On Thursday afternoon, as promised by Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY), the Senate voted on the border bill that already failed in February. As expected, the bill failed once more, with a vote of 43-50 in favor of advancing the legislation. Not only did it fail, but there were more senators against the bill this time than there were before. The vote was previously 49-50.
The bill from February was the product of months of negotiations between Sens. Chris Murphy (D-CT), Kyrsten Sinema (I-AZ), and James Lankford (R-OK). This time, however, Sinema and Lankford voted against moving forward. Sens. Cory Booker (D-NJ) and Laphonza Butler (D-CA) also were new "no" votes.
Senate votes 43-50, on border bill, well short of 60, as expected. All vulnerable Dems voted for it though, which was the point.
— Burgess Everett (@burgessev) May 23, 2024
Dem flips: Booker and Butler vote no
— Burgess Everett (@burgessev) May 23, 2024
Sanders, Markey and Padilla are also nos, as they were before
The vote, taking place just before the Memorial Day weekend, was expected from the start to surely fail. Even if it did somehow pass the Senate, Speaker Mike Johnson (R-LA) and the rest of House Republican leadership have repeatedly reminded that the bill would be "dead on arrival."
Even with the result being an expected one, Schumer still took to social media to lament the outcome and throw out accusations against Republican opposed to the bill. Of course, members of his own party opposed it as well.
Senate Republicans again rejected the strongest, most comprehensive bipartisan border bill we've seen in decades.
— Chuck Schumer (@SenSchumer) May 23, 2024
A sad day.
While the GOP isn't interested today in getting this done—we’ll keep trying.
It’s too important to our national security, our communities, our country.
Recommended
House Republicans have passed stronger measures that would actually do something to fix the crisis at the southern border. Just over a year ago now, the House passed HR 2, the Secure the Border Act. There was some bipartisan support from House Democrats, and even Sen. John Fetterman (D-PA) expressed willingness to support of the bill.
A pinned post from Republicans on the House Committee on Homeland Security calls to mind the passage of HR 2. The Committee has also posted and reposted about the need for real border security.
Biden’s broken borders are ground zero for heinous child trafficking and sexual assault.
— Mike Lee (@SenMikeLee) May 21, 2024
The Democrats’ do-nothing bill won’t change that.
H.R. 2 will.
We must secure the border. pic.twitter.com/EuiVXBm8FT
Since Senate Dems are now pretending to care about border security, we'd like to remind them that, over one year ago, @HouseGOP passed the strongest border security bill in history—and Schumer ignored it. https://t.co/EQbDn2Avpr
— House Homeland GOP (@HomelandGOP) May 21, 2024
.@SenSchumer's attempt to revive the Senate's ineffective 'border security bill' won't fool the American people. The crisis at our Southern Border demands real action, and H.R. 2 is the solution.
— Congressman Kevin Hern (@repkevinhern) May 20, 2024
It's time to prioritize national security and put an end to the chaos.
It's been 375 days since @HouseGOP PASSED the strongest border security bill in history.
— House Homeland GOP (@HomelandGOP) May 20, 2024
Sadly, Senate Dems have chosen to ignore this legislation, and instead focus on a bill that they cannot even pass themselves.
The American people deserve better, Leader Schumer. https://t.co/qskXiD7X8o
Among the criticisms of the Senate border bill includes how the bill will not actually do anything for border security.
The Biden administration created the border crisis and has refused to take action to end it.
— Rep. Eric Burlison (@RepEricBurlison) May 21, 2024
Now they are trying to fool the American people by pushing a bill they say will end it. (Newsflash: it won’t.)
Don’t believe the spin! https://t.co/Ydcs6HozID
NumbersUSA CEO James Massa also provided Townhall with a statement explaining further how bad the bill is.
"To frame the Senate bill as 'tough on illegal immigration' is an insult to anyone who has read the bill and the height of political cynicism. The American people demand and deserve much better than this," he said, also highlighting how it has to do with the election. "In what can only be described as an election-year political stunt, the Senate border bill failed to pass for a second time today. Every Senator who voted to advance this legislation in effect affirmatively pledged support for continued illegal immigration and President Biden's abuse of his executive powers regarding immigration policy. Although H.R. 2, the Secure the Border Act, passed by the House of Representatives last May, would actually bring an end to the border crisis, not one provision from it was included."
"The Senate bill codifies catch-and-release each year of up to 510,000 inadmissible aliens into law and increases legal immigration by 250,000 over five years.The Senate bill was the opposite of being tough illegal immigration. The truly bipartisan aspect of this bill was that significant representation of Senators by both parties voted to defeat it," Massa also explained.
While the White House has gone back and forth teasing about President Joe Biden executive action on the border, Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre still continues to push a bad bill. During Wednesday's press briefing, Jean-Pierre was awfully dismissive about the idea of the president stepping in to actually do something.
"But why should he have to do it unilaterally," Jean-Pierre wondered during her back and forth with a reporter. "What I will say is it is long past time to get this done, to get this moving. We were able to get a bipartisan negotiation--a plan forward on an issue that many Americans care about, an issue that matters for our immigration system, for what’s happening at the border. And that’s a good thing," Jean-Pierre also claimed, as if the bill wasn't so disastrous.
Speaking about Schumer, Jean-Pierre offered that "the senator is--is very good at this. He’s very good at dealing with big legislation, obviously, as we’ve been able to move important legislation through over the past three and a half years. So, I’m going to let him speak to that." With such comments, one wouldn't that the bill was about to fail as spectacularly as it did.
Biden's taken plenty of executive actions, including on his very first day in office, to make the crisis even worse, while Jean-Pierre and others then go on to blame Republicans.
Reporter: "You opened the briefing by saying it’s up to Republicans to do something to solve the [border crisis]...The president has the authority to do something about this unilaterally...Why isn’t he doing anything?
— Townhall.com (@townhallcom) May 22, 2024
KJP: "But why should he have to do it unilaterally?"… pic.twitter.com/QSJZQCI7A8
Again, such a vote has to do with the deeply unpopular incumbent president and vulnerable Democratic incumbents being up for reelection. "The Senate voted down the bipartisan border bill Thursday, marking the second time it has been blocked in a matter of months as Democrats look to shore up their political troubles and give President Biden and incumbent senators a boost in the process," coverage from The Hill began.
Among those voting in favor of the bill included Sen. Sherrod Brown of Ohio, who is facing Republican Bernie Moreno in a true "Toss-Up" race.
Moreno was quick to release a statement. "Sherrod Brown has spent his decades-long political career supporting amnesty and allowing hundreds of thousands of illegal immigrants to come into our country, take jobs away from Ohioans and drive down the wages of the workers that Sherrod claims to support," he noted. "Brown sat back as he watched Joe Biden reverse the 94 executive orders that secured our border. If he really wanted to stop the illegal invasion of our country, he’d push to have those executive orders reinstated. No matter how hard Brown tries to cover his tracks with a Border Bill In Name Only, Ohioans know that he puts illegal immigrants first and Ohioans last."
Sherrod Brown supported every open border policy and rejected any attempt to stop illegal immigration in his 30 years in DC.
— Bernie Moreno (@berniemoreno) May 23, 2024
When choosing between better pay and safeguarding American jobs versus illegal aliens, he’s always been on the side of the illegals. pic.twitter.com/4Ixa7YsP0S
Join the conversation as a VIP Member