Make no mistake about this decision. Whatever prompted the change, its practical effect is to delegitimize those who have called for tougher enforcement of U.S. immigration law. The AP just erased from journalism's lexicon the important distinction between legal and illegal immigrants.
The racial justice website Colorlines launched its "Drop the I-Word" campaign with the argument, "No human being is illegal." That argument has penetrated my thick skull when it comes to using the I-word as a noun for illegal immigrants, "illegals." I get it. It's rude.
But if no human being is illegal, some human beings are illegal immigrants. They overstayed their visas or crossed the border illegally. They're not legal immigrants; they're illegal immigrants. It doesn't speak well for journalism when the AP Stylebook directs reporters to write in a way that obscures reality.
(Some critics, such as Mark Krikorian of the pro-enforcement Center for Immigration Studies, believe that the AP should refer to them as "illegal aliens" -- as opposed to legal aliens. "Alien" is the more accurate term for noncitizen residents. But it's archaic English, likely to confuse science fiction fans.)
In October, Carroll defended the use of "illegal immigrant" and rejected the suggestion that the term offended anyone's dignity. After all, she observed, "we refer routinely to illegal loggers, illegal miners, illegal vendors and so forth."
Last week, however, she wrote that the AP's position had evolved as part of an effort to rid the stylebook of labels. The stylebook now tells reporters to refer to what they used to call a schizophrenic as someone "diagnosed with schizophrenia." Even as news space shrinks, the stylebook tells reporters to take the long route and look for "the best way to describe someone who is in a country without permission" -- also known as a long clause over which readers skip.
In October, the AP rightly rejected calls that it replace "illegal immigrant" with "undocumented" or "unauthorized" immigrant on the grounds that those terms "can make a person's illegal presence in the country to appear a matter of minor paperwork." Ahem. "In a country without permission" doesn't?
Paying Attention Now? Gosnell Movie Campaign Reaches $1 Million After MSM Ignore Gruesome Abortion Story | Cortney O'Brien