If Maclean's (and Steyn) lose, it could face unspecified fines. Even more
troubling, according to Canadian law and tribunal precedents, Maclean's
could be ordered to publish something it doesn't want to publish, and be
barred in perpetuity from publishing anything the human rights commission
deems "Islamophobic."
It might be easy for some to dismiss all of this. After all, we're talking
about Canada.
But this is just the latest in a long parade of assaults on free speech,
including the aftermath of the Danish Muhammad cartoons and the murder of
Dutch filmmaker Theo van Gogh. Sometimes it seems like a lot of people see
free speech as "an American concept," thus in need of rethinking.
As the Atlantic's Ross Douthat observed, the New York Times' only story on
the case suggested "that the 1st Amendment is a peculiar and quite possibly
outdated feature of the American political system, along the lines of, say,
the electoral college or the District of Columbia's lack of congressional
representation." By implication, it also lumped Steyn in with rabid Nazis
and Holocaust deniers.
Without outlining what Steyn wrote, the Times launched into a discussion of
how "hate speech" is treated in the U.S. and elsewhere. Quoth the Times:
"Canada, England, France, Germany, the Netherlands, South Africa, Australia
and India all have laws or have signed international conventions banning
hate speech. Israel and France forbid the sale of Nazi items like swastikas
and flags. It is a crime to deny the Holocaust in Canada, Germany and
France."
Left out of this fascinating tour of speech-control laws around the globe:
Mark Steyn is no Nazi, and whatever one makes of his arguments, it is
disgusting to insinuate otherwise. If Steyn were in the crosshairs for
defending abortion rights, I suspect the New York Times would be more
careful about leaping to Nazi comparisons.
But it seems that throughout the West, "leaders" are willing to accommodate
those who would stifle, intimidate or, ultimately, ban free speech, all in
the name of "tolerance." You could read all about it in Steyn's book. It's
not banned -- yet.
|