The Republicans Are Really a Mess
Does Biden Have Any Influence on the World Stage? Don't Ask Karine Jean-Pierre.
Police Provide Update on Man Who Lit Himself on Fire Outside Trump Trial
'Low-Grade Propaganda': Bill Introduced to Defund Liberal NPR
Democrats Give More Credence to Donald Trump's Talk of a 'Rigged Witch Hunt'
Colbert Takes His Democratic Party Road Show to the Convention, and Jesse Watters...
The Power of Forgiveness
New Report Confirms Trump Won't Receive a Fair Trial
Karine Jean-Pierre References Charlottesville When Confronted About Pro-Hamas Chants
Biden's Title IX Rewrite Is Here
It's Been Almost a Week Since Iran Attacked Israel, Yet These Democrats Stayed...
Following England’s Lead, Another Country Will Stop Prescribing Puberty Blockers
The Five Stone Strategy of Defeating the Islamic Regime in Iran
Another Republican Signs on to Oust Johnson
Biden’s Education Secretary Vowed to Shut Down the Largest Christian University in the...
Tipsheet

Weigel on Notre Dame's Mistake

George Weigel explains why it was such a travesty for one of the nation's premier Catholic universities to invite President Barack Obama to deliver its commencement speech and accept an honorary degree.
Advertisement


Two observations come to mind.  First, it's remarkable how often those who are more conservative are asked to view the speech of those more to the left as nothing more than part of a "conversation" -- and how the episode is posed as a test of open-mindedness.  It's hard to imagine it working the other way, however -- students (or alums) of U Cal-Berkeley  being asked to tolerate, say, a speech from Sarah Palin on the grounds that it's nothing more than part of a big "conversation."  And make no mistake -- they wouldn't tolerate it.

The second, larger issue raised by the  Notre Dame debacle is just how much the Church or its institutions can countenance (or even celebrate) views that are antithetical to Church teachings without losing its identity.  It's the religious equivalent of wondering just how big a "tent" the GOP can have and still remain the GOP.

Certainly, any group based on ideas or beliefs -- religious or political -- generally wants to grow its membership, because a larger membership means enhanced influence.  But where is the tipping point, where expansion means changing the core nature of the group to the extent that it no longer stands for what it used to?

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement