Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, July 29, 2009
Jonah Goldberg :: Townhall.com Columnist
Planet Bull's Eye
by Jonah Goldberg
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Do you feel the leaked information from a global warming alarmist organization is meaningful?



The year is 2109. Celebrations continue as mankind's heroic, century-long, quintillion-dollar effort to lower the global mean temperature by 1 degree has paid off: July 2109 is just as hot as July 2009. Few can contain their jubilation.

But even as the carbon-neutral champagne corks fly, the sky darkens. A projectile of a different kind is coming our way. An asteroid streaks across the skies, giving the media just enough time to spread the word. The New York Times, now beamed directly into subscribers' brains via digital-neural networks, fulfills ancient prophecy and warns that women and minorities will be hardest hit by the incoming object.

But there's little we can do. The space flotsam smashes into the solar energy farm formerly known as Arizona. The space rock, 100 meters in diameter, hits at 50,000 mph with the force of thousands of nuclear warheads. Millions die. Dust and debris blot out the sun and will chill the planet for years. Crops fail, billions starve. The heat of impact releases torrents of nitrous and nitric acid rain.

So horrendous is the calamity that some even wonder if the enormous investment in fending off climate change might not have been better spent.

Alas, there's no time to defrost Al Gore's frozen head to ask his opinion.

This vision of the end times came to me on hearing the news that something hit Jupiter in the breadbasket the other week and nobody saw it coming.

It left a Jovian scar as "small" as the Pacific Ocean or as big as Earth. An amateur astronomer in Australia saw it first because none of the pros were even looking. Then again, the rock was probably pretty small, between 50 and a few hundred meters wide. That is to say, about the size of John Edwards' house.

Now, I know what you're saying: So what? It's not like we need an early warning system for Jupiter, a "gassy giant." What have the Jovians done for us? When God starts pelting rocks at Earth, or our own gassy giants, like Chris Dodd, then we can worry.

Well, He has been, on a regular basis. In March, a meteor called 2009 DD45 came within a few inches, astronomically speaking, of smashing into Earth (about 45,000 miles). Fortunately, we spotted that one ahead of time -- a mere three days ahead of time. That's just enough warning for Keith Olbermann to knock out several top-notch diatribes on why George Bush is to blame, but not enough time to, you know, keep New York City from being liquefied.

In 1908, a DD45-sized meteor exploded over Siberia with a force 1,000 times the Hiroshima blast. It leveled 80 million trees over an area twice the size of Los Angeles. If it had arrived five hours later, St. Petersburg would have been gone.

Scientists think there are millions of such "small" near-Earth meteors out there, and more than 1,000 that are at least a kilometer wide. Those are the ones that really leave a mark. Just ask the dinosaurs. And we're discovering more every day.

A few years ago, a book titled "The Black Swan" came out. No, it's not about swans singled out by the Cambridge Police Department for breaking into their own roosts, but about sudden, unpredictable events occurring far more often than we'd like to think. There are flocks of black swans out there, but we find it discomfiting to contemplate their existence.

In 2008, science writer Gregg Easterbrook surveyed preparedness for a "space-object strike" for the Atlantic magazine. He found that even though serious experts believe there's as much as a 1-in-10 chance of a significant Earth strike within the next century, NASA doesn't much care.

Things are improving, but it's still a cottage industry. A scientist quoted last month in Maclean's magazine noted that "there are more people working in a single McDonald's than there are trying to save civilization from an asteroid."

Meanwhile, the global warming industry -- and it is an industry now -- could fill football stadiums.

It makes you wonder. For all the rush and panic, the truth is, climate change -- if real -- is a very slow-moving catastrophe. Moreover, it happens to align with an ideological and political agenda the left has been pushing for generations: Unregulated economic growth is bad and must be controlled by experts; nature is our master, and we must be her servants. What a convenient truth for environmentalists.

Meanwhile, a "deep impact" is a terribly inconvenient threat, partly because it requires making peace with the idea that nature can be conquered.

Better to not even think about it.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Jonah Goldberg is editor-at-large of National Review Online.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Jonah Goldberg's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Funny
Yet thankfully me and my Christian brothers and sisters will not be around for such calamity....

TownhallPlus.com

About an hour ago, I heard on the radio that we might see a huge wave of heroin-addicted injured and returning military in 5 years.

M
MEDICARE RECIPIENTS TO LOSE $ 500,000,000,000 IN OBAMA'S HEALTH PLAN


Obama plans to cut Medicare funding by 500 Billion Dollars to subsidize his Health Insurance Plan.

Medicare recipients will be faced with rationing and will move from the front of the line to the back.

That 500 Billion Dollars will be used to add over 11 Million Illegal Aliens to the health care rolls.

America's "Greatest Generation" is now Medicare Recipients and Obama wants to take 500 Billion Dollars from them and give

it to illegal immigrants.

Most Medicare recipients are unaware of this.


HYPOCRITES & OBAMA'S HEALTH INSURANCE PLAN

AARP is backstabbing those they're suppose to protect by not informing their members of the 500 Billion Dollar Medicare cut.

In fact the liberal AARP is backing Obama's plan to the detriment of their members.

Sen. Bill Nelson of Florida is also going to backstab all those Medicare recipients in Florida that he represents.

Sen. Bill Nelson will vote for the Obama plan & cut in Medicare funds.

For those of you who are members of AARP or residents of Florida, tell AARP or Sen. Nelson that they are Backstabbing Hypocrites.

Also that you are going to resign from AARP or not vote for Sen. Nelson.



Using Nature to Control Humans
The brutal truth for all--including Harvard intellectuals--is we cannot control nature. Today's environmentalists are no different than the Aztec priests who believed they could keep the sun from disappearing by sacrificing human lives. The paradox is that even in the 21st Century stupidity still exists and thanks to modern communications is even more widespread.

The one basic truth that has been disseminated down through the bloody history of earth's homo sapiens is that there always will be people who want to control others by any means available. Al Gore and Barack Obama are modern descendants of the Central American bloody priests.

A change we can believe in...
Chicago-Coldest July on record
New York-Coldest June since 1958

I guess all the greenhouse gases are gone in Chicago and New York...just hot air left in Washington

Planet Bull's Eye
Unfortunately, not much to be done here. Granted; the farther out one can detect an astroid on collision course, the more time there is to do something. We don't have the technology to stop something like this.

We Could
DEVELOP the technology to do something about this.

Unfortunately, those available economic resources will be sucked into the scam called cap-and-trade trying to reduce the earth's temperature by one (1) degree in a century.

Talk about short sighted stupidity........

Perfect!
"The New York Times ... warns that women and minorities will be hardest hit by the incoming object. "

That is the best line in his column.

I don't know about that Jersey Vet

"The brutal truth ...is we cannot control nature."

"...Aztec priests who believed they could keep the sun from disappearing by sacrificing human lives."

The Aztecs might have been on to something. Just to be on the safe side, maybe we should continue that practice. I say we start with nancy pelousy and the entire democrat congress.

Good Article
Our elected "leaders" dither over all the minutiae and garbage that they are trying to ram down our throat, while ignoring the clear and present dangers of our existence. Rogue states with WMD's, terrorists trying with all they have to forge a new world order, corrupt politicians and public officials. And we are going to bankrupt the country to make a vain attempt to lower the temperature by less than one degree?

On this particular possibility of destruction, I read a very good work of science fiction many years ago called Lucifer's Hammer. It was about an asteroid hitting Earth and the resultant devastation and societal collapse. Well written and certainly worth the time it took to read it. While we may not have the technology today to stop something like this from happening, I would much rather the government use our tax dollars in research and development of defenses that could eliminate or at least minimize the possibility of something like this happening. After all, isn't one of the ennumerated powers of the Federal Government to provide for the defense of the nation? I've looked several times and can't find anything in the constitution giving them the power to fight climate change at the expense of the taxpayer.

Corndog
You have a plan. It might not work but it's worth the chance to try. We need to add Al Gore to that list too.

Global Warming
The real problem is that too many people believe humanity it all-powerful. People, we simply are a pimple on Earth's behind. Get over it.

The real reason global warming is such a push is 1) too many scientists are using the panic to get millions of dollars to "study" the problem and 2) Big Al owns a big share of the company that has developed equipment to remove CO2 from industry exhaust stacks. The only trouble is that it is VERY expensive and no one can justify using the equipment. But if he can get his friends in Washington to come through for him by making the equipment manditory, he stands to make billions of dollars.

Come on now, where is his cheering section?

Do you REALLY want to solve the problem?
The scientists (and Al Gore too) say the problem is due to CO2 getting into the atmosphere. Well, talk to any high school science teacher about CO2 and you'll find that it is a requirement for plant growth. They absorb the CO2 and emit oxygen which we need to breath to live.

So the obvious solution to excess CO2 is to plant trees or other plants. Even grass will work fine.

But then - Big Al couldn't make billions on that simple a thing, now can he?

Bravo
Jonah - Excellent point and with humor. I think the technology is probably there to at least indicate where an asteroid will strike and then notify a specific region to evacuate. Of course if it is a global killer then well Adios!

Nature
So if nature can't be controlled (ie asteroid shield) then why are we worried about CO2? Isn't killing our economy to save 1 degree temperature change the same as attempting controlling nature. If you follow this logic then don't worry about CO2 and nature will take care of it. Nature will take care of asteroids too - another million years before we have to suffer the re-evolution of NY Times, liberal wingnuts and global warming! We'll just be worrying about survival...

I think we are seeing nature taking care of CO2 in Chicago... and this winter is going to be a rough one.

MR GREEN JEANS AL GORE
AL SAYS HE NEEDS PLENTY OF GREEN TO GO WITH HIS PORK CHOPS,AND THE DEMO-RATS JUST LOVE HIM AS HE PASSES OUT MORE GREEN.WHAT A SHAME!

Jerseyvet
Great post!

Rev 6:13-14 "Then, the stars of the sky fell to earth like green figs falling from trees shaken by mighty winds. And the sky was rolled up like a scroll and taken away. [Think nuclear winter.] And all of the mountains and all of the islands disapperared."

Rev 8:8-10 "Then, the second angel blew his trumpet, and a great mountain of fire was thrown into the sea. And one-third of the water in the sea became blood. And one-third of all living things in the sea died. And one-third of all the ships on the sea were destroyed. then, the third angel blew his trumpet, and a great flaming star fell out of the sky, burning like a torch..."

Hey!!
Do I still get my health care?

Daniel
Actually, here are the verses that hit me...

Rev. 9:20-21

"The rest of mankind that were not killed by these plagues still did not repent of the work of their hands; they did not stop worshiping demons, and idols of gold, silver, bronze, stone and wood—idols that cannot see or hear or walk. Nor did they repent of their murders, their magic arts, their sexual immorality or their thefts."



Corndog...
...you better ask God if he takes plastic before offering up Nancy Pelosi!

Just once in a while I come up with a good one.

truth
Ever visited the meteor crater in Arizona? Impressive. Actually women and minorities represent the majority demographic so even toungue in cheek ther is truth in fiction.

I gather the real point here is that life happens and we should not let false crises be used to dictate our lives.

Hay Jay

SPEW ALERT PLEASE !!!

"...you better ask God if he takes plastic before offering up Nancy Pelosi!"

That was HYSTERICAL.
However, yet ANOTHER call to my IT department to replace my keyboard, having fouled it once again with diet Pepsi and snot.

There's no money
in asteroid warning systems, Mr. Goldberg. Globull warning, however, will make a few people very rich.

Jerseyvet @ 6:58 am
Very good analogy. There is an even more frightening parallel with the Aztecs. Since human beings expire CO2, how long will it be before the elite scientists and despotic politicians tell the common folk we should off ourselves for the well-being of the planet? Think about it...cap and trade legislation following closely on the heels of health care reform. Perhaps in their mandatory end of life counseling sessions, seniors and terminally ill patients will be told they can not only save the government money, but also save the planet by choosing death!

If Only
the Left could learn to spend their money on matters that would REALLY improve life for all of us. Oh yeah, I forgot - they really put no value on lives other than their own. Always did admire those Christians thrown into the lion's den. Be not afraid. He goes before us always. Out of the goodness of O's heart...

It has been prophesied!
It is in the Bible. The Cubs will make it to the World Series. With the score tied in the bottom of the ninth in game seven, the meteor will strike!

What happens when the idiots behind
the fake Global Warming give us an ice age instead? That's what their models predicted back in the 1970s... Small input changes to the models give wildly divergent results.

If we're hit by a big rock, let's hope it's soon. That way, I won't have to her Pelosi-Reid-Obama bloviate about health care reform.

Paul in AZ
Is that the series between the D'Backs and Cubs?

We are getting hit with a meteor
The meteor is our President. He is abetted by congress.


And what about the flood of Noah?
There is a scientific theory gaining ground that the flood of Noah (and Gilgamesh) was caused by a giant meteorite splashing down into the ocean around 4800 B.C.. This caused gigantic tsunamis (hundreds of feet high) and torrential downpours, wiping out hundreds of thousands of people. (The 2004 Indian ocean tsunami wiped out 200,000 people in hours. And those waves were less than 100 feet high. What would a tsunami 500 feet high do?)

Scientists have found the remains of an underwater impact site which looks to be just about that old, as well as others.

http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/200806/asteroids
and also
http://www.nytimes.com/2006/11/14/science/14WAVE.html?scp=1 &sq=ancient+crash&st=nyt

The earth is only 5000 years old
Global warming is made up.

LOL

SteveL
Thanks for the link..Interesting

Wormwood
"And the third angel sounded, and there fell a great star from heaven, burning as it were a lamp, and it fell upon the third part of the rivers, and upon the fountains of waters; And the name of the star is called Wormwood: and the third part of the waters became wormwood; and many men died of the waters, because they were made bitter."

-- Revelation 8:10-11

There was considerable talk in the '80s about whether this passage refers to Chernobyl. Some writers and broadcasters reported incorrectly that the name is Ukrainian for _wormwood_. It actually refers to a related species, mugwort.

An asteroid, comet, or nuclear weapon is plausible; but these verses may refer to a literal star. One candidate: WR104, a binary system in the constellation Sagittarius. The more massive star looks like a good candidate for a gamma-ray burst. GRBs are the most energetic events since the Big Bang. Last March a greatly red-shifted GRB was briefly visible to the naked eye at a distance of 7.5 billion light years. That's how powerful these things are.

There's some evidence that a GRB perhaps 5,000 light years away caused the mass extinction at the Ordovician-Silurian boundary, during which the earth's oceans may have frozen over. WR 104 is about the same distance away (5,000-8,000 light years -- estimates differ). Worse, it seems to be aimed at us.

A direct blast from a GRB that close might blow away much of the ozone layer, allowing greater UV penetration. This, in turn, would cause the formation of NO2, which would cause significant global cooling. It would also dissociate into nitrous acid. The waters would probably turn sour, not bitter;, but you get the idea.

Sometime later, the trailing cosmic radiation -- extremely enegergetic particles traveling near the speed of light -- would strike, causing further trouble.

Phil & Paul,
Take me out during the ball game. And it should happen on 4th of July -- great fireworks show, while I eat my hot dog. How fitting. Except the game will have to be called, on account of showers. Rescheduled, of course.

If we get "rained on," whatcha gonna do? We just might be able to avoid it, if we as a nation, and as individuals, turn our hearts back to God. Worth a try.

Otherwise, you may have to take the long way home after the game.

Tyler in WA
"The earth is only 5000 years old
Global warming is made up.

LOL"

OK, I'm convinced. It was probably all those global warming conferences held during blizzards. To show my commitment, I pledge to keep my energy usage to below that of your cult leader Algore.

Guess we better just give up
Since we're all going to die via meteor and can forget about climate change, we might as well just stop building roads and bridges and trying to go to college and caring about our children. I mean, it's all going to end in a big ball of flame right? What a bummer man. I'm just gonna mope around and drink all day until we all die from your meteor in 2109.

Con Logic, or lack thereof
"... we cannot control nature."

And yet we change it every day. Such a bland statement as yours has no meaning in a scientific discussion.

--------------
"Chicago-Coldest July on record
New York-Coldest June since 1958"

And yet Seattle is having a record heat wave. Is there some brain chemistry that blinds Cons to science? I'm thinking the Earth means only Chicago and New York this week, but some other city next week for Cons.
------------------
"So the obvious solution to excess CO2 is to plant trees or other plants. Even grass will work fine. "

Yes, but wouldn't that spark yet another Con uprising against other scientists, i.e. environmental science? Cons don;t understand much about science, and yet propose scientific solutions that would "control nature". I don't get Cons.
-----------------
"I gather the real point here is that life happens and we should not let false crises be used to dictate our lives."

If any small group of people can suddenly decide they are smarter than 95% of the world's scientists and tell us what a real crises is, then we are living in Con World.
-----------------
"What happens when the idiots behind the fake Global Warming give us an ice age instead? That's what their models predicted back in the 1970s..."

Are you speaking of the small group of scientists who did not represent consensus? I thought so. If you were a scientists (or at least a reader) you would know this. Funny thing is that by all natural accounts, we should be heading slooooowly into a cold spell. Knowing that man can and is changing that is important to the argument -- something Cons tend to gloss over or ignore.
---------------
"It was probably all those global warming conferences held during blizzards."

Or those help in heat waves. Why so Cons choose the cities and dates convenient only to them, while real scientists are using the Globe (if you missed it, we are speaking of Global warming, not Seattle warming.)

HILARIOUS!
VERY FUNNY TAKE ON ADOLESCENT DISASTER FANTASY ... I LUV THE COMMENTS FROM CHRISTIANS WHO CAN SMUGLY QUOTE SCRIPTURE. UNREGULATED ECONOMIC GROWTH, BAD. CONTROLING NATURE GOOD. HOW'S THAT BEEN GOING FOR YA?

wingnut fantasy
Wow! I mean, ....Wow!
That was about the most disturbing attempt at humor I've run into in some time.
Have you considered therapy?
Seriously.

Hahahah
This post is hilarious! Gosh, is this what Neocon reasoning has come to? What exactly would Jonah have us do? Pour billions into some kind of planetary missile defense shield? Why not address the things we can and let the rest handle itself? If we're all going to die of an asteroid, why stress? Oh Jonah, you are a treasure.

Oh, what you missed
With all due respect (how much is due, I leave to fellow readers), the idea isn't to control nature. The idea is to not mess it up more than we already have. If you were old enough to remember when you could barely walk three blocks in a U.S. city without having to duck into an office building to exchange the polluted air in your lungs for something made a little cleaner by their HVAC, you would know that Federal regulations work. Your life is better for the ones we put in place -- and enforced -- before you were born.

Live Birth Record
If that dirty muslin Nobama would just show his birthcertificate that would protect us all from meteors and prolly eve assteroids (and might even cure jonah's hemorrhiods).

USA USA USA

.................Asteroids?
...T---The what?

o_O


SteveL, Reply # 31
And what about the flood of Noah?
There is a scientific theory gaining ground that the flood of Noah (and Gilgamesh) was caused by a giant meteorite splashing down into the ocean around 4800 B.C..
=====================================================
While such an event certainly explains why people 2,000 years ago would write about a global flood, there is still no proof that anyone rode out the flood in a boat filled with two of every animal.

The big one...
Did you and Sean sit around last weekend and make this up just for laughs?? Did you call Beck just for grins to get his feedback?? Have you changed your meds lately?? Maybe you should...Please don't write anymore on subjects that are WAY above your pay grade and reality is darkened by your presence even close to a discussion about the subjects.

You are a stupid man so please keep your un-informed opinions to yourself..you can include sean and beck if you want. that still makes the total IQ power less than 10.

Five hours?
Actually, the Tunguska asteroid would only have had to arrive a little over two minutes later to remove St. Petersburg--that's Leningrad for all your Leftist readers--from the map, due to the Earth's orbiting the sun at 107,300 kph. Its course must be assumed to be independent of the Earth's, which makes their intersections that much more unlikely: the window was more like 20 minutes than the two days the "five hour" comment implies.

Still, great column, and it's pointed me at some very interesting reading!
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.