National Science Foundation Grants Are Subverting the Integrity of Journalism and Election...
The New York Post and Real Journalism
Do Some Climate Alarmists Wish Us All Dead?
'Save the World' Is a Racket; Stop Falling For It
Selecting the House Speaker Should Not Be That Hard
Does Trump Really Want to be President Again?
Republicans Need to Retool the Party Platform, Prioritize Kitchen Table Issues For Support...
Just How Stupid Are Sen. Thom Tillis and the Rest of the Republican...
Republicans Should Follow Elon Musk's Whistleblowing Blueprint
America the Amazing
December Is No Time to Ignore Congress
Lessons Republicans Should Learn From the Election Losses (but Probably Won’t)
Biden's Bribe of Americans
How's the Weather in China
Twitter Files: The Real News Is That the Left/Dems/Media Do Not Care

The False Premise of Who Pays

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of

Often when surveying the political landscape here in Washington, one can’t help but be struck by the feeling “is this the most important thing we have to discuss”?  That was my reaction to today’s Politico story on party differences with extending the payroll tax cut. 

The difference, as Politico would have us believe, are that Democrats want millionaires to pay, while Republicans want government employees to bear the costs.  It seems to be the case with whatever the issue is, who pays

Quite simply, this debate between Republicans and Democrats over who should bear the costs of government is completely misplaced.  We should be asking ourselves why the government has such a deep involvement in our lives in the first place.

If the government should not be involved in an activity, how is said activity any more just if its paid for by millionaires or the middle class.  

Would the fact that we have the largest prison population in the world somehow be more just if only more of the cost of it was borne by millionaires?  Would having our failed drug war funded solely by millionaires turn it into a success?  How about the U.S. playing world policeman?  Would we be more loved around the world if our military was funded more by millionaires?  Would we be viewed as honest brokers in the Middle East if our foreign aid was funded by millionaires?  Is having children struck in failing public schools more just if those schools are funded by millionaires?

Here’s my offer to both my Democrat and Republican friends, you let me decide what the size and scope of government is going to be, and I am happy to let you decide upon “who pays”.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member


Trending on Townhall Video