Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, September 17, 2008
Michelle Malkin :: Townhall.com Columnist
The Book Banners Hollywood Ignores
by Michelle Malkin
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


Have you ever heard Hollywood liberals talk about suspected Islamic jihadists the way they talk about suspected Republican "book-banners"? The September 11 terrorist attacks didn't turn celebrity leftists into hawks. But the minute they started reading false rumors about Sarah Palin restricting unfettered access to "Daddy's Roommate" and "Heather Has Two Mommies" in her hometown library, Tinseltown's docile doves became militant warmongers.

Actor Matt Damon, parroting left-wing Internet lies about Sarah Palin censoring novels while mayor of Wasilla, Alaska, took a defiant stand against the "terrifying possibility" of a McCain-Palin victory. "We can't have" book-banning, he inveighed.

And now we know what keeps feminist playwrights like Eve Ensler ("The Vagina Monologues") awake at night. Not Iranian nuclear ambitions or al Qaeda beheading videos. She is haunted by nightmares of Bible-thumping, book-burning Sarah Palin. A McCain/Palin ticket "is one of the most dangerous choices" of her lifetime, Ensler seethed in her viral call-to-arms e-mail, because "Sarah Palin does not much believe in thinking," The evidence: "From what I gather she has tried to ban books from the library, has a tendency to dispense with people who think independently. She cannot tolerate an environment of ambiguity and difference."

Classic projection. Damon, Ensler and the anti-censorship crusaders are the unthinking ones who can't tolerate independence, ambiguity and difference. The rumormongers continue to spread a bogus banned book list attributed to Palin that includes books not even published at the time she served as mayor. No city records corroborate Internet reports that she tried to keep anti-homosexual books, as gay lobbying organizations have claimed, or any other books off government-funded library shelves available to children.

And even if she did inquire about the process, so what? Regulating age-appropriate content is only alarming to the same kind of civil liberties extremists who oppose reasonable filtering of sexually explicit material in public spaces Who is scarier: hockey moms who want to put tax-subsidized books about lesbian couples out of reach of kindergarteners or Hollyweird ideologues who want to ensure that homeless people can surf porn websites in your neighborhood library?

If book banning is such a life-and-death issue to these celebrity foot soldiers for free speech, where were they four years ago when John Kerry and his rabid minions were pressuring Regnery Publishing to withdraw "Unfit for Command" from bookstores? Where were they when members of the Borders Books Employee Union were openly advocating sabotaging book sales? A message on the union's members-only website urged:

"You guys don't actually HAVE to sell the thing!

"Just 'carelessly' hide the boxes, 'accidentally' drop them off pallets, 'forget' to stock the ones you have, and then suggest a nice Al Franken or Michael Moore book as a substitute ...

"I don't care if these Neandertals (sic) in fancy suits get mad at me, they aren't regular customers anyway. Other than 'Left Behind' books, they don't read. Anything you can do to make them feel unwelcome is only fair. They are the people pushing retailers to cut costs, don't forget. And they would censor your speech, your books, your music in a heartbeat, so give them a taste of it!"

Where were they when left-wing hitman David Brock of Media Matters for America sent a demand letter to Wal-Mart, Amazon.com and Barnes & Noble urging them to pull "Unfit for Command" from their shelves?

Where were they two years ago when two Democrat lawmakers, New Jersey Assemblywomen Joan Quigley and Linda Stender, called on merchants to ban the sale of Ann Coulter's book, "Godless," because of her remarks about anti-Bush 9/11 widows. "No one in New Jersey should buy this book and allow Ann Coulter to profit from her hate-mongering," the politicians lashed out. "We are asking New Jersey retailers statewide to stand with us and express their outrage by refusing to carry or sell copies of Coulter's book. Her hate-filled attacks on our 9-11 widows has no place on New Jersey bookshelves."

Where were they in 2005, when a University of North Carolina law professor, Eric Muller, called on his blog readers to get one of my books banned from a national parks bookstore? Where were they when J. Millard Burr and Robert O. Collins's "Alms for Jihad" was banned in Britain; Robert Spencer's "The Truth about Muhammad" was banned in Pakistan; and "The Jewel of Madina" was banned, well, everywhere?

And where are they now? Stewing in their salons and screenwriting rooms. Concocting horror stories about terrifying Christian conservative bogeymen who threaten peace, tolerance, independent thought, ambiguity and difference. Patting themselves and each other on the backs as the valiant protectors of dissent.

(But only the kind with which they agree, of course. Shhhhh.)

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Michelle Malkin makes news and waves with a unique combination of investigative journalism and incisive commentary. She is the author of Unhinged: Exposing Liberals Gone Wild .

Be the first to read Michelle Malkin's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

©Creators Syndicate
Dems = Anti-American
Anti Christian, anti-morality. The progressives are scary race-baiting morons. Intolerant, and cannot stand that a conservative woman may become our Vice President.
Bets on how many celebs promise to move if Obama loses?

Michelle - Good Stuff!

Thanks, for all you do in exposing the Left in their ongoing duplicity.

Upland
Okay, I'll bite, I say at least Babs Streisand, Alec Baldwin, Damon, Sarandon, Robbins, Meathead, Roberts, Penn, Dicaprio.... 9 so far. I'm sure that's just the tip.

Classic Projection
When the lib/leftists are squawking about a particular practice, tactic or act, you can bet your bottom C-Note it's exactly what they are doing. Sometimes it's jinned-up to pre-empt the charge against them.

BTW, Matt Damon is so stupid, he shouldn't open his yap to say one word that isn't written for him. On second thought, his yapping does reflect what his lib controllers have scripted for him.

But he's a man of influence - not. What a maroon...

Great column, Michele - keep up the spirited Palin defense!

yankette & Upland
Don't hold your breath. We could not get that lucky. Besides, they wouldn't spend THEIR money to move anyway.


BTW all, how's Charlie Rangel doing with his latest tax problems? How many want to bet that he gets off of any charges since he is a flaming libtard?

Obama Stifles Free Speech
Obama texted Chicago-area supporters Monday telling them to subvert the talk on a WGN radio show that night which featured one of the people who wrote a book against Obama.

That is a taste of how Americans will not be allowed to dissent during his wannabe Presidency.

And all this dissenting about conservative books?

Puh-lease!

And as far as being able to read? All four members of my family have a Bachelor's Degree, and, in addition, one has an AAS, one has a CLU, and one has a Master's Degree.

Go, Michele!

McCain and Palin in 2008!

Celebs:Moving out of country
Oh,if only they would keep their word!

Yankette and Upland Patriot
Along with the 9 already mentioned... any chance that THE celeb HIMself will move too.

Just wishin'. They seem to love him so across the water.

Michelle's wrong again
You really ought to check facts and quotes before you write. And what's with that hair? Sort of stuck in the '80's.

There are some of us
who are willing to donate for the celebrity moving fund just to get them out of here. It's getting wearisome hearing them talk about it for years, but never really move. How about giving them a little row boat ride to Cuba? I'm sure they would all love it there.

Book Banners
Michelle, I love you. If that chap you're living with treats you badly, please let me know.

I wonder.

If someone wrote a very accurate and detailed book on "How to Kill Your Mother," would the lefties want that on the reading list of a school kid?

Book burning
I believe that banning books is tattimount to burning them, but we shouldn't consider that any book is appropriate for all ages. Liberals would have us believe that only their viewpoint is valid, and we shouldn't allow anyone to speak against them. Anyone know what happens when only one view point is allowed to be discussed in public??? Communism.

Xerxes
Ok Xerxes, you tell us where she was wrong and where we can go to verify your claim. I want just the facts. It's easy to say she's wrong when you don't cite any references to the contrary.

Jim
LOL! I'm sure that would be just fine with the libs, "How to Kill Your Mother". They would find some reason for it to be age appropriate and other reasons why a kid might have to kill their mother.

Jim
There you go again. Grace Kelly! She was my favorite beauty Hollywood star. Nothing like her today. And, I just watched Rear Window the other night. Such a classic.

And Sarah Palin's hair is just fine. I like the way her hair doesn't look like she had a $400 haircut. Her hair looks natural like most of us women out here in average America.

the book banners hollywood ignores
I wonder if Matt Damon and his ilk have ever considered dining at the local garbage dump for stilling their bodily hunger and if not, why not? Yet, they really expect us to dine at a local library dump and feast on the mountain of garbage for our minds?

I give them the bennefit of the doubt that they know, body and mind need to be fed good food to flourish. What I have seen in public libraries lately is everything else but that.

Besides, what is so sacred about books, garbage is garbage and ought to be thrown on the local garbage dump. Come to think of, that is true for computers, maybe they are smarter than we are????

Not much has changed
William Tyndale, who was the first to translate the Bible from the orginal Greek and Hebrew into "modern" English was executed for Heresy because he wanted the masses to be able to read the Bible for themselves. We again face the "censors" who would ban the Bible, and have done that already in schools. Ironic that the church fathers who did not want the masses to have the Bible in English are in agreement with the current "secular" church fathers who do not want the masses to read the Bible. The Bible has freed more people on this planet than other written work.

Every tyrannical power on the planet has always put the Bible on the top of the banned list. There IS a reason for that.

Total Control
Liberals don't think they are advocating total control of our lives, but if you look at their speeches and actions that is exactly the result. If Liberals had their way conservatism would be banned. I'm not kidding.

7sticks...
.... you may not care if Jimmy cracks porn in a public library. But, others at the library... or, Jimmy's parents, actually MAY care. Therefore, if you want to surf porn, do it at your own house or at a private place, not in a public library.

And, to those that say that it's wrong to ban ANY books... I agree and disagree. I don't like book-banning; but, it depends on the potential audience. It's necessary to draw lines. For example, I don't want my (hypothetical) 8-year old child to be able to walk into a Blockbuster and rent hardcore pornography.

'Farenheit Sarah'


Increasing numbers of hypothalamus' apparently getting scorched and torched in Hollywood and the 92 St. "Y" because of 'Sister Palin'.

It's not just books however is it?

Remember the hysteria over Mel Gibson's
"Passion of the Christ"?

Hey, a movie about the brutality of the crucifixion by a Director that had made, "We Were Soldiers."
He made soldiers in Vietnam appear noble and showed Christ to suffer. "Oh fie, fie". Ban, shun, whisper, denigrate, rail and salivate. How dare he try to do that and have it succeed?

Succeed however they do. Just like "Unfit for Command" did. Oh, how it did succeed.

Let them fry around the collar. Their rage creates anti-bodies.

Susan Sontag was lambasted for her observation that "Communism is Fascism." Well, EL Doctorow may have called up the troops to scorn Ms. Sontag, but we know her statement to be truth and a truth writ large for our time as well.

Their rage is our warning.


Ranger 29
You have went down in flames all over TH for pasting your fantasy militairy claims. I have watched posters clean your clock on your claims time and time again. You do not learn. If you had any shame you would give it up. Wobbie the fake.

If you have a comment, fine. Dispense with your phony military stuff, or we can start doing some cut and paste stuff I saved on you the last couple of months when you were outed as a fake.

Anyway Ranger 29, thanks for the amusement.

DePeReCa
Democratic Peoples' Republic of California -
our dopey "stars" already live in a 3rd world country...and vote like it.

Synonym for Progressive and Liberal
Communist. Good article Michelle. The Progreliberommunists continue trying to squash free speech and otherwise detract from the Bill of Rights by any means necessary.

Anderson659
Hay man, I thought Ranger29 sounded familiar. He is a fake military member.

I remember him from last year. I just came back from Kuwait, and I find him still plying his droll.

Michelle is right about the liberals as usual.

How much FREE speech...
...was at that Obama gala in Hollywood last night? $28,000 dollars bought a piece of Obama's FREE speech. I wonder if the Obama let loose with any of that religion clinging gun toting FREE speech like he did in Frisco at that gala FREE speech event several months ago.

Pants, Not Books On Fire

The Lefties are a bunch of big liars. It is time to stop giving them the benefit of the doubt. They make up a bunch of lies out of whole cloth, pass them around as talking points, and repeat them as if they are in an echo chamber.

It is funnier when you get one of the room temp IQ seminar callers that does not even understand the talking points that he is spouting.

Or it would be funnier if it wasn't so scary

Oh well, if you don't laugh, you cry.

Another one of those
Palin rumors spread by the astroturfing crowd setup by the Obama campaign that proved without any foundation whatsoever.

I am against censurship in general but if a community wishes to bann screening of pornagraphy on the computers in their library that is fine with me. State law here REQUIRES a filter program on library computers.

What I would be against is requiring screens on ALL computers, public or private. If you wish to acess internet porn at home that is fine with me, but the public should not have to pay for you to access internet porn.

Useful idiots
The liberals' campaign to destroy Palin has nothing to do with principle and everything to do about gaining power. The joke on most of them is that the power they will have, should their hero become president, will only be vicarious and ephemeral to boot. The "useful idiots" as Lenin so aptly characterized them, will be discarded once the demothugs get back to the trough.


Chappaquiddick movie coming any Decade
Hollywood is totally even handed.

A Chappaquiddick movie will likely be out in just a few more Decades (say 10 or 20).

And it was by clerical error that when "Senatorial privilege" about the incident was on the Best Seller list, the Boston paper shortened the list they published sufficiently to exclude it.

Remember Rush's books?
BOTH of Rush's books BROKE SALES RECORDS in hardcover AND paperback. They both topped the NY Times bestseller list for weeks and stayed in the top ten for months. The bookstore trolls tried to hide them, "lose" them and berated any buyer who asked for them. They still took off like skyrockets!

Last check Nancy Pelosi's turd of a tome has sold 2 thousand copies. Don't worry Nan, the unions will buy them all up and put them in a warehouse just like Jim Wright's book.

-Ray
NRA Life Member

Hollywood
It is better to keep your mouth shut and let people think you are stupid than to open it and remove all doubt. Or something like that.


Banned books
Look in your local elementary school library for
The Bobbsey Twins
Huckleberry Finn
Aesop's Fables
The Book of Virtues
or any of
The Childhoods of Famous Americans
Actually, try finding any honest history book.
All horrible books that have banned by liberals.

So, what does this mean?
So, does this mean that after January 20th George W. Bush will no longer have been the worst President in history?

Seriously, are we going to have to listen to this every four years any time we have a potential President or Vice President to the political right of Vladimir Ilyich Ulyanov?

Note to Hollywood: Shut up and act.

Great Article Michelle
You are one of the pundits I am never disappointed in.

Re: banning books. I am a firm believer in the local citizenry of any municipality having a say in what books (or computer websites) can be accessed by minors at the library. But there should be no banning of any books on the retail market. Let the free market decide what sells.

Liberals Dont' Believe
It obvious the liberal left does not believe their own B.S. Unless it fits their agenda. then they will try to destroy you with character assassinations, and lies. I have found that best way to handle a liberal is not to listen to what they say or even acknowledge their existence, but express yourself beyond their rants and raves. They don't want to hear what you have to say or write. So one needs to ignore them and use your first amendment rights and express ones view point.

Gee, liberals are hypocrites....
What a surprise!

redmanrt
Everything the Left does is for power. They have no principles on which to base anything. Everything they want is about more control in your lives: what you can and cannot say, how you can and cannot worship, where you can and cannot live, how you can and cannot transport yourself from point A to point B, and so forth. This is no different.

The Left follows the Henry Ford mantra about the color of the Model T: "Any color's fine, so long as it's black."

Wrat Wrangler
It has long been my suspicion that Demoncrap book sales are nothing more than a method of funneling bribes to them. Why else would a publisher pay hundreds of thousands in advances for a book that will not sell enough to even pay for it’s printing costs.

What I would like to see is an investigation that included an audit of the books of some of these publishers to track the money.

What are the odds of that happening?

LMAO
I love it when you whine. Guess what we never said we were perfect that is the conservatives' claim as they allow economic meltdown, devastated cities, endless war, illegal immigrants, abortions, shall I go on and on? Guess what there are no perfect solutiopns or answers but there are good ones to bad conservatives are unable to find them. Now you have two candidates who lie freely and expect America to vote for them LOL.

mrbmrb are you really Cameron Diaz?
I still laugh when I think about the ignorant woman weeping and talking blather on Oprah (before I boycotted that show). She was babbling about how rape might become legalized in America if people didn't vote for Kerry. Too many bright lights and not enough real book learning in that lady's life. Her and the rest of the self-proclaimed Hollywood political pundits are too busy being captivated by liberal histrionics. You see, feelings seem to drive liberals more than facts. If it feels right, it must be right.

Fear-mongering
I find the Christian Taliban in this country more threatening than al Qaeda and Iran.

Oh yeah- I love the "tolerance" of Upland Patriot calling all Democrats "anti-American, anti-Christian, anti-morality...scary race-baiting morons." Gosh, the worst thing I would say (in writing) about SOME Republicans is that they're bigoted, clueless, and totally uninformed.

Linda
I don't know how old you are but if you did not experience the 60s and 70s, you have no idea how Taliban-like the radical left is. Words are easy to throw around (which of course I am doing here), but if you really want to engage us in intelligent debate, why don't you give us a few examples of what you say is "threatening" from the Christian right. I have never experienced the right using Taliban tactics like I have the radical left during those years. Back then if you did not adhere to the left's agenda you were marginalized by them and dismissed as stupid, ignorant, shallow, uncaring, and backwards.

Hal Doofus Rides Again 7:05am
"Now you have two candidates who lie freely and expect America to vote for them LOL. "

That would be Obama and Biden.

Thanks for agreeing with Conservatives Hal Doofus.

LAUGH MY A*S OFF!