It’s Going to Be JD and Kamala, So Calm Down
Why Hawaii's Lt. Gov Just Got Indicted
The NYT Reported on the State of the Democratic Party. It's a Total...
This Senate Dem Candidate Is Going to Be Left All Alone. She Should...
Former CBS News Reporter: There Might Be Proof Showing Bidens Were Blackmailed by...
Of Course, the Indiana Fever Did This Over Sophie Cunningham's Stance on Men...
Health Care Provider Roasted by Appeals Court Over Firing Remote Worker Over COVID...
Hate Is Losing in Michigan (but the Race Isn’t Over Yet)
If It’s Good Enough for Wartime, It’s Good Enough for Peacetime
Either Or
What's in a Name?
Uncle Sam Gave Him a Work Permit, Then Arrested Him for Working
'No Drama’ Jay Clayton Is the Right Choice for Director of National Intelligence
Data Centers Aren’t the Problem. Scarcity Politics Is.
Florida Supreme Court Smacks Down Florida Bar for Targeting Conservative Attorney’s Free S...
Tipsheet

Blue States Score Major Court Victory Over Trump Administration Thanks to Obama-Appointed Judge

Blue States Score Major Court Victory Over Trump Administration Thanks to Obama-Appointed Judge
AP Photo/Brennan Linsley, File

A federal judge has blocked the Trump administration’s plan to slash public health grants and other funding to four blue states over concerns about fraud.

U.S. District Judge Manish Shah, an Obama appointee, on Thursday issued a temporary restraining order prohibiting the White House from cutting public health grants that had been awarded to Illinois and the other plaintiffs, which include California, New York, and Colorado.

Advertisement

The primary issue in this case centers on whether federal agencies can suddenly stop public health funding grants that state and local governments rely on for programs like HIV prevention and lead poisoning screening. Judge Shah ruled that “plaintiffs have established a likelihood of success in demonstrating that defendants have taken final agency action amounting to guidance or directives to review grants awarded to plaintiffs for termination based on arbitrary, capricious, or unconstitutional rationales.”

Shah reasoned that Illinois and the other states would likely win their case and that the federal government was violating federal law by trying to slash this funding without proper justification or following the proper procedures.

The court’s ruling dealt with several important legal questions about whether the federal government is allowed to cancel grants that were already approved and being used for public health programs. The judge insisted that “plaintiffs have shown that they would suffer irreparable harm from the agency action.” This means the damage to public health programs would be severe enough that it couldn’t easily be fixed later.

Advertisement

Judge Shah concluded that “the balance of equities and public interest favor plaintiffs because the public interest is not harmed by temporarily enjoining arbitrary and capricious and unlawful agency action.”

The temporary restraining order requires federal officials to “immediately treat any actions taken to implement or enforce directive to identify and terminate public-health grants awarded to plaintiffs based on undisclosed agency priorities, as null, void, and rescinded.”

This legal battle comes as the result of the White House ordering the CDC to claw back hundreds of millions of dollars in grants, claiming they were “inconsistent with agency priorities” and overly focused on health equity initiatives.

The New York Times noted that the grants support a wide range of programs, including HIV and sexually transmitted infection prevention, post‑pandemic workforce recruitment, modernizing data systems, and preparedness for health emergencies in California, Colorado, Illinois, and Minnesota.

Advertisement

The Trump administration has justified the cuts by pointing to evidence of widespread government welfare fraud in these states — especially Minnesota, whose leadership has fallen under scrutiny for allowing fraudsters to steal up to $9 billion in taxpayer funds.

Editor’s Note: Do you enjoy Townhall’s conservative reporting that takes on the radical left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.

Join Townhall VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement