Last week Senator Warren proposed a bill to allow student loan interest rates to stay at artificially low levels of 3.4%, preventing them from doubling on July 1st of this year. This new bill has been met with much enthusiasm amongst the hard progressive left. As Senator Warren released the bill, she used her infamous early 20th century populist rhetoric to try and generate support from fellow left wing enthusiasts. Here is what she wrote on an online petition for Moveon.org:
"Wall Street banks—the ones that wrecked our economy—should not be getting a better interest rate on their government loans than young people trying to go to college."
To no one's surprise, Senator Warren tries to pit the banks against the students. She has repeatedly blamed big business and Wall Street for almost all of our economic perils. Putting aside her questionable arguments as to why we should equate student loans to banking, it is first very important to examine the economics of the proposed bill and explain how it will work if enacted into public policy; as well illustrate other reasons why we are seeing students having trouble paying off their loans.
One of the biggest problems with this bill is that it aims to fix the student loan problem with the very same types of policies that created the housing bubble and are currently creating the student loan bubble.
In one of my recent pieces I wrote about how many different market signals are currently showing that we are heading towards a massive student loan crisis. Many economists agree, low interest loans and accessibility to cheap capital is one of the biggest reasons bubbles are created. Senator Warren's bill only intensifies the problem instead of putting forth a concrete solution.
Almost all data available shows that student loan default rates are skyrocketing, and youth unemployment is still unusually high, but the reason we are seeing young people not being able to pay off their loans is only partly because of a bad economy. One of the less talked about reasons, is that there are lots of young people who are going to four year universities that should not be attending college in the first place. Many high school graduates who twenty years ago might have become plumbers, mechanics, and electricians are now being swayed and convinced they have to go to college to be successful.
Iranian Exiles Have Suffered as We Have Ignored Tehran’s Expanding Influence in Iraq | Leo McCloskey