The Rosetta Stone language education company will take in almost $1.7 million from its contract with the Transportation Security Administration, serving over 28,000 TSA employees. But each of those employees has only completed an average 2.5 hours of learning with the program, according to the TSA.
That boils down to about $60 per employee, or $24 an hour for two and a half hours of lessons – a figure that is more than reasonable for professional instruction. The issue is whether those 2.5 hours are worth the cost. What linguistic knowledge is actually being imparted in that short a period of time, and why would tens of thousands of employees have a need for it?
TSA represents a fraction of a percent of the total government contracts held by Rosetta, meaning that these sorts of questions have a much larger scope. For example, the entirety of the U.S. Army has free access to Rosetta, with over a million people eligible to sign up. While the Army’s pricing could be significantly less than TSA’s pricing – perhaps just a few dollars a person – it still represents a major expense to the U.S. taxpayer.
“$24 an hour for language is not bad,” said Seton Motley, head of the nonprofit organization Less Government. “But the issue is how many people are doing it, and why are they doing it. It’s tough to imagine that 28,000 people in TSA would require language skills to complete their jobs.”
Pete Rumpel, the vice president of institutional markets at Rosetta Stone, couldn’t disagree more.
“From a cost standpoint, what we do is fantastic,” he said. “I think the bigger waste is the amount of money that gets poured into classroom training.”
That training, he said, can run from $2,000-$10,000 a head. Rumpel also disputed the original numbers provided by TSA about the cost and completion rates of their program, but declined to provide alternative numbers.
“Our goal is to develop a highly effective language learning program where every employee can engage and learn at their own pace, at a good price,” he said.
Other agencies that utilize Rosetta Stone, such as NASA, don’t even track the number of hours completed – they simply purchase a bulk of licenses without bothering to evaluate the completion rates. For example, NASA paid $54,000 for 400 one-year licenses, and has no record of any employee completing a single hour of training.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) had 10,000 of their employees use Rosetta. Information on cost was not readily available, and information on hours completed simply didn’t exist, said said Pat Reilly, at ICE’s public affairs office.
“Length of learning time is very subjective,” said Reilly.
Green Hypocrisy: CEO of Virgin Airlines Says Global Warming Skeptics Should ‘Get Out of Our Way’ | Leah Barkoukis