Kamala's Deputy Campaign Manager Explains Why There Wasn't an Open Primary. Get Ready...
Was It Appropriate for a CNN Guest to Spill This New Theory About...
Does Trump Have His ATF Nominee Lined Up?
Village People Founding Member: Yes, I'd Consider Performing 'YMCA' at Trump's Inauguratio...
Trump Administration Energy Policy Imperatives
Trump Doubles Down On His Support for Pete Hegseth
World Leaders Line Up to Meet Trump
New Poll Finds Joe Biden’s Legacy to Be In the Toilet
WH Press Secretary Mocked for Using Wrong Poll to Justify Hunter Biden Pardon
Biden-Harris Makes First Ever Climate-Change Related Arrest
Remember How Kamala Harris Spent Six Figures on a Fake Set for the...
Deadly Venezuelan Gang Invades Another State
Eric Adams Won't Rule Out Joining the GOP
One Story That Says It All
Thanks to the Elites, College Is Now a Costly Path to Nowhere
Tipsheet

Spanish High Court Rules Pandemic Lockdown Unconstitutional

AP Photo/Paul White

The first Wuhan coronavirus lockdown imposed by the government of Spain was ruled unconstitutional by the Spanish Constitutional Court, in a 6-5 ruling on Wednesday.

Advertisement

The ruling, which came in response to a suit brought by the right-wing Vox Party, found that the lockdown’s “limitations on movement” had violated the fundamental liberties of Spanish citizens. Therefore, the court said, the “state of alarm” order issued by Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez was insufficient and not protected by Spain’s national constitution.

Attorneys for the Vox Party had argued that any enforcement of Sánchez’s restrictions would have required a “state of exception” order, which is essentially a more expansive state of alarm that requires parliamentary approval instead of just the prime minister’s cabinet.

In a statement, the Court said that the ruling “annulled by a simple majority some articles of the state of emergency decree related to free movement of citizens.” Its complete ruling has not yet been publicized but will likely be released in the coming days.

Sánchez issued his state of alarm order on March 14, 2020, as Wuhan coronavirus cases spiked across Spain. Under the order, which was just the second of its kind since Spain transitioned to democratic rule in 1978, most citizens were only permitted to leave their homes for essential shopping or medical trips.

Advertisement

After 98 days of one of Europe’s strictest lockdowns, Sánchez’s order was lifted on June 20, 2020, paving the way for Spain to transition to an era of “new normal” with relaxed restrictions. But as cases continue to spike among young Spaniards, local governments are pushing for a return to many of the restrictions.

In the region of Valencia on Monday, a court authorized the return of a 10-person limit on gatherings, as well as a 1 a.m. curfew in 32 “high-risk” towns that had recorded significant outbreaks. And also on Monday, officials in the region of Catalonia enacted a 12:30 A.M. curfew, capacity restrictions for nightclubs, and a ban on eating and drinking in the streets.

The ruling of Spain’s highest court is likely to provide a legal pedestal for anti-restriction cases in the near future. Roughly 51 percent of the country is fully vaccinated, and vaccination rates are both steadily increasing and, ironically, generally greater in the urban areas that have enacted the new restrictions.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement