BREAKING: A Helicopter Carrying Iran's President Has Crashed
Bill Maher's Latest Closing Segment Was Probably His Fairest
Former Ted Cruz Communications Director and CNN Commentator Alice Stewart Has Died
How Trump Reacted to a Dysfunctional Podium in Minnesota
Washington Is High School With Paychecks
A Quick Bible Study Vol. 218: What the Bible Says About Brokenness
Biden Sure Told Some Shameless Lies About Voting Rights at Morehouse College Commencement
Morehouse College Grads Turn Their Backs on Joe Biden
Tim Scott Reminds Americans of Joe Biden’s Association With a KKK Member
Here’s What Republicans, Democrats Think of the Trump, Biden Debate
Democrat State Caught Housing Illegal Immigrant Children in Hotels With Sex Offender
Catholic Groups Accuse Biden Admin of Withholding Funds From Hospitals Who Don't Perform...
MSNBC Legal Analyst Thinks Blaming Bob Menendez’s Wife Is a Good Tactic
Russia Warns U.S. Is 'Playing With Fire' in Its Continued Support for Ukraine
Good Teaching Requires the Right Ingredients

Super-Committee to Slash Defense Spending: What It Means for Investors

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of

Be sure to mark November 23rd on your calendar.

That's the deadline for Congress to pass -- and the President to sign -- major budget changes being drawn up by the bipartisan "super-committee." 


Recall that the last agreement, struck in early August, tasked this group with a huge challenge: Come up with a wide range of chosen budget cuts, or live with the consequences of automatic spending cuts that leave no stone unturned.

That's bad news for investors, as we could see history repeating itself in a very unpleasant way.

At this point, Democrats and Republicans are far from an agreement. Democrats have offered up $3.2 trillion in spending cuts, paired with $1.3 trillion in new taxes.

Republicans are fine with the spending cuts but insist on no new taxes. 

With neither side ready to blink so far, it's becoming increasingly apparent that the automatic cuts will be making their way to the budget soon.

This is horrible news for the defense sector and investors who hold stocks in these companies. Cuts in military spending already have the support of most Democrats, and a rising number of deficit hawks in the Republican Party are willing to trim Department of Defense (DoD) spending as well. 

Still, a negotiated budget will be far friendlier to the DoD than the automatic cuts that may take place on Nov. 23. 

So How Much Money Are We Talking About?

About $454 billion from the next DoD budget. That's more than one-third of all planned automatic cuts that would take place. And these cuts come on top of $350 billion in previously agreed-upon cuts as a result of this summer's budget agreement.


The number of soldiers on active duty would likely have to shrink, but it's impossible to quickly shed tens of thousands of soldiers, shutter dozens of military bases and withdraw from key strategic regions around the world. This is a long-term possibility, but not a short-term one.

Instead, look for the budget axe to come down hard on defense contractors, all of whom live off lucrative contracts to build billion-dollar planes, ships and security systems.

Merrill Lynch says spending by defense contractors will shrink 3.3% annually for the next five years -- and even this number may prove optimistic. Defense spending has risen from 3% of gross domestic product in the 1990s to a current 4.8%. A return to that 3% level represents a 35% drop.

Merrill's analysts note that since Operation Enduring Freedom began in October 2001, defense and security spending has risen 74%.

"In our view, this defense budget trend is unsustainable considering the current political and economic backdrop. We expect the budget to decline and revert to the mean, particularly as our operations in Iraq and Afghanistan wind down."

With such a dire outcome coming into focus, it's fairly remarkable that defense stocks are trading as if it's business as usual.

Sure, defense stocks have weakened, but not nearly to the extent that you might imagine.


In fact, the PHLX Defense Sector Index, which contains a basket of stocks in the industry, remains roughly 100% above the lows seen in 2009.

The Pain of a Deep Cut in Defense Would Spread Across the Board

For example:

  • Boeing Co. (NYSE: BA) currently has 30,000 workers employed on next-generation airborne refueling tankers. This is a pricey project that was already hampered by a lack of widespread support at the Pentagon.
  • Textron Inc. (NYSE: TXT)'s V-22 Osprey tilt-rotor aircraft program may also end up on the chopping block.
  • General Dynamics (NYSE: GD) may lose a lucrative contract to upgrade Abrams tanks.
  • Raytheon's (NYSE: RTN) Patriot missile system may also be sharply pared back.
  • Lockheed Martin (NYSE: LMT), Northrup Grumman (NYSE: NOC) and BAE Systems have all heavily invested in the F-35 joint strike fighter program, which is already plagued by massive cost overruns. This makes it an easy target for budget cutters at the Pentagon. At its current pace, the program could cost $1 trillion during the next 10 years unless it's scaled back.

"Programs that can't meet schedule, that can't meet cost... requirements are very much in jeopardy and will be very much under scrutiny," Adm. Mike Mullen, who recently retired as chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said at a September Congressional hearing.


The Profit Impact

Curiously, Wall Street analysts have yet to bake the existing budgets cuts agreed upon this summer, let alone the cuts that may hit the tape after Nov. 23. Lockheed Martin, for example, is expected to see earnings per share (EPS) actually rise 13% in 2012 to a record $8.53, according to consensus forecasts.

Raytheon's EPS is expected to rise around 9% to $5.43. Textron's per-share profits are expected to rise 45% to $1.67.

Analysts likely think that any major cuts won't take place until 2013 and beyond, but they probably underestimate the speed with which the Pentagon may move to alter the trajectory of many key programs.

Defense Secretary Leon Panetta has already noted that a sense of urgency will kick in once the budget matters are clarified. Like many others in Washington, Panetta has expressed deep concern about automatic budget cuts being enforced, rather than a negotiated solution.

Sadly, such an outcome looks less likely with each passing week. With three weeks left to strike a deal, time is running out.

The Investing Answer: It's hard to envision any scenario in which current levels of U.S. defense spending are preserved, and for now the defense sector appears cheap with as most stocks trading for a little less than 10 times earnings. But if earnings begin a secular decline, as increasingly looks likely, then such a multiple is no longer quite appealing.


We'll have a better sense of which defense contractors are most vulnerable to DoD budget cuts in early 2012 as new plans are articulated. Before then, it may simply be wiser to short the iShares Dow Jones U.S. Aerospace ETF (NYSE: ITA), which holds a range of defense stocks. Another option is the PowerShares Aerospace Defense ETF (NYSE: PPA). Even if you're not inclined to short this group of stocks, then it may be a wise time to sell them now if you own shares, as it's hard to see any potential upside in such a challenging environment.

This article originally appeared on

Join the conversation as a VIP Member


Trending on Townhall Videos