Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Thursday, November 27, 2008
Ross Mackenzie :: Townhall.com Columnist
Time To Refocus On Less Materialism, Simpler Life
by Ross Mackenzie
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


So -- the financial markets, the incoming administration, Thanksgiving. What do you think?

If you follow the markets at all -- and how is it possible not to? -- it's hard to find any comfort. The Dow down 6,000 points in a year -- 45 percent. Investors holding paper losses of $9 trillion. Profits plummeting. Cutbacks. Layoffs. Companies (the U.S. auto companies?) going toes-up. The dread R and D words -- recession, deflation, depression. Many people are wiped out, and find me someone -- anyone -- who isn't worried.

But hey, the government is coming to the rescue . . .

In the contemporary cliche, that may be more part of the problem than part of the solution. To quote from a recent news account, "In little more than six months, the government has put a federal guarantee behind the biggest Wall Street firms, taken over half the $11 trillion mortgage market, gained ownership of the world's largest insurance company, enacted the biggest financial bailout in history, and (become) the lender of last resort for corporate America."

And you're not happy about that?

It's all being done in the name of stabilizing the markets and the financial system -- to build both liquidity and confidence. Yet much of it is mere nibbling around the edges. The best way to stabilize the financial system is to stabilize the dollar. The current infusions and regulatory Band-Aids may help bring a short-term fix, but they will not prevent future liquidity and confidence crises.

Insufficient regulation brought us to this point. That, and the 1999 Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act that repealed the 1933 Glass-Steagall Act separating commercial and investment banking.

You're mouthing the Obama campaign line -- wherein he and his brain trust, recently empowered further by Alan Greenspan's bizarre "confession" about the failure of free-market economics, are blaming the subprime lending crisis that cascaded into the financial collapse that morphed into the recession on . . . deregulation. It's baloney.

But the financial people around Obama -- his new team -- are brilliant. They've got the answers.

Many of them are not new but Clintonian retreads -- so much for Obama's "change" mantra on that front. And their answer seems to boil down to more intrusion, more regulation, and more redistribution. Throwing more taxpayer money at every unproductive entity with its hand out. They're wildly supported in all this by the increasing Democratic cohort in Congress, many of whose members (most notably -- regarding for instance Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac -- Barney Frank and Chris Dodd) have contributed hugely to crushing the economy.

At least we can hope they'll do the right things.

Hope is not a strategy. Yet that brings us to Thanksgiving -- the opening of the holiday season that is, perhaps fundamentally, the season of hope. In this season, maybe the current condition of the global economy will focus Americans on essentials: family, nature, eternal verities, a new frugality, a simpler life. With its focus on money and "things," materialism diminishes our appreciation for what we have. It fosters frustration, exasperation, even anger at what we don't, and a redefining of wants into necessities and have-to-haves.

How does this relate to the financial markets and the incoming Obama administration?

The stock market is, alas, but another form of gambling -- hardly different from playing the ponies, the numbers, the slots. Whether the current collapse is an unavoidable cyclical readjustment or was brought to us by a perfect storm wrought by the ignorant, the insensitive, the self-serving, and the malign -- it is what it is.

Mere mortals, the everyday rest of us -- working saps and the retired -- can do little but husband their remaining cash as best they can. A preoccupation with the markets -- with the crap tables -- suggests a motivating preoccupation with the material. And as the song says, "You've got to know when to hold 'em, know when to fold 'em, know when to walk away, know when to run."

Isn't that notion itself now a cliche?

Maybe. But it is shared by our greatest living historian, Britisher Paul Johnson, who has written extensively about disintegrating civilizations:

"The financial crisis, detonated by greed and recklessness on Wall Street and in the City of London, is for the West a deep, self-inflicted wound. . . . If we seriously wish to repair the damage, we need to accept that this is fundamentally a moral crisis, not a financial one. It is the product of the self-indulgence and complacency born of our ultraliberal societies, which have substituted such pseudo religions as political correctness and saving the planet for genuine distinctions between right and wrong and the cultivation of real values."

He laments the demise of "industry and thrift," and cautions that "we are traveling along the high road to incompetence and poverty, led by a farcical coalition of fashionably liberal academics on the make, assorted eco-crackpots, and media wiseacres."

Johnson's jeremiad meaning, exactly, what?

Meaning that in the midst of a terrifying financial tsunami, and -- with Obama -- the coming to power of precisely the ideologized panderers Johnson knows too well, hope (certainly not a strategy) is all that is left to us. Diaphanous, gauzy hope and whatever rope we can find to batten down.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Ross Mackenzie lives with his wife and Labrador retriever in the woods west of Richmond, Virginia. They have two grown sons, both Naval officers.

Be the first to read Ross Mackenzie's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

Does anybody reallyknow what Time it is?
Focus on less materialism, the simpler life? No, it's much more important to recognize the failures of unregulated capitalism, where 5% of Americans control 40% and more of the wealth, and have the power to get the government to bail them out for their greed and failures. We need more sharing of wealth; that would be a first step in encouraging those who really do the work producing it. Whatever Obama and the Democrats can do to encourage this necessary focus of political economy, the better.

dudley from MA

Dudley, Sorry thats not on the Liberal agenda.

Dudley, someone spiked your turkey
No socialist government that seriously redistributes wealth ever achieves anything except low-level misery for all.

The former Eastern bloc countries that lived under communism are running 8% GNPs and using flat taxes. Young Swedes are fleeing their sinking ec. at home for work and wealth in Poland and Hungary and Slovenia.

Great Britain and Germany seize wealth and run ec.'s that tolerate 10-13% unemployment and barely produced 2% GNP, so they are close to recession on a regular basis. Any ec. slowdown affects them seriously.

We need people like Dudley to go live in Germany and lounge around living on unemployment and enjoying everyone else' labors and never coming back to Am. where people can make their own wealth all of the time. THAT'S WHY THE ENTIRE WORLD WANTS VISAS TO GET HERE, EVEN OUR *ENEMIES* IN THE MIDDLE EAST WANT TO COME TO AMERICA TO SUCCEED BECAUSE NO OTHER COUNTRY OFFERS THE OPPORUNITIES OF AMERICA.

If Vietnamese boat people could flee their nation and risk pirates and the Pacific, arrive here to learn Eng. as a third languages, and yet produce high school valedictorians while establishing a fishing dynasty, then anyone can do it.

Just do it with your own talent and make your own money.


thank god for term limits
I hopeful the am. people will recover from the Obama kool-aid in 2-4-6-8 years. I hopeful he will not be able to totaly wreck this country's sprit of "i can do it" with "I can do it for you". Record welfare is on the way

I have the feeling
we are on the way to being taught that lesson whether we like it or not.

The original Thnksgiving
occured due the abundance ambitiously produced by free people precisely because they were free. This is exactly what we have moved away from.

There's no way to "do the right thing" with serfs, and not alot to be thankful for regarding the direction of this country.

So Dudley
you clearly haven't been one of the small business owners taxed in excess of 50% for being "lucky" enough to work 50+ hours per week, nor have you been a social worker. How about those who want to "share the wealth" engage in behaviors that generate wealth? I have witnessed enough people having more children than can ever be afforded by anyone acting like victims of an "unfair" society- enough. We already do "spread the wealth", and its exactly why social problems continue to get worse in scope and severity.

If anything, its time to hold people and organizations accountable for decisions, actions, and expenditures.

United Socialist States of America
The USSA is already here folks. It seems too late to stop this huge push to socialism. Our out of control government is going to get even bigger under the Community Organizer in Chief because that's what community organizer's do - organize. Think up new social programs in order to buy the loyalty, buy the votes of their newly dependent constituents.

Nothing but Fabian Socialists in DC. Both parties.

It's the lobbyists, stupid
Forget the simpler life. We need to focus on ridding Washington of the lobbyists who "persuaded" Congress to pass legislation enabling Wall Street to gamble away the wealth of this country.

With laws favoring sending jobs overseas, the collapse we're now experiencing was inevitable. Kevin Phillips accurately predicted our plight in his 1994 (!) book ARROGANT CAPITAL.

If T. Jefferson were blogging on Townhall, he'd be calling for another revolution.

Live and Let Live....
When man does not ask themselves in good times as bad times, what the hell is going on? They face the piper at a later date.

America has been printing money, stimulating the country that everyone has some if not more then. Printed till man said, we are the greatest country on earth. The debt is 350% of GNP. 250% in the great depression. Plus debt owed abroad in exports.

Pride before a fall, always happens in the 8th inning.

Materailism? Well, when inflations doubles. I wished. Try more like five fold over the next few years. That will tighten the hatches down to essentials of life.

Not counting our internal debt problem where our famous new President has concentrated his efforts. Because the world is dictating the other to America.

Hang on for the ride. It will be wild, crazy, and somewhat unpredictable and few make the eight seconds.

Simpler Life
We the people are supposed to guide our own destiny with interest and active participation in the politics of the country. Prudence and a conservative stance are required. We vote for politicians who do our bidding not the other way around and a sense of entitlement at the expense of others is not a consideration. “Keeping our powder dry” for future emergencies is essential; another words a healthy reserve in economic and military might is necessary. We the people are doing none of these things and we make ourselves very vulnerable to our enemies and we are mortgaging our futures on borrowed moneys that we don’t control. It’s time to get our internal house in order. Get back to basics like balanced budgets and fiscal responsibility in our own homes and in government. Secure our borders, throw all the blood-sucking vermin out of the country, bring back the manufacturing base, bring our military home, and restrain our diplomatic efforts to a minimum…we are not the world’s policeman and it just invites more animosity from all the deranged but envious mobs outside our borders. We have to stop the hemorrhaging of all that is dear to this nation starting with ourselves and demanding accountability and restraint from the political office holders. That is a nation of strength; the one we have now is an obese Baby Huey waiting to be knocked over with a feather (one of its own at that).

Blah...
"Insufficient regulation brought us to this point."

B.S. - government with its regulation and even worse, excessive spending, brought us to this point.

"But the financial people around Obama -- his new team -- are brilliant. They've got the answers."

No, they don't. Obama wants to start with a $500 billion stimulus. That's not brilliant. He's merely continuing Bush's money printing schemes to make his mark as president. Productivity will continue to decline in this country, as a result.

Paul Johnson has written some good things, but his Christian perspective, and yours, on what ails America, are dead wrong.

Ross
is a little down on the free market eh? The stock market is no different than gambling? It may seem like that today but, calm down. Look at the history. The value of any company is simply the net present value of future expected cash flows. Investors are worried about those cash flows and have adjusted their discount rates accordingly. They are demanding a higher rate to compensate for risk and the net present value plummets. If you were wanting to cash in some stock soon, I am sorry. Bad timing. If you can wait a while, rest assured. What goes down, must come up.

This is a financial crisis, not a moral one. The moral one is long term and ongoing and the demise of industry and thrift are premature. Will Obama push communist policies like FDR and LBJ. He probably will but, the end of the country will take far more then four years. There is still plenty of time to wake up the sleepwalkers, however, the end result is by no means guaranteed.

It could be that continued wrong headed policies supported by an ignorant populous will cause the eventual long term annihilation of wealth but, the market will come back in the short run before this happens and it will be a long road down. If this happens it will still be punctuated by periods of free market exuberance and wild stock market rallies when a free market Congress and/or president get a chance to slow the slide.

Cheer up Ross. Your advice about living simpler and valuing things non material applies anytime and everytime but, is separate from capitalism which is freedom.

This & That
Dudley: How does knowing that I won't be able to hang on to my earnings supposed to motivate me to work and produce? Forget it. I'm going to have my wife quit her job, I'm going to default on my mortgage, and I am going to take some of your redistributed wealth to stay in my house!
Get rid of lobbyists? Not going to happen. Why? Follow the money. There is too much money involved for politics to change. Remember McCain-Feingod? Wow, that sure kept the money out of this election cycle! LOL
Insufficient Regulation? Proof that common sense is not that common. I suggest you take a look at the Code of Federal Regulations. Any Part will do. We have regulations on top of regulations. This notion that there was not or is not enough regulation is absurd.
The writings of historian Paul Johnson highlighted in the article nailed it.

my 2 cents
we're just gonna have to hunker down and weather the storm. Hopefully with midterms in 2010 we'll see some sense in Washington,

but i ain't holding my breath

Dudley
I don't mind sharing what I have.

I DO, however, mind being told who I have to share it with, and will do ANY dam. thing I have to do to avoid that.

one more thing
read 'Atlas Shrugged'

scary - especially when you realize that it was written 50 years ago

Elusive Truth
This is a good article, well written. The problem is the Bible has already stated its truth in a more concise and cogent sentence.

"Life does not consist of the abundance of things you have."

Now, if a person chooses to reject God's Word on these things why would they embrace its truth in a more flowing vocabulary.

No, the problem with the economy is not socialism versus capitalism but the heart of Man versus the way of the Lord.

But columnist can't write that else they will lose their audience like God has.

Christians
I love how the Bible-Thumpers rail and shriek about "spreading the wealth" and socialism.
Jesus was the ultimate socialist. Jesus counseled us to help those in need.
What are these drive-thru Walmart mega-churches teaching the good folks today? Did Jesus believe in lower taxes?

I'm really tired of (especially southern and red state) conservatives bleating about hand-outs, welfare, and other coded racist remarks directed at BHO. The truth of the matter is that progressive blue states contribute more to the common weal in terms of tax dollars, while red states use more of those dollars. If that is not spreading the wealth, I don't know what is. And if we in the blue states started deciding who gets our hard-earned tax dollars and who doesn't, Kentuckians and Oklahomans would have to start buying their own damn bridges and stop signs with their own tax dollars. If that happened, you folks would feel real different about "sharing".....

Huh?
"The financial crisis . . . is the product of the self-indulgence and complacency born of our ultraliberal societies"

Then who is to blame for the crises of 1929, 1907, etc?

Moral Crisis.
the financial crisis is ultimately a moral crisis. i'm on board with that. but it's difficult to reform the morality of a country, and that's certainly nothing the liberal illuminati can do. so right now, lets focus on how to feed our families and pray that churches do their God-given work.

Iam - Forced Charity is not Charity

Iam your post really points out the problem and why Liberals vision of Federal government is just wrong.

Why should Red states fund projects in Blue states or vice versa? Why don't the states fund their own projects? If they have a need, they should fund it.

For our country to work well requires an educated population. Voters in New Jersey can not possibly know if the good people in Wyoming need a water purification project or not. Yet we expect them to support of disapprove of these projects.

So what would Jesus do? I think Jesus would agree that forced charity is not charity at all.

Scaling back your lifestyle may be a
grand adventure for some people, but for me, it is getting a little old. The economy where I live has been declining for years, due to many factors that have combined to kill jobs in Southern California.

Have fun roughing it, all you cheerleaders, but for me, I am getting ready in case I have to give away all my possesions and rent my girlfriend's sofa.

dudley-- I don't care how much money
the rich people have, as long as they give me a job. When corporations suffer, everybody who works there suffers!

It is now too expensive for Hollywood to make pictures in Hollywood, if they want to make a profit. Most pictures LOSE money, and only a few blockbusters keep the whole thing afloat. Of course, it doesn't help that all the Lefties throw away hundreds of millions of dollars making Anti-American propagand pieces that nobody wants to see!

But I have been able to keep a little roof over my head by picking up freelance work from Disney. They are trying to save money by using freelancers rather than hire people in-house.

However, as the corporations suffer, and lay off people, fewer are going to Disneyland, and I am afraid that I won't get any work next year, if this big corporation can't afford my services.

Throughout history, artists have counted on the wealthy in order to create art for a living. Do you think that Leonardo or Michaelangelo could have made so much amazing artwork if they didn't have wealthy benefactors who commissioned their skills?

We are all better off for the beauty created by wealthy people. If we take their money away and make everybody live at a middle income, would we ever get to have a nice drive through beautiful, tree-lined streets like there are in Pasadena, or Hancock Park?

SCALE BACK LIFESTYLE IN CAMELOT
A SCALEDOWN AMERICA WITH A SPEND THIFT PRESIDENT
NOW THIS WILL BE AN INTERESTING FOUR YEARS. BIG GOVERNMENT AS ORDINARY AMERICANS READ MORE, STAY HOME MORE, AND WATCH SOCIAL PROJECTS AND WELFARE CONTINUE TO DESTROY THE AMERICAN ECONOMY.

Ross complains about Big Government
So much did you and YOUR friends skim off the top at the country's expense Ross buddy? You've had your 8 years living with a moron as President. Apparently, it is catching. You want more of the same Ross? Tough luck. Your order is being delivered shortly and it is something quite a bit different
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.