Supreme Court Sends Transgender Bathroom Case Back to Lower Court

Posted: Mar 06, 2017 10:27 AM
Supreme Court Sends Transgender Bathroom Case Back to Lower Court

The Supreme Court has decided not to rule on a controversial case involving a transgender boy in Virginia and which bathroom he should be permitted to use, sending it back to The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals. The lower court allowed Gavin Grimm to use the restroom that corresponded to his gender identity. Yet, in light of the Trump administration's recent rollback of the Obama-era bathroom mandate, the Supreme Court has asked them to take another look at the law and reconsider its initial conclusion.

The Trump White House's decision to reverse Obama's bathroom mandate means that citizens must use the bathroom that reflects their birth certificates.

The Family Research Council, a group which works on behalf of conservative causes, praised the Supreme Court's decision as a win for parents.

"The Supreme Court has provided good news to parents and students concerned about privacy and safety in school showers, locker rooms and bathrooms," FRC President Tony Perkins said in a statement.

"In light of the Obama edict being withdrawn and this case now remanded, we are cautiously optimistic that the Fourth Circuit Court of appeals will reverse itself. As the Fourth Circuit stated in its earlier opinion, it would 'leave policy formulation to the political branches,' for 'the weighing of privacy interests or safety concerns' was not to be left 'to the courts."

Who Benefits From Democratic Control?
Walter E. Williams

This post has been updated.