Most people have three varying images of psychology. One is of a scientist poring over notes derived from a patient -- the Robin Williams-in-"Awakenings" brain specialist. The second is of a patient, lying on a divan, telling a psychologist stories about her parents' unstable marriage -- the therapist. The third is of a patient and her psychologist in flagrante delicto.
The truth is somewhere between the first and second images. Psychology is a field that is part science, part hand-holding and lots of speculation. The truth is that we know very little about the inner workings of the mind, and even less about abnormalities of the mind.
That inherent vagary is troubling because politics tends to fill the gap where scientific knowledge is thin. Take, for example, the latest edits to the Diagnostic and Statistical of Mental Disorders (DSM). Every couple decades, the psychology establishment rewrites this basic diagnostic textbook for the field, which is analogous to a "Gray's Anatomy" for the mind. And every couple decades, political correctness ensures that true science of the mind is obscured in favor of liberal niceties.
Back in 1974, for example, the DSM removed "homosexuality" from its list of mental illnesses. There was no actual scientific reason to do so -- homosexual men still have higher rates of suicide and depression than heterosexuals, homosexual women still have higher rates of substance abuse, homosexuals are statistically deviant (a crucial issue when discussing normality in any statistical sense), and homosexuals are definitionally incapable of natural reproduction. But due to pressure group influence, homosexuality was out.
The DSM then replaced homosexuality with "ego-dystonic homosexuality," which they defined as persistent lack of heterosexual arousal and distress from homosexual arousal. That wasn't good enough, either, and in 1986, the DSM dumped it completely.
What of the countless thousands who wish they could be treated for homosexuality? They don't matter, since the gay movement says that anyone with homosexual feelings should learn to be happy with those feelings -- a position they don't take with regard to men who think they are women and vice versa.
I Was A Woman In The Marine Corps In the Mid-70s. Hillary Clinton’s Story Doesn’t Add Up | Susan Hutchison