Salena Zito

Franklin D. Roosevelt understood what it meant to be a core Democrat and maintaining his party’s ranks.

He built winning coalitions around his policies by empowering previously suppressed groups, such as labor unions and urban ethnics. In the process, he created a 40-year dynasty for Democrats.

Today’s bunch? Not so much.

The problem for FDR’s party is that it hasn’t adapted swiftly enough to two realities – that jobs are the most important issue to the nation, and that the middle class (which Democrats claim to champion) is dissolving under its watch.

It seemed that Democrats may be starting to understand, when President Barack Obama kicked-off what is supposed to be a series of “main street” listening tours last week in Allentown, Pa.

Going Rogue by Sarah Palin FREE

Thirteen months after Democrats took over the entire federal government, fewer Americans identify themselves as members of their party, bucking a trend that began in 2004. A new poll by Rasmussen reports that the number of Americans calling themselves Democrats fell by almost 2 points, to 36 percent, last month alone.

Republican party-identity is lower than that of Democrats at 33.1 percent, an increase from 31.9 percent the previous month.

But here’s the kicker: The number of people who say they are not affiliated with either party is rising.

Both parties have an identity problem. Despite news stories on how fractured Republicans are, Democrats – the bigger of the two parties – have a larger problem. That’s because “bigger” tends to come at the price of homogeneity, so it’s harder to find a common thread among the Dems than among Republicans.

Many populists in the “Tea Party” movement are the same people who used to indentify themselves as Democrats. They are moving away from their party (many reluctantly, especially in rust-belt states where you almost inherit party affiliation through family and community ties) because of the numerous agendas crowded into the party’s tent.

Political parties evolve depending on events, and the opportunity to construct coalitions around those events strengthens a party.

Democrats (excluding those in government jobs) aren’t seeing the up-side of an expensive federal stimulus package; they don’t see how cap-and-trade doesn’t cost jobs in their community. And the healthcare bill lost its luster when it became so politicized.

Salena Zito

Salena Zito is a political analyst, reporter and columnist.