At issue was the dismissal early in 2001, the first year of the Bush administration, of Allen Stayman from a State Department post. The accounts alleged that he was sacked because he advocated improved labor conditions in the U.S.-owned Northern Marianas in the Western Pacific, whose government was represented by Abramoff. Nowhere was it mentioned that Stayman left a long paper trail of partisan Democratic activity and hardly could be expected to survive in a Republican administration.The attack on Mehlman typified the standard October surprise: information about an event years in the past distributed by a partisan operative as a campaign nears its close. The most successful recent example came in 2000, when Al Gore's campaign waited until the last week before the presidential election to release never before published information about a drunken driving conviction of young George W. Bush 24 years earlier. That throttled Bush's momentum and very nearly elected Gore.
October surprises have abounded this year. The revelation of Rep. Mark Foley's past improper advances to former congressional pages dominated the news for two weeks and stifled what had seemed to be a Republican upsurge. The subsequent disclosure of questionable land transactions and use of campaign funds by Senate Democratic Leader Harry Reid did not get nearly as much attention.
The reports about Reid did not begin to counter the Democratic national campaign theme of a climate of corruption under Republican rule in Washington. The Mehlman story, first reported in the Los Angeles Times Oct. 15, fits the image of Abramoff running rampant in the White House and winning governmental action for his clients with favors for presidential aides.
The not so hidden hand promoting this story is the fiercely partisan Rep. Henry Waxman, ranking Democrat on the House Government Reform Committee. Waxman had talked Republican Chairman Tom Davis into a pre-election release showing over 400 contacts at the White House by Abramoff. E-mails by the Abramoff lobbying operation claimed credit for getting Mehlman, then White House political director, to sack Stayman. Waxman suggested that Mehlman has "violated fundamental ethics regulations and the law."