonahPlatt) June 28, 2026
Insane is all they've got.
Maybe next time don't massacre your employers https://t.co/E7scs44nY9
— Dr. Eli David (@DrEliDavid) June 29, 2026
That's solid advice for anyone who wants a job.
It's a well-observed feature of every genocide through history that victims were extremely upset at being denied the opportunity to work for people trying to murder them. https://t.co/q9LEL3jr8E
— LoLNothingMatters (@DastDn) June 28, 2026
This is also a really good point. Israel is committing a genocide, but Palestinians still want to work in the country that's genociding them?
Makes no sense.
It is beyond deranged that The New Yorker and other Leftists believe Israel has an obligation to allow Palestinians into the country after what happened on October 7. Palestinian workers helped Hamas terrorists kill Jews in the largest massacre since the Holocaust. Banning them from employment in the country is the moderate option.
Editor's Note: Do you enjoy Townhall's conservative reporting that takes on the radical Left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.
Join Townhall VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member