Jeff  Carter

Since I have gotten involved with building an entrepreneurial ecosystem in Chicago, I have done a lot of listening to people that either built, or are trying to build one somewhere else.

It’s interesting to listen.

No matter what their political persuasion is, they all talk about government interference, or government involvement. The top thing they cite is that government shouldn’t be involved at all. Not in planning, directing, giving tax breaks or encouraging. Stay out of it.

They all say what government should do is keep taxes very low. Keep the streets clear and drivable, and make sure people have water to drink. They also think we need much better immigration policy. That’s about it. Entrepreneurs will take care of the rest.

The other phenomena they talk about is competition for talent. The start up community needs a lot of different human capital resources, but the most important one is engineering and programming. Virtually every business no matter what they focus on has some sort of tech piece that attaches itself to the business.

Looking at the businesses I have put money into over the past several years, they may not need hi tech in the production of the product, but they need it in their marketing. Win Detergent ( and Tallgrass Beef ( are both consumer products that are starting to figure out how to utilize the web to build a brand.

The competition for specific talent has made it easy for coders, programmers and engineers to find jobs. When one firm fails, they can hook on with another firm if there are enough firms around.

The essential building block of an entrepreneurial ecosystem then is to have enough computer geeks around, and enough start ups for them to work for. That’s why Silicon Valley continues to self perpetuate itself. It’s also why other areas of the country have had a hard time building an ecosystem.

I am convinced that supply creates demand. If you want a bunch of start ups in a community, create cheap and easy access to capital for them. That means angel groups and funds that will invest in start ups. If you want a bunch of computer geeks to move to your area to fill the jobs that will be created by the start ups, what do you do to attract them?

I have had interesting conversations with entrepreneurs to get their opinion. One idea gets to the base of what it means to be human, and an unreported story amidst all the Groupon ($GRPN) publicity last week was how they attacked the problem.

Jeff Carter

Jeffrey Carter is an independent speculator. He has been trading since 1988. His blog site, Points and Figures was named by Minyanville as one of The 20 Most Influential Blogs in Financial Media.