The Democrats' Witch-Hunt Against Conservatives Just Ramped Up
Rashida Tlaib's Meltdown Over 'Death of America' Chants Begs a Key Question
The First Black Swan
John Fetterman Has Another Encounter With Pro-Palestinian Protesters
OJ's Death Permits Racism
What it Takes to be a Good Black Politician or Pundit
AP Really Wants You to Believe Illegal Aliens Are the Key to a...
Rand Paul Promises to Drop the Veil On the 'Great COVID Cover-Up'
The Importance of US-Iraq Relations
Crippling Cyberattack Brings U.S. HealthCare System to a Halt
Trans Activists On The Wrong Side of History
The America First Approach Offers HOPE, Support for Women and Children
The Empire Strikes Again – in Ethiopia
The Threat of Modern School Counselors in Public School
Trump Snaps At Hostile Reporter Who Questioned His Abortion Stance
Tipsheet

Is Roe Settled Law? Sotomayor Thinks So

Guest post from Charmaine Yoest 

A significant moment arrived in the hearing this morning as Sen. Herb Kohl (D-Wis) turned to questioning Judge Sotomayor, albeit briefly, on the abortion issue and the “right to privacy” underlying Roe v. Wade.  Sotomayor replied that she does agree that Roe is “settled law” as follows:

Advertisement

KOHL: All right. Judge, the court’s ruling about the right to privacy in Griswold laid the foundation for Roe v. Wade. In your opinion, is Roe settled law?

SOTOMAYOR: The court’s decision in Planned Parenthood v. Casey reaffirmed the court holding of Roe. That is the precedent of the court and settled, in terms of the holding of the court.

KOHL: Do you agree with Justices Souter, O’Connor, and Kennedy in their opinion in Casey, which reaffirmed the core holding in Roe?

SOTOMAYOR: As I said, I — Casey reaffirmed the holding in Roe. That is the Supreme Court’s settled interpretation of what the core holding is and its reaffirmance of it. [Transcript via Los Angeles Times.]

This question of Roe as settled law goes to a central point in the testimony we’ll be providing on Thursday morning:  Roe is not settled law.  The holding in Roe establishing the right to abortion has been substantially modified in subsequent cases - even Casey while reaffirming the central holding of Roe, modified the standard of review applied to abortion regulations.  As Roe and it’s successors continue to be repeatedly reconsidered, it is anything but settled law.

Charmaine Yoest President and CEO of Americans United for Life

Advertisement

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement