Pre-Election Special SALE: 60% Off VIP Membership
BREAKING: Supreme Court Rules on Whether Virginia Can Remove Non-Citizens From Voter Rolls
Tim Walz's Gaming Session With Ocasio-Cortez Was a Trainwreck
Oregon Predicates Request to Judge on Self-Delusion
GDP Report Shows Economy 'Weaker Than Expected'
How Trump Plans to Help Compensate Victims of 'Migrant Crime'
NRCC Blasts the Left's Voter Suppression Efforts in Battleground Districts
Watch Trump's Reaction to Finding Out Biden Called His Supporters 'Garbage'
26 Republican AGs Join Virginia in Petitioning SCOTUS to Intervene in Voter Registration...
There Was a Vile, Violent Attack in Chicago, and the Media's Been Silent....
One Red State Just Acquired a Massive Amount of Land to Secure Its...
Poll Out of Texas Shows That Harris Rally Sure Didn't Work for Colin...
This Hollywood Actor Is Persuading Christian Men to Vote for Kamala Harris
Is the Trump Campaign Over-Confident?
Is This Really How the Kamala HQ Is Going to Respond to Biden’s...
Tipsheet

Are Nazi References "Off the Table"?

President Bush's Nazi/appeasement analogy delivered before the Israeli Parliament has certainly created a lot of controversy.  Pat Buchanan, for example, calls it "
Advertisement
playing the Hitler card."

Aside from the irony that liberals have long compared Bush to Hitler, it does seem to be good and safe PR advice to advise politicians to steer clear of making Hitler or Nazi analogies. 

In fact, some believe we should never invoke the comparison.  As a blogger on The American Prospect put it:

North Americans need to forget the events of World War II, including the Holocaust.

Really?  I would argue we should never forget.  As Santayana said:  "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."   

Still, the idea that Nazi references are "off the table" seems to be gaining acceptance among pundits.  But what if there really is a direct analogy?  ... And if human nature inexorably leads some to totalitarianism, why eliminate a compelling argument that journalists could use to warn civilization about the threat?
Advertisement


Without a doubt, demagogues have wrongly used -- or over-used -- the Nazi analogy in the past.  As Justin Logan wrote for Cato and American Prospect, "If you live in the United States and want to start a war, the first step is to compare the foreign leader to Adolf Hitler."  As such, it is prudent for those who value freedom to not "cry wolf." 

AsGodwin's law states:  The "overuse of Nazi and Hitler comparisons should be avoided, because it robs the valid comparisons of their impact."

So what's the solution?  We should resist the pundits' call to declare even legitimate references to Hitlerism and Nazism as out-of-line, but we must also reserve the analogy for appropriate cases. 

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement