‘Not in the Mood to Negotiate’: Trump Heads to the Situation Room
Here Are More Details About the Detention of MN Dem Assassin Suspect's Wife
Here's What Happened When One Million Illegals Self-Deported
Adios, Señor Padilla
Why Dick Durbin Should Tread Carefully With These Remarks About Political Violence
How the Left-Wing Corporate Media Works
Do We Go to War to Prevent Iran from Having Nuclear Weapons?
Hit 'em Hard and Again
Peppering Trade Policy Too Much Could Leave Voters Salty
The Last Mile
Worker Freedom Starts in the States
Louisiana Gov. Jeff Landry’s Lawsuits Betray Trump’s Energy Agenda
Trump Closes Notorious EPA Lab that Conducted Illegal Human Experiments
Left-Wing Groups Paying Influencers to Spread Coordinated Anti-ICE Propaganda
CA Dem Blasted for Medicaid Fearmongering After Voting to Hike Taxes, Gut Benefits,...
OPINION

21st-Century Politics: A Minus-Sum Game Where Everybody Loses

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.

"A simple recipe for violence: promise a lot, deliver a little. Lead people to believe they will be much better off, but let there be no dramatic improvement." The brilliant political scientist Aaron Wildavsky wrote these words in 1968 while America was engulfed in race riots and anti-war protests. Sadly, his words from long ago eerily describe the politics of 21st-century America.

Advertisement

President Barack Obama and his recent predecessors have been good about promising a lot but delivering little.

The current crusade to raise the minimum wage is a perfect example. Regardless of whether or not it makes sense, the impact doesn't measure up to the problems it is supposed to solve.

Will it help reduce poverty? Perhaps a bit. The Congressional Budget Office estimates it will lift 900,000 people out of poverty over the course of a few years. But the government says nearly 50 million people are officially living in poverty. So, raising the minimum wage might help about 2 percent of the poor move from just below the poverty line to just above it. And the people it helps are not the ones who need it most. The poorest of the poor lack jobs of any kind.

Back in 1968, Wildavsky said such symbolic political gestures create "minus-sum games in which every player leaves the contest worse off than when he entered." In the case of the minimum wage, Obama could fail to accomplish his goal and disappoint his base. However, when symbolic issues pass, it can be even worse because "it soon becomes clear that nothing has changed."

Advertisement

Minus-sum games are the norm in American politics today. Issues are raised, and symbolic solutions are proposed. If the proposed solution doesn't get passed, the losing team gets angry. If it does get passed, nothing changes.

The problem of promising a lot and delivering little is especially true of the president's health care law. Symbolically, it was supposed to insure the uninsured, reduce costs for everyone else, and improve service. There were no downsides in the symbolic version of the plan. If you liked your insurance or your doctor, you were told you could keep it.

Now that the law has passed, the reality doesn't measure up. Even those who have experienced little disruption are disappointed solely because the promises were much loftier. The president led people to believe they would be better off, and they're not. Not surprisingly, national frustration with the law is growing daily.

Obama, of course, is not alone in this approach. Republicans do it, too. They continually rail against government spending but fail to propose anything more than symbolic gestures to slow down the growth.

Advertisement

The core problem is that both political parties in Washington promise that the federal government can fix every problem. But the truth is it can't. To solve the challenges before our nation, we need an all-hands approach that unleashes the creativity and resources of individual Americans, community groups, churches, small businesses, state and local governments, and more.

This will certainly mean a smaller role for the federal government, but it will put the problem-solving responsibility where it belongs -- with the American people.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement