Mitt: 'Without Romneycare, I Don't Think We Would Have Obamacare'

Matt Vespa
|
Posted: Oct 25, 2015 6:00 PM
Mitt: 'Without Romneycare, I Don't Think We Would Have Obamacare'

Last Friday, Thomas Stemberg, the co-founder of Staples Inc., passed away two years after he was diagnosed with gastric cancer. The Boston Globe reported that Mitt Romney, then working for Bain Capital, fronted the cash for Staples’ first store in Brighton, Massachusetts in 1986. The success of Staples and Stemberg was an integral part of Romney’s personal and business career, often using the rise of the office supplies giant as an anecdote to boost his job creating credentials. Then again, Romney also let slip the number one reason why conservatives were skeptical of his 2012 candidacy [emphasis mine]:

The success of Staples became an oft-mentioned business story that Romney told on the campaign trail as he ran for US Senate, Massachusetts governor, and twice for president.

In 2012, Mr. Stemberg spoke at the Republican National Convention in Tampa, trumpeting his friend Romney’s contributions to his business dream.

Romney also credited Mr. Stemberg with persuading him to push for health care reform in Massachusetts when he was governor.

Romney recalled that shortly after he was elected, Mr. Stemberg asked him why he ran for governor. Romney said he wanted to help people, and Mr. Stemberg replied that if he really wanted to help, he should give everyone access to health care, which Romney said he hadn’t really considered before.

Without Tom pushing it, I don’t think we would have had Romneycare,” Romney said. “Without Romneycare, I don’t think we would have Obamacare. So without Tom, a lot of people wouldn’t have health insurance.”

Romney’s spokeswoman tried to smooth over these remarks (via CNN):

"(Obamacare) drove up premiums, took insurance away from people who were promised otherwise, and usurped state programs. As I said in the campaign, I'd repeal it and replace it with state-crafted plans," Romney said.

As for his comment about his friend, Romney said, "Getting people health insurance is a good thing, and that's what Tom Stemberg fought for."

This waffled line represents one of the most frustrating aspects of the 2012 election. Romney, whether we like it or not, was our best candidate. Obama was eminently beatable, but Mitt’s inability to escape his health care policy past left him at odds with conservatives (for the most part). He was the only person where we couldn’t talk about health care without Obama’s campaign bringing up the fact that a) Romneycare was the blueprint for Obamacare b) Romney had previously campaigned that we should take Romneycare nationwide.

In 2012, The Federalist’s Ben Domenech noted how Romneycare was an abject failure. At the time, he said the state was spending more on health care per capita than anywhere else in the industrialized world, and that by 2020–health care would make up more than 50 percent of the state’s budget.

Domenech added that Romneycare drove up premiums, an admission by Mitt’s own advisers, and it went over budget. That point is more disconcerting, and something that undercuts the state-based approach talking point, since he said that within a few years of this program becoming a budget buster, Romney’s successor, Deval Patrick, came down to Washington to ask for more money; he got $4.3 billion more than he had asked from federal taxpayers. Romney may have been speaking fondly of his friend, but he also showed how Romneycare was an albatross around his neck in 2012.