Operation Twist

Morgan Brittany
|
Posted: Sep 22, 2011 12:01 AM

The Federal Open Market Committee adopted a drawn-out Operation Twist. The same three regional Fed Presidents dissented at this meeting as did at the previous meeting – Fisher, Plosser and Kocherlakota.

The Fed cited more evidence of a weakening economy and global strains.  We think this, more than its portfolio rebalancing, explains the decline in equities and in bond yields following the announcement.

The FOMC decided to buy $400 billion more in 6 to 30 year Treasury bonds, but will spread the purchases through June 2012.  It will pay for them by selling Treasuries with maturities of up to 3 years.

This will shorten the effective maturity of the U.S. national debt (the maturity of the consolidated Treasury and Fed holdings).  Treasury has been gradually lengthening its issuance.  If continued, this will counteract some of the Fed’s purchases, especially since the Fed is buying slowly.

In addition, as the Fed’s mortgage backed securities mature (conventional MBS guaranteed by Fannie and Freddie), the Fed will switch to reinvesting its maturing MBS in MBS rather than Treasuries. 

We don’t think the Fed’s total assets or excess reserves will change much as a result of the announcement.   In effect, the Fed is running a leveraged SIV (structured investment vehicle), borrowing short-term at 25 basis points to finance long-term bonds yielding more.  This is very profitable for the Fed as long as interest rates stay low.  We expect the Fed to generate in excess of $100 billion in profit per year under current policies, which it turns over to the Treasury Department less expenses.  The cost is born by savers earning negative real interest rates. 

Implications

By expanding its purchases to mortgage bonds, the Fed is emphasizing the importance of mortgage rates in its policy.  We don’t think this change was priced into markets, and we expect it to push conventional MBS yields and, with a short lag, mortgage rates even lower.  

However, we think the FOMC’s schedule for purchasing long-maturity Treasuries is slower than market expectations, dulling any impact.  Though Treasury bond yields fell today after the announcement, we think this is mostly in response to the Fed’s view of the economy, not the Fed’s bond announcement.

Bottom line: We don’t expect today’s announcements to improve the outlook.  European developments are more important.  They continue to be negative, with Italian bond yields rising again.  


John Ransom | Create Your Badge

See more top stories from Townhall Finance. New Homepage, more content. Be the best informed fiscal conservative:

John Ransom Obama Creates Chicago Solution to Chicago Problem at Solyndra
Political Calculations The Guess What's the Biggest Driver of U.S. Government Revenue?
David Malpass Operation Twist
Bob Beauprez Fraud Charges Floating for Obama Administration
George Friedman Obama's Dilemma: U.S. Foreign Policy and Electoral Realities
Bob Goldman Alphas of The World, Unite
Jeff Carter Fed Makes Us Twist
Mike Shedlock Three Worst States to Conduct Business: California, New York, Illinois
Email Ransom thfinance@mail.com
Twitter http://twitter.com/#!/bamransom