Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Sunday, November 23, 2008
Paul Jacob :: Townhall.com Columnist
In need of bankruptcy?
by Paul Jacob
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Looking for something to be thankful for? How about the fact that you are not too big to fail?

There are advantages to not being rich, or all that important. The rules don’t bend for you. That means you have a good chance of keeping your dignity, maintaining your self-responsibility. You may end up broke, but you can at least maintain your sense of place in the universe.

Pity, then, all the insiders. “Too big to fail” or “too important to go bust” means always having to say they’re sorry, but never actually being sorry. Because they’ve been bailed out.

Some day cultural historians are going to look back on this time, and judge the actual effects (as opposed to the predicted effects, by folks like me) of the Too Big To Fail doctrine. What will it do to all those egalitarians who line up so regularly to vote Democratic? They have such faith in “everybody’s equal” (or “should be made so”), but their politicians keep proving that some people are more equal than others.

And they do it every time.

The Olde Guarde Republicans, those Main Street folks who vote for the Wall Street bankers and wheelers and dealers . . . well, they’ve always believed that some people are more important than others. They support their brand of corruption (as opposed to the Democrats’) simply to maintain that fantasied order, their vision of the Great Chain of Being that places their ilk ineluctably on top.

But until future historians make up their mind about the Era of Bailouts, what can we say?

Well, perhaps The Carpenters put it best: “We’ve only just begun.”

Seeing an opportunity for “free money,” a number of bit players in the current crisis have horned in on the action. Shall we call it “No Nabob Left Behind”? Once you open the floodgates, why not let the states of New York and New Jersey, for example, get “special treatment”?

And then, just when you thought it could not get any more absurd, enter the Big Three automakers.

Hey: if the federal government is handing out money to banks, why not hand out money to failing auto companies?

I could list a long series of reasons. But consider, instead, the sage words of one congressional skeptic, Rep. Jeff Flake:

My own view is that, if there was ever an industry in need of bankruptcy, it’s the auto industry. It’s the only way they can renegotiate their union contracts and make other changes to be competitive. They might not make it out of bankruptcy, but they certainly can’t survive long term on their own without entering it.

Bracing words. Repeat them: “If there was ever an industry in need of bankruptcy, it’s the auto industry.”

I wish I’d said this myself. “In need of bankruptcy” is not exactly our current era’s marching cry, but perhaps it should be. Bankruptcy is about failure. Understandably, no one wants to fail, and no one wants to praise a process that is “about failure.” But that’s why it’s needed. Bankruptcy is a recognition of failure.

We should not be so afraid of failure that we cannot identify it when it happens, or call it by name.

So take a step back. Take a breath. And then recognize a basic truth: If the Big Three cannot survive the current market climate, then they have failed.

Formal bankruptcy recognizes their failure. And would allow them to “move on.”

And think, for a moment, about those pitiable CEOs and CFOs and COOs. Under a receivership, they don’t get their bonuses, like in our bailed-out mortgage and banking industry. Instead, they are more likely to receive the blessings of responsibility: pink slips.

All contracts get put on hold, many are voided. The business’s receivers take control, and all claims upon the assets of the company get sorted out.

And, inevitably, the failed company’s assets go to new owners.

Some of the Big Three’s divisions are extraordinarily profitable. They get sold or auctioned off to the highest bidders, who then run them (it is hoped) at a profit.

Some of those divisions have been so badly run for so long a time that it would be better to let them die a peaceful death. We don’t weep for Studebaker, today; why weep for just another SUV line?

It would be great if some new owners and managers would take up the promising Volt project from Chevy. There is probably a big future in electric cars. I bet there are investors who would be willing to take it up after receivership.

Or, GM could sell off the line now, staving off bankruptcy.

Or, better yet, GM could sell off other lines, and invest in electric vehicles, where there’s likely a big future.

Unfortunately, before GM, or Ford, or — what’s the third one, again? Iacocca’s once-bailed-out dinosaur? — Chrysler can move forward, they each face a speed bump the size of the Rocky Mountains: the unions.

Representative Flake is right: Getting out from under union contracts is almost a necessity. America’s automobile industry won’t recover as long as it remains weakened by union leechcraft. It’s a wonder that these companies have survived as long as they have, considering how unreasonable union demands have been, and how life-draining union benefits have been to those companies.

And that gets to the heart of why things look so bleak right now. Do we have any reason to believe that president-elect Obama has the insight or the courage to take on the unions? Indeed, he and the congressional Democrats will be sorely tempted to throw billions at Detroit rather than confront one of the more sordid skeletons in their closet: America’s pro-union laws. In fact, our laws may soon be further rigged in favor of unions.

The Democratic Party has played the toady to “organized labor” at least since FDR’s time, and organized labor has played one of the most pernicious political roles, with devastating influence on American policy and culture. The teachers’ unions have consistently held back K-12 schooling in America, and they prevent, at every possible turn, the best attempts to improve education. America’s unions also helped cartelize — and then ruin — the industrial sector. Think steel. Think rust belt. Understand why America is as “post-Industrial” as it is.

Big Three automakers are remnants of the ancien régime, of old school American can-do-it-ness. They’ve been hurting for decades now, struggling to keep up with modern demands.

And now they claim to need government funding.

What to do? Why not fire them all? Fire every CEO, CFO, COO. And fire every worker. And then hire needed workers back at market wages.

Yes, they need bankruptcy . . . because America needs to move on.

But with the party beholden to unions now in control, this is about as likely as . . . financial sanity under the Republicans.

Both parties believe that some enterprises are “too big to fail.” And because of this, they may imperil the biggest enterprise of all: the United States of America itself.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Paul Jacob is President of Citizens in Charge. His daily Common Sense commentary appears on the Web, via e-mail, and on radio stations across America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
http://www.endthefed.us
http://www.endthefed.us/

..

Mr. Jacob
The downfall of the 'Big Three' was most educational for people like myself, who always assumed that the 'Big Three' and large companies like them (AIG, Chase, etc) were doing just fine. What an eyeopener!
Now that Americans have been educated regarding the 'new' unions, the salaries, the bonuses, the perks and the 'paid NOT to work' program, there is NO sympathy. There is also no trust in the 'Big Three' or in the government.
I won't buy a car, a policy or apply for a loan from a failing company.
I have taken all of my money out of the market because of the 'promise' of increased Capital Gains Taxes. I won't be putting money back into the market until I'm convinced I won't be punished.
I do not want Congress or the Senate to have anything to do with oversight of where their 'America is going to fail if we don't have this 7 billion right now' emergency money. They've proven themselves as inept at handling money as the Big Three. We need a bipartisan panel of experts, who have run successful companies without government help.
Since it is We the People's money being spent, I want to see the checkbook every month. I want to know who, why, when and how much I'm paying these companies and what they plan to do to improve what got them in the ditch in the first place.
When a company has achieved a 'too big to fail' status, they have obviously forgotten those of us who bought their products to put them there. Bankrupcy would be good for all of them...along with a HUGE dose of humility. Oh, and NO raises!
Keep educating, Mr. Jacob. Americans like myself have trusted 'blindly' for way too long.

Amen
Amen Brother!

Let the bankruptcys begin!
Mr. Jacob;

This is exactly how I feel. Why throw money away that will just go to private jets and golden parachutes and union greed?

I also agree that the Democrats will not let bankruptcy happen without throwing billions at the big 3 and union employees. It's just postphoning the inevitible.

opportunity
When you remove the chance of failure, you also remove the opportunity for success.

The majority
I get the sense that the majority of Americans would rather have the "big three" go into bankruptcy than have them "bailed out". If that is the case, then why are our elected officials who are suppose to represent US in Washington considering just the opposite? Are they not listening to US or are we not just LOUD enough for them to hear us?
As was the case for off-shore drilling, it's time to get vocal about NOT bailing out these failed companies.

The USA was once thought too big to fail
HAH!!! 80 years of creeping socialism and criminally inferior public education is about to bring down our once great nation.

The dhimmicrats will again ignore the law of unintended consequences and continue to throw HUGE amounts of GOOD money after BAD; as fast as they can print it, down all their favorite rat-holes. I'm pizzed at repubicans for their betrayal of core conservative values, but the dhimmicrat party is the enemy of the Constitution, freedom and liberty, as far as I'm concerned.

This has been their plan all along and they've pushed it so far down the road, going faster and faster, it may be well nigh impossible to keep us from going off a washed out bridge, over a cliff, or crashing into whatever fatal obstacle is over the horizon.

That obstacle is the reality they've ignored, dismissed, lied about and generally denied as it doesn't fit into their Utopian dreams. God doesn't - honesty, morality, decency, and personal responsibility don't either.

The dhimmicrat party is completely, criminally insane (See: Algore, Pelousey, Reed, Frank, Kennedy, Dodd, Murtha and on and on) and while humorous when not in power, they are scary and dangerous when they run things.

This country HAS to pull it's collective head out of a dark, smelly place, but I'm worried that you just can't fix stupid.


The Academy
One of the most heavily subsidized giants that ought to fall...prepare yourself...is higher education. Not that it doesn't serve a function: if it didn't, countries from all over the world wouldn't be sending their kids here. The problem is, it's been hijacked by professors of "silly studies" and "angry studies." The future President's own wife has a minor in Angry Studies.

Jokes about jocks taking "underwater basketweaving" are almost true - except that jocks aren't the ones taking those courses. It's the unexceptional students who can't pass muster who sign up for those things, just to pull the GPA up.

Meanwhile, professors are encouraged to develop new courses - often from nothing worth studying. If anything, the Duke Lacross Hoax has proven the truth of this.

So if you're waiting for behemoths to fall, you don't have to go to Detroit: you probably have one in your city - a college or university that prizes diversity over actual scholarship. And becoming as unsustainable as the Edsel.

Bankruptcy of the
Detroit Three is inevitable. But not before congress throws 25 billion of OUR money at it. This nonsense about waiting until the car companies come up with a plan is nothing but theater and window dressing designed to placate most Americans' objection to a bailout. Trust me, the car companies WILL get the money -- it's a done deal. The scenario goes like this: Okay, you get the 25 billion, but if you can't turn it around, don't come back for more. In that way, congress can have it both ways -- they can tell the unions, "We tried." They can tell the rest of us, "No more bailouts."

Are our representatives paying attention
This should be required reading for every gas bag from the Senate (esp. the 2 from Calif.) and all 454 representatives.

Where does the line end? Why do all liberals believe in evolution and survival of the fittest except when it comes to all matters of economics? Either U.S. industry becomes competetive or the world economy will bury them, and a bailout will only prolong the agony!

Sidwell for me uinionized crap for thee
There can be no greater point in favor of private nonunion performance verses failed vastly overpaid union nonperformance than the Obamas choice of Sidwell Friends school for their children.

Unlimited investment in public unionized education in DC ($16,000 per student annually) has been an utter failure but pres-elect Obama is a slave of the teachers' unions. He will throw tons of money at these unions and call it an "investment in education" but will of course send his children to a private school where he knows the demented fools that run public schools will not be teaching his own.

The last bastions of unionized labor, auto manufacturers, state and local government are leading the parade to DC is the quest for bailout money. After the bankruptcy of the big three the reorganization of excessive union contracts given by states (CA leading the way) through bankruptcy would also be a good thing.

Grateful for Bankruptcy
As usual, Paul Jacob hits the nail on the head. Failing businesses deserve to go bankrupt; depriving them of that necessary remedy only makes things worse — for them, and for the rest of us.

Will the bankruptcy be filed in DE
We documented Bankruptcy Fraud in DE

that had the protection of the DE US Attorney
http://coverupbycolmconnolly4mnat.blogtownhall.com/

Perhaps with the Change of the Administrations it would not be wise for Obama or Biden to permit such mendacity to continue

Here's an idea
Let's all pull all our money out of the banks, cash in our investments, retirement plans and then see if they think we are unimportant.

We have already started to put the screws to them by stopping our purchases of anything but necessities. Oil is a good example. If we continue to do what we are doing, we can bankrupt the Arabs, too.

Wasn't there ...
a Lockheed bailout? Lockheed who?

Wasn't Chrysler bailed out? Who asked our leaders in industry to roll over for wrckless government mandates. Know why they did? Because behind the scenes they were using friends in government to hammer the competition with regulation that favored them and discouraged the competitor.
Where were the union guys to discourage government involvement in business. I'll tell you where they were. They were in line to kiss the butt of the Barny and Kennedy ilk to also recieve government favors.

When you are that close to someone's butt, they should have known what to anticipate from that oriffice.

Come on Paul,
GM is getting rid of two of their eight Gulfstream jets, aren't they suffering enough? Good golly, the big shots might have to...choke...gasp...rideshare!

Let's get the capitol switchboard
flooded once again - they finally got our message re: illegal immigration, perhaps it will work with the NO MORE BAILOUTS situation!

Great article, Mr. Jacob - and I hope you will continue to speak about this most important issue.

I will agree that at one time the unions served a purpose. However, we now have safe working conditions and I DO NOT believe being paid for NOT working is a proper program for a company who wishes to prosper! Get off your tushes and go find a job! You will probably be quite surprised to find out that the rest of American workers do NOT bring in the hourly wages that the unions in the auto industry think is reasonable. And somehow we exist! And rather well at that...so GET REAL! You really are NOT worth $60/$70 an hour!

I doubt there are many Americans who have the first drop of empathy for these early retirees who are complaining about losing health benefits. Get a darn job like the rest of us so you can have some insurance!!!

I would like ALL states/cities/
'too big to fail' companies to FAIL! It is time to find a drop or two or accountability in this country!

Good old Massachusetts decided to make health insurance MANDATORY and has gone in the financial hole bigtime ever since it was implemented! So........you want universal health care across the country and you THINK it won't cost you a thing...take a gander at the problems in this one state and you'll soon realize that a $700 billion bailout is small change in comparison!

Capitalism and entrepreneurs are the backbone of America and you can't achieve success without also accepting the possibility of failure. And with each failure, you learn and next time you just might succeed.

ONE NEVER LEARNS IF THEY DON'T SUFFER THE CONSEQUENCES OF THEIR FAILURES!

NO MORE BAILOUTS!

BANKRUPTCY OVER BAILOUT
STOP THE BAILOUTS AND LET THE BANKRUPCY SEASON BEGIN. NO TOO STIMULUS CHECKS.

Let the Bankruptcy begin
I believe that once bankruptcy begins the unions and the inept Congress, both present and future will come to terms with just how bad management and leadership has been across the board.
Perhaps it will induce the unions to reduce their bleeding demands and get back to actually working for their wages and production of a quality and less-costly product that is also more efficient product.
I've always felt that unions may have had a useful place at one time but now are an albatros around the neck of free enterprise that is choking industries and has forced many overseas where labor is cheaper. less demanding and more efficient.
We no longer take pride in our work with only excessive greed and excessive expectations to drive the workforce.

Card Check? Union Goons need jobs!
Now who in their right mind would be against card check aka Union Goon Full Emloyment Act! With unemployment at almost a record high it is nice to know that Bubba, Tiny, Crusher, Briuser, Butch, Knuckles, Sluggo and their thick necked friends will not have to look for real employment!

Those dumb foreign automakers who pay their workers only $40 p/h in the US will soon be made to join up with the UAW and start paying a living wage of $70 to their exploited workforce. Then with just high enough duties on imports and US autoworker will be saved from the indignity of making less than $70 per hour.

Walmart greeters can be unionized and should be down for at least $50 per hr. Every man a king sounds alittle sexist. How about every person a regent!

Wow! It is all so easy when the Dems are in power! Millions of unionized jobs all producing green vehicles, green energy, making the world green with envy. When you elect a messiah there is no stopping us or the US.

A messiah who can suspend the laws of supply and demand, who can heal the oceans, who can suspend mortgage payments permanently, who will provide unlimited health care, who will give free education to all, who will bring peace on earth. Indeed he is the alpha and omega! Obama be thy name! Thy kingdom come!

Those evil rich have been in charge way to long now its time for change! Yes We Can!

Obama and the unions
When the Dems and Obama give the big 3 and their union thugs the billions they want, there will be political hay to make for Republicans. Outside a few terminally depressed midwest states, very few in this country have any sympathy for those union slobs who have destroyed our manufacturing base with their $70 hr pay and ridiculous pensions.

WRITE and CALL
this creep! If you haven't seen the video "With Republicans like this who needs democrats?" (conservative must reads) go do it now. Then google Joe Knollenberg and email and CALL his offices in the morning and tell him IT IS OUR MONEY! Someone has to toss this arrogant SOB out of office! I cannot believe he had the audacity let alone sheer STUPIDITY to tell us all that money that would be used to bailout the big three is not ours! This guy is dangerous. We can all be damned---he ain't working for us!

JAG CA
I'm in total agreement with U..I worked a Union job briefly after HS, got laid off--Enlisted in the Army and spent 24 yrs--Retired went to work Union.
In fact I was a Shift Steward for years--Spent most of my time handling grievences for people who PROBABLY should have been dismissed!!
But Ur absolutely right--the AFL/

RINOS - BIG-3 and Bankruptcy
Bye Bye Knollenberg. Michigan still reliving '64 Convention, here Moderate Republicans routinely allie themselves with Democrats against Concervatives hence a Governor like Jennifer Granholm. At least we've got Mike Rogers and Thad Mccotter.

BIG-3 deserve to go under but do have points in their favor like importance to national defense and ridicuolus mandates from DC. Still be careful what you wish for. At $70/per hour as outrageous as that is, each auto job lost is like 3 average jobs in terms of its effect on the economy not mention trickle down.

jag ca Contd
AFLCIO surely want to get their meat-hooks on those WalMart DUES..But from the input from here locally that won't happen..The State of WV was a Union paradise for Generations, in fact that's the only reason the state is and always be Democrat...The fact is that the Unions have pretty much ruined the Crafts they represented for so long.. Chapter 11 for the Big 3 is better than they deserve.

In Need of Bankruptcy, reason 2
Yes, the burden of union contracts is one of the reasons the Big Three need Chapter 11 process, but there is another heavy burden, one that came as a result of those contracts, and that's the heavy burden of pensions. This, also, harms the auto makers, preventing them from profitably offering their products at competitive prices. The question thus arises, however will those promises be treated by the bankruptcy courts? For that I do not have an answer.

Let's go for it!!
Let's throw the baby under the bus. It's the Unions fault.

Of course the unions have agreed to a two-tier pay system for new hires. The unions have agreed to pick-up the health care of their members. The unions have agreed to limit their pensions. The unions have agreed to eliminate the job bank.

The unions have made this country great with a liveable wage for their members. They generated income that allowed their members to buy boats and homes. Items that stimulated the economy for all Americans.

Oh and by the way, the stimilus that got us out of the recession after 9/11, it was GM with their rebates that got the economy rolling. Ask the Fat Boy Rush, I'm sure he'll tell you the truth.

I challenge anyone of you twits to work on the line for a week. Your brain and soul would turn to mush.

"The employees need to bargain with management". Yep, that's the way to run a company, each employee negotiating their own pay.

Guess what happens when the Big 3 go under? Three million people get pink slips and lose their health care benefits. States lose taxes because of the lost income and unemployment benefits bankrupt Ohio, Michigan, Indiana.

Tennessee, Alabama, Mississippi get to close their auto plants because their suppliers went bankrupt because the Big 3 filed for chapter 11 and can't pay the employees to keep manufacturing.

Horror story? Oh you betcha. Worse than Zombies. But that's okay with conservatives because the destruction of the economy and millions of lives is more important than helping other Americans and destroying the UAW.

It's called conservative principles or dogma. Enjoy the depression, your policies and party caused it.

merrycollin #25
Let the Big three go under. Yep, good idea. Of course all those automotive test tracks in Arizona will close down. You will lose about 1,000-2,000 jobs directly. Maybe another 10,000 indirectly. What about the air bag manufacturers in your state? Don't worry, Arizona will do fine with their Federally subsidized stolen water.

Paul in MI - Boo who...
Hey, Unions giving back? About 25 years too late.  Unions were able to keep product lines going that should have been dumped probably 20 years ago, (Oldsmobile, Buick, most of the Dodge products).  Yep you're right we owe, the unions, we owe the people who didn't save dime one of their overtime.  We owe the people who steal millions in equipment (tools, lubricants, etc... it's called internal theft).  Yep, we owe the people who can't figure out that an emergency room is for an actual emergency, not your kids flu.  Yep, most people's minds would turn to mush workin' the line, and trying to stay awake the full 8 hours, after the (2) 15 minute smoke breaks, the (2) 45 minute toilet visits, the 30 minute lunch.  And all while trying to figure out how management is just plotting to stick it to the worker.  You made your bed now lie in it.  If the products were so superior and customer satisfaction were so high, I don't see how the Pathetic 3 could be in so much trouble.  American made?  Ha...  Look at the parts content, pinhead.  For Heaven's sake, Honda, and Toyota have more American in them then any of the "American" vehicles.  So, after sticking it to your suppliers, (Yep, I worked at one of them, and am now back in school going into healthcare) you want the people that you stuck it to, to bail you out.  Tough luck...

Roy of Michigan
Roy offers us a voice of sanity.

Why I am fond of Ford Motor Company
I suppose it's no good reason to keep Ford in existence, but I remain fond of the company because in late 1969, when a soldier fighting in Viet-Nam I went to the PX & paid down $500. on a new Ford that was to be picked up by me at a dealer in K.C. when I rotated back to the States in March, 1970. But I had the ill judgment to get myself badly shot up in a firefight on 22 January 1970 and spent the next ten months & 3 days in hospital attempting but failing to recvover from my wounds incurred, I with the dubious honor to be one of the 7 3/4% of US WIAs to have been determined to be 100% disabled due to their wounds incurred in 'Nam.

Anyway, at Fizsimmons Army medical center in the States, Denver, I had my family notify Ford I'd not be picking up the new LTD I'd ordered. Soon thereafter two Ford representatives appeared at my hospital bedside to not only inform me that not only was Ford taking back the vehicle I'd ordered with no penalty to me; they also then & there returned my $500. deposit, a fair chunk of change to I, a G.I., in early 1970.

Probably GM & Chysler would have done the same, but, a big difference, I KNOW Ford treated me, a seriosly WIA G.I., decently.

Yes, millions of Americans falsely claim Viet-Nam service. That I fought & was WIA over there are facts verifiable online. Go to http://www.vietnamproject.ttu.edu/banshee & once there merely check the unit roster for my name, Dave Livingston.

Nothing said above is to suggest regret for having fought or been WIA in Viet-Nam. As unreasonable as it may be, I'd not have not worn Uncle's uniform in 'Nam. As were most of us in 'Nam, I was a volunteer.

In addition, I see myself especially blessed by our Lord, permitted to survive the wounds I did. I believe when hit, He reached out to give me a light tap & said "Live." Otherwise, I wouldn't have.

Robbing Roy To Pay Paul
When my company went under, NO ONE bailed us out. Why should people earning less than $50,000 a year pay their tax dollars so that Paul can continue to collect his ludicrous salary and benefits. Overpaid corrupt management and Labor have ensured that "The Big Three" are no longer viable. Any bailout would just be spent to pay for Paul's healthcare and pension plan. The only hope for "The Big Three" is to declare Bankruptcy, cut salaries top to bottom, close unnecessary plants and lay off 30,000 - 50,000 workers.

Kenneth - Pensions in Bankruptcy
As defined benefit plans, they would be covered under the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, a federal agency.

Has anyone noticed that the Bush administration's latest infusion of $20 billion into Citigroup? Oh, and taxpayers are also promising to cover potentially hundreds of billions in losses from Citigroup's toxic off-balance sheet "assets."

Can't hurt their self-esteem
Jacob is right, this is about failure. And our culture has devolved to the point where we can stand to let little kids playing baseball fail, ie, lose, so how does anyone think we'd ever stomach letting three car manufacturers admit their failure by declaring bankruptcy.

Go watch "A Clockwork Orange". That's what we're heading for.

Persnickety - On defense production
--
Writes Persnickety Curmudgeon:

"BIG-3 deserve to go under but do have points in their favor like importance to national defense and ridicuolus mandates from DC. Still be careful what you wish for. At $70/per hour as outrageous as that is, each auto job lost is like 3 average jobs in terms of its effect on the economy not mention trickle down."


The production units of the "Big 3" responsible for the manufacture of military vehicles will tend to be the most valuable assets to be picked up by other manufacturers when bankruptcy liquidation ensues, and there should be no strategically significant interruption in the delivery of goods from these units.

As for the aggregate worth of these "$70/per hour" jobs burdening the Big 3 companies, you're falling into the "broken window" fallacy.






=====
"Special interests request money from the government (in the form of subsidies, grants, etc.), and the government then forces the taxpayer to provide the funds. The recipients certainly do benefit, so the government action is often regarded by the people as benefitting everyone. But the people are failing to consider the hidden costs: the taxpayers are now poorer by exactly that much money. The food, clothing or other items they might have purchased with that money will now not be purchased—but since there is no way to count 'non-purchases,' this is a hidden cost, sometimes called opportunity cost. Bastiat referred to this in his essay as 'what is not seen'. Because the costs are hidden, there is an illusion that the benefits cost nothing. Hazlitt summarized the principle by saying, 'Everything we get, outside the free gifts of nature, must in some way be paid for.' Robert A. Heinlein popularized a summarization/acronym of the concept called 'TANSTAAFL' (There Ain't No Such Thing As A Free Lunch)."

-- Wikipedia article, "The parable of the broken window" (accessed 24 November 2008)

America is suffering
America is suffering unlawful deception from the Alinsky group.
Group u$urp$ power on January 20th—the constitution violated.
The United States Supreme Court alone can relieve this outrage.

example: Bogus Selective Service System FOIA Registration?
http://www.debbieschlussel.com/archives/2008/11/exclusive_d id_n.html
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.