Jonah Goldberg
Recommend this article

John Edwards, when he wasn't fixing his hair or cheating on his wife, liked to talk about "two Americas." In one America, things were pretty bad, somewhere between "The Grapes of Wrath" and Thunderdome. In the other America, where Edwards himself lived in a McMansion, things were going swimmingly.

Edwards was hardly the only one to use this two-Americas formulation. It's been a popular talking point for years. Socialist intellectual Michael Harrington helped to inspire the Great Society with his book, "The Other America."

Sean Hannity FREE

As serious analysis, this bifocal vision of America has always left me cold. The American economy is too dynamic, the American people too optimistic, to talk so glibly about haves and have-nots as permanent classes, the way French aristocrats talked about the peasants. More than half the people in the poorest 20 percent pull themselves out of it within a decade. Moreover, it's all based on a kind of class envy that has never flourished in the U.S. the way it has elsewhere.

But it's certainly fair to say that our political leaders believe in two different Americas. They even believe in two different Constitutions.

Democrats insist that health care is a "right." It's that conviction more than anything else that is driving their push for ObamaCare.

The notion that health care is a right is an old one, with deep roots in socialist and progressive thought. It achieved its highest expression in FDR's 1944 address to Congress. The president insisted that the old Bill of Rights had run its course, and the new industrial age required new rights. These rights included a guaranteed good job, a good home and, naturally, good medical care.

"Necessitous men are not free men," FDR insisted.

Roosevelt said that opposition to this sweeping transformation of America made you a fascist. If "history were to repeat itself and we were to return to the so-called 'normalcy' of the 1920's, then it is certain that even though we shall have conquered our enemies on the battlefields abroad, we shall have yielded to the spirit of Fascism here at home."

Keep in mind that the 1920s was a decade of roaring economic growth. The return to "normalcy" FDR referred to was the return to a more limited form of government (not counting Prohibition). The Republicans released Woodrow Wilson's political prisoners. They shuttered the Democrats' propaganda ministry (the Committee for Public Information). They called off the censorship and the "war socialism" of the Wilson years. And they helped usher in roaring economic growth.

Recommend this article

Jonah Goldberg

Jonah Goldberg is editor-at-large of National Review Online,and the author of the forthcoming book The Tyranny of Clichés. You can reach him via Twitter @JonahNRO.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Jonah Goldberg's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.