Zohran Mamdani, the socialist mayor of New York City, has proudly touted a steep drop in violent crime during his administration. His allies have seized on the numbers as proof that socialism works on public safety, despite the fact that the decline was already put in motion under former Mayor Eric Adams.
But the story has become more complicated than Mamdani’s victory lap suggests. An analysis from the Manhattan Institute's City Journal found that the city’s crime picture is far less rosy once you look beyond just the murder rate. Homicides may be down, but nearly every other category of crime has risen.
These numbers are striking - murders in NYC dropped 19%, but car theft went up 144%. Murders are pretty much the only crime that dropped.
— City Journal (@CityJournal) August 27, 2026
Why?
A relatively small group of people commit the overwhelming majority of murders. NYC got them off the street.
Targeted policing works. https://t.co/lPk3RAwCpg pic.twitter.com/19Gj5a6YpL
According to the analysis, murder may have fallen by 19 percent and shootings by 15 percent. But that is where Mamdani’s success story largely ends. Car theft is up an astounding 144 percent. Felony assaults have risen by nearly 50 percent, while major felonies are up almost 25 percent. Misdemeanor assaults, robbery, grand larceny, and burglary have all increased between 5 and 10 percent.
In other words, New Yorkers may be less likely to be the victim of murder, but they are increasingly likely to be robbed, assaulted, burglarized, or have their car stolen.
As for why that is, Rafael A. Mangual, a fellow at the Manhattan Institute, argues the answer may once again lie in law-enforcement strategy.
NYPD is focused on the relatively small number of offenders most likely to commit serious violence, removing them from the streets and deterring others in their immediate networks. That approach can produce sharp reductions in murders and shootings, while doing far less to curb, or even allowing increases in lower-level offenses. In other words, the numbers may reflect targeted policing against the most dangerous offenders, not a socialist public-safety miracle.
My latest for the @CityJournal Substack explains why NYC is on pace to see record-low shootings and homicides while other crime categories remain elevated.
— Rafael A. Mangual (@Rafa_Mangual) August 26, 2026
Read it here: https://t.co/PzxRAO0PzZ pic.twitter.com/3MvYqiMc8z
Mamdani is eager to claim credit for a narrow drop in homicides, because the apparent success of his socialist worldview depends on it. But he cannot credibly call his public-safety agenda a success while so many other crimes are rising. As is usual of socialists, Mayor Mamdani has succeeded in one thing, and one thing only: raising taxes on the wealthy, effectively whipping up a frenzy of resentment toward the rich nationwide.
🚨🇺🇸 BREAKING — Mayor Mamdani:
— Pamphlets (@PamphletsY) July 28, 2026
"NYC Hit Lowest-Ever Recorded Murder Rate." pic.twitter.com/nH0xKtBtnU
Editor’s Note: New York City is now facing the consequences of Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s socialist takeover.
Help us continue to report on his radical policies and expose the Democrats who support him. Join Townhall VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Join the Conversation
VIP members get the ability to comment on articles.