In September, David J. Bier of the Cato Institute made the ridiculous argument before Congress that having tough immigration laws leads to illegal immigration. No, he really did.
"Our immigrant coworkers, neighbors, friends, and family want to contribute to this country legally," Bier said. "Let them. Fix legal immigration."
"Imagine if just three percent of gun sales were permitted," he continued. "Many in this room, myself included, would call that gun prohibition. But that's how few immigrants seeking permanent legal status in the United States through the proper processes actually get approved in a year."
The difference, of course, is that gun ownership is a Constitutional right. Despite what David and the Left will argue, immigrating to America is not. Especially not if you hail from a culture that is diametrically opposed to American and Western values. Earlier today, I wrote about how the Tren de Aragua gang is using malware to steal millions from ATMs around the country, including a bank that's within walking distance of my house. Under David's line of thinking, because the bank didn't hand TdA a sack of cash, they welcomed the robbery.
But David isn't the only one at Cato to have a hot take on immigration. Alex Nowrasteh had this to say about borders:
Borders are supposed to keep other governments out, not other people.
— The Alex Nowrasteh (@AlexNowrasteh) November 15, 2026
What do you think other governments are, if not people? What sort of statement is this?
We have a vested interest in keeping the vast majority of the world out, as I and my colleagues have noted. In another piece I wrote today, a Muslim preacher in Austin is praying to his congregation for Allah to help find and kill infidels. Another imam in Texas goes around demanding stores stop selling liquor, pork, and lottery tickets — all things that are haram in Islam. In Dearborn, the Islamic call to prayer rings out at all hours; Hamtramck voted to bar the Pride flag from public display.
In September, a watchdog group found tons of vetting errors with migrants who came to this country after the Biden administration botched our withdrawal from Afghanistan. One of those migrants, Rahmunalla Lakanwal, gunned down Spec. Sarah Beckstrom, 20, and Staff Stg. Andrew Wolfe on a Washington, D.C., street last November, just days before Thanksgiving. Beckstrom died; she was 20 years old. But Lakanwal wasn't the only one with problems. Luqmaan Kahn was arrested for plotting a mass shooting; Jaan Shah Safi was arrested for providing support to ISIS-K; Mohammad Dawood Alokozay plotted to bomb targets in Fort Worth, Texas; and Nazira Haji Zada was deported over her role in an ISIS-inspired plot to carry out a mass shooting on Election Day in 2024.
Two years ago, more Chinese nationals were encountered at the southern border near San Diego than Mexicans. Some 21,000 Chinese nationals were encountered, and that number had been surging since 2021. The majority of Chinese crossing our border illegally are single adults of military age. They're not here to enrich our culture, I fear. In 2023, an illegal Chinese bio lab was found in California, operating in secret and dealing with numerous infectious agents, including HIV, hepatitis, and herpes. A Chinese national was arrested in April for allegedly photographing military aircraft at a Nebraskan Air Force base. Last December, a Chinese national was busted smuggling E. coli bacteria into the country, and in June of last year, two others were arrested for smuggling Fusarium graminearum, a pathogen that causes foodborne diseases that are toxic to humans and animals.
Over the course of the Biden administration, illegal aliens were given billions of American tax dollars in benefits, including housing and food, including FEMA funds meant for natural disaster relief for Americans. That meant that after hurricanes hit North Carolina, Americans who lost their homes were kicked out of hotels in the dead of winter because there just wasn't money for them.
The notion that borders aren't meant to keep these people out is, in a word, laughable. But Nowrasteh doubled down, blaming the criticism on "bots."
Lot of bots are replying to this with non-sequiturs like “what about criminals?”, “take the doors off your house,” and comments on my physiognomy.
— The Alex Nowrasteh (@AlexNowrasteh) November 18, 2026
Every single time someone says something stupid on X and then gets called out for it, they hide behind this argument. It's as tiresome as it is stupid. If you showed up at Nowrasteh's house and broke in, I doubt telling police you did so because he locked his doors and made it hard for you to enter would go over well.
The comparison to doors is correct — you put doors on your home to keep other people out. We put up borders to keep other people out, not just their governments. It is in our national interest to do so. And more to the point: governments are the product of their people.
Somalia is facing another famine not because we cut USAID dollars. It's because the Somali population voted for corrupt, ineffective "leaders." Haiti is a dumpster fire because gangs run the nation unchecked – or they did until they messed with El Salvador and Nayib Bukele wasn't having it. We do not have to import to America the same people who were incapable of bringing prosperity, safety, and law and order to their own nations. They'll bring the same failed policies and failed cultural norms here — as we're seeing in Michigan and Austin and elsewhere.