KJP Has a Meltdown Over Questions About Lack of FEMA Funding
REMINDER: What the White House Said About Russia's 'Merchant of Death' When Biden...
Kamala's CBS Interview Was a Complete and Total Trainwreck
The Atlantic Came After One of Our Own...and It Ended Dreadfully
For Some Reason, Karine Jean-Pierre Got a Promotion
Kamala on '60 Minutes' Delivers Zero Minutes of Logic, Stephanopoulos Has Selective Rhetor...
Anniversary of 10/7 Makes Me Glad for Gun Rights in America
How the Left Marked the Anniversary of October 7
Cue the Outrage As Georgia Supreme Court Reinstates State Abortion Ban
Tillis Sets the Record Straight on Harris Campaign Taking His Words Out of...
The Media Sure Are Noticing a Key Concern About the Harris Campaign
Here's Why This Former Democratic Congressman Endorsed Trump on Anniversary of October 7
Melania Trump Tried to Donate to a University to Help Foster Kids. Here's...
Tom Cotton Destroys NBC's Kristen Welker When She Brings Up 'Misinformation' About FEMA...
Spain's First-Ever Team of 'Trans Men' Competed in Men's Soccer. It Turned Out...
OPINION

Open Border Conservatives Speak Out

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Amidst outrage over illegal immigration, some self-identified conservatives who see a bright side to open borders have been speaking up.

“These are economic migrants,” said Jason Riley, a member of the Wall Street Journal editorial board, speaking at the Cato Institute. “We have the jobs. They need the work. Let them come legally.”

Advertisement

Riley is one of several conservatives who dissent from the movement as a whole on the issue of illegal immigration. He argued that there are substantial economic motives for legalizing aliens and referred to border control as “Soviet-style central planning.”

“The case for open borders is pretty straightforward. It’s the case for letting the free market decide who comes into this country,” Riley said.

Conservative author Michael Barone also called for “labor laws to work more in tandem with markets” and claimed that there is historical precedent for the recent influx of Latino immigrants, pointing to the enormous Irish immigrations during the 1850s and the German immigrations of the eighteenth century.

“In fact, we are not dealing with something unprecedented, but something we have faced before,” he said.

Open border conservatives like Riley and Barone tend to identify closely with the libertarian wing of the movement and approach the issue from a small-government perspective. Many of them work at libertarian think-tanks like Cato and the Reason Foundation.

The most pronounced opposition to illegal immigration has come from conservative talk radio and cable news, where hosts like Lou Dobbs and Laura Ingraham frequently rail against illegal immigrants and open border policies.

Advertisement

Such conservatives don’t think very highly of their open borders brethren. In a 2007 online video, popular anti-illegal immigration blogger Michelle Malkin called Riley’s Wall Street Journal editorial board “effete conservative elites”. Many conservatives have also blasted President George W. Bush and Senator John McCain (R-Ariz.) for supporting a bill that would offer illegal immigrants a pathway to citizenship.

Riley said that many of the arguments used for cracking down on illegals are either false or misleading, such as the contention that immigrants take American jobs.

“The typical immigrant is either higher-skilled or lower-skilled than the average American, so they tend to complement the workforce rather than take jobs,” he said.

He also pointed to declining welfare caseloads, poverty, child poverty, and hunger over the past fifteen years as evidence that recent illegal immigration has not harmed the country.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos