Let Your Rabid Leftist Friends And Family Go
The Holiday Survival Guide (Trump WON Edition)
New York Democrat Issues Warning to His Party About Hochul
A Quick Bible Study Vol. 243: What the New Testament Says About Fearing...
Avoiding Self-Inflicted Trade and Economic Wounds
Dems Ramp Up Criticism of Tulsi Gabbard
Why We Should Be Concerned Over the Philippine VP’s Comments
These Democratic Senators Could Sure Be in Trouble After Voting for Sanders' Anti-Israel...
Top Democrat Leader Obliterates The View’s Reasoning for Why Trump Won
Joe Rogan, Elon Musk Hilariously Spark Exchange On X Over Failing MSNBC
Matt Gaetz for Florida Governor?
Trump to Create New Position to Deal With Ukraine
Giving Thanks Is Good For You
The Hidden Pro-Life Message You Missed at Miss Universe
The Border's Broken Vetting System: Why We Can't Wait to Fix It
OPINION

Enacting Price Controls to Address Surprise Medical Bills Will Crush Independent Doctors and Harm Patients

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
spukkato/iStock/Getty Images Plus

Independent physicians haven’t fared well in recent years. Obamacare’s high administrative burdens, along with added financial incentives favoring consolidation, devastated independent practices. As a result, the number of independent physicians fell from 62% in 2008 to 35% by 2014. Unfortunately, rather than remedy the damage federal policymakers have done to private practices, they are considering new proposals, this time to address surprise medical bills, that could prove the final nail in the coffin of independent practices.

Advertisement

Long the cornerstone of the American medical system, independent practices provide a high volume of care at lower costs, and produce better patient outcomes, compared to hospitals or large medical groups. The doctor-patient relationship is strongest in private practices where doctors have greater freedom to tailor treatments according to individual patient needs.

Obamacare created incentives for consolidation with the intention of shifting financial risk away from government programs onto doctors. The steep decline in independent practitioners is the result. Among other things, this means less local competition, which studies show results in higher prices and worse healthcare for patients.

The disturbing trend away from independent doctors will only get worse if Congress pushes through legislation to address surprise medical bills based on the flawed approach of imposing price controls.

There is widespread agreement that surprise medical bills, where an insured patient receives an unexpected bill for healthcare services, are a growing problem that needs a legislative fix. One study reports an increase in hospital visits resulting in a surprise bill from 32% in 2010 to 43% in 2016, with the average cost rising from $220 to $628 over the same period though in the most egregious cases they can run into the tens of thousands.

Advertisement

There’s less agreement over what to do about the problem. Insurers are pushing hard for rate-setting, which would put the government in charge of deciding what is to be paid for each procedure and force doctors to accept network rates even if they haven’t contracted with a particular insurer. This would discourage network building, while another proposed solution called benchmarking, or setting the payment based on a local average of networked rates, gives insurers an incentive to narrow networks in hopes of manipulating the rate in their favor.

These are bad ideas for those market-distorting reasons alone. But the fact that independent practitioners would suffer, despite not having substantial involvement in the problem of surprise bills that mostly result from emergency hospital visits, is especially troubling.

Health care markets don’t function well thanks to poorly designed government inventions. Price controls would make this problem worse and reward insurers for refusing to cover their customers’ treatments. It would also exacerbate negative trends that are harming patients by putting independent practitioners already struggling to cover the costs of regulatory burdens on life support.

Advertisement

Congress should step back and examine the issue more closely if this is the best it can come up with. Doing nothing is preferable to imposing price controls.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos