The cliche about entitlements (the "third rail") had been largely true. Neither Republicans nor Democrats had shown the courage to tell middle-class voters that Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security would have to change. But on April 15, all but four Republicans (and zero Democrats) voted for a budget that would block grant Medicaid to the states and gradually transform Medicare from the whale-shark entitlement that threatens to swallow all other federal spending into a premium support program.
Naturally, the Republicans got no credit for this principled vote from the usual suspects (the press, the liberal commentators, the professors). But you'd think fellow Republicans and conservatives would offer at least a clap on the back. Nope. Just a few weeks later, former Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich, appearing on MSNBC's "Meet the Press," labeled the Ryan budget "too radical" and "right-wing social engineering," which Gingrich explained that he opposed as much as "left-wing social engineering."
As Rep. Paul Ryan said at the time, "With allies like that, who needs the left?"
It set the tone for what was to come. While claiming to save the Republican Party from the supposedly "moderate" Romney, one after another of the Republican presidential candidates has seized the slogans of the left -- even of the Occupy movement -- to make his case. Judging by campaign rhetoric, there is really only one conservative left in the race, and that's Romney.
A few weeks after "Meet the Press," Gingrich reversed himself on the Ryan budget. A spokesman said, "There is little daylight between Ryan and Gingrich on Medicare." But Gingrich was soon sounding like Michael Moore regarding Romney's career at Bain Capital. "Is capitalism really about the ability of a handful of rich people to manipulate the lives of thousands of other people and walk off with the money or is that somehow a little bit of a flawed system?" asked the self-styled "Reagan conservative." Romney's wealth, Gingrich said, came from a model of "leverage the game, borrow the money, leave the debt behind and walk off with all the profits. ... I think it's exploitive. I think it's not defensible."