Mayhem Has Engulfed This Distant French Territory
New Video of Scottie Scheffler's Arrest Paints a Very Different Picture
Comedian Takes Aim at San Francisco's Anarchic Tendencies
You Have to Be an Exceptionally Bad President to Lose Silicon Valley
The $400 Pineapple Is Now Sold Out in the US
The High Art of Virtue Signaling
Video Captures Illegal Immigrants Throwing Rocks, Sand at Border Patrol Agents
Half of UCLA Med School Students Fail Basic Tests Thanks to DEI Push
Liberal Outlet Censors Sen. John Kennedy's Op-Ed On Protecting Women’s Sports Due To...
Look What's Come Back to Haunt Hunter Biden at His Gun Trial
Opposition to U.S. Steel Deal is Misguided and Counterproductive
Red States Could End Up Paying for Blue States’ Climate Policies
As AZ Democrats Panic Over the ‘Secure the Border Act,’ Republicans Should Keep...
EVs Should Only Be for Consenting Adults
FIFA Is Latest Target of Palestinian Hijacking
OPINION

Suddenly, a Silence

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

As always, the man -- and the justice of the Supreme Court of the United States -- confounded and astonished, dismayed and delighted even as he took his abrupt leave over the weekend. How even begin to describe the indescribable, constant and changeable Antonin Scalia? He was the court's great dissenter and disturber of the peace over the decades he served on it. He could be both scholarly theorist (he called his theory Originalism, or doing what the Founding Fathers surely intended in their time) and agitator extraordinaire as he took on all comers, always looking for trouble even if he had to start it.

Advertisement

Antonin Scalia and Richard Arnold, the greatest American judge never to have sat on the Supreme Court of the United States, made a fitting pair of bookends -- so different in style, so alike in their dedication to the civil liberties of the American people. Yet they were fast friends, exchanging dueling quips about the superiority of Yale or Harvard Law. Concise as Scalia was verbose, Arnold would naturally be first in his class at both. His background in the classics doubtless helped. If memory serves, and sometimes it doesn't, he wrote the class poem -- in Latin.

But how sum up Antonin Scalia's contribution to constitutional law? Let's just say that whenever an appellate judge or legal scholar wants to ornament an opinion, he'll be using a quotation from the ever quotable Justice Scalia.

Few justices of the Supreme Court of the United States have so enjoyed being justices of the Supreme Court of the United States, which is always a bad sign -- for power is to be feared, not relished, especially in one's own hands. Justice Scalia staged public debates with his ideological rival, the Hon. Stephen Breyer -- an unedifying spectacle that detracted from both the dignity and confidentiality of the court's deliberations. No one is denying that the Hon. Antonin Scalia was a great showman; the question is whether justice should be a show, let alone an operatic performance.

What a contrast Justice Scalia has made with his colleague Clarence Thomas on the court, its Quiet Man, who's been known to sit through entire sessions without saying a single word. Justice Thomas has given American law consistency and content, depth and dependability as opposed to Antonin Scalia's never-ceasing quips, entertaining as they have been. They've made a complementary pair, Justices Scalia and Thomas. Such a combination is not likely to be seen again in our lifetimes -- or anybody else's.

Advertisement

To go from the sublime to the superficial: the confirmation hearings for Justice Scalia's successor. Or maybe not, since the Democrats will be eager for the president to appoint the next member of the highest court in the land while the Republicans will do everything in their power or beyond it to see that the next president -- a member of their party, they hope -- will get to appoint him or her. That is, stall, delay, distract and anything else they can think of.

So here comes the next act in that continuing show, struggle and drama known as American constitutional law. Fasten your seat belts.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos