Federal Judge Sides With Christian Groups in Lawsuit Over Obamacare Birth Control Mandate

Posted: Dec 11, 2018 4:45 PM
Federal Judge Sides With Christian Groups in Lawsuit Over Obamacare Birth Control Mandate

A federal judge issued a permanent order Tuesday blocking the government from enforcing the Obama-era contraceptive mandate which had forced religious groups to provide birth control to their employees despite their religious objections.

Judge Philip Brimmer, a judge for the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado, wrote that compliance with the mandate violated the “plaintiffs’ rights under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.”

Judge Brimmer’s order brings an end to an over four-year long legal battle that began when these religious groups sued the Obama administration over the mandate.

The six groups in the suit are the Association of Christian Schools International, Samaritan Ministries International, Taylor University, Indiana Wesleyan University, Asbury Theological Seminary and the Alliance Defending Freedom.

The Trump administration’s Department of Justice abandoned any defense of the mandate. Recently, the administration also broadened the exemptions to the mandate to include employers with non-religious but moral objections to the rule.

In his order Tuesday, the judge noted that the Trump administration conceded that “requiring employers with sincerely held religious objections to comply with the Mandate or the accommodation process would violate RFRA.”

The Alliance Defending Freedom celebrated the decision Tuesday.

“Religious organizations have the freedom to peacefully operate according to their beliefs without the threat of punishment by the government. Tuesday’s order fully affirms that freedom and provides permanent protection from the mandate,” ADF Senior Counsel Gregory S. Baylor said in a statement.

“These faith-based organizations no longer have to fear being forced to pay fines for simply abiding by the Christian beliefs that they teach and espouse, and they are no longer required to fill out forms authorizing coverage for abortion-inducing drugs, contraception, and sterilization,” he added. “The government has many other ways to ensure access to these items without forcing people of faith to violate their deepest convictions.”

ADF noted that “Other federal district courts have issued similar orders in recent months for Christian organizations in Oklahoma, Indiana, California, Iowa, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Florida.”