US Women's Soccer Will Get Half of Men's World Cup Winnings for Doing...
With the 2022 Midterms Over, These Old Stories About Biden Are Resurfacing
A Letter to Christian Voters in Georgia
Soldiers Take an Oath to Defend America, Not a Rainbow Flag
In a Winter of Discontent, Americans Vote for the Status Quo
Elon Musk Should Tell EU Censors to Bugger Off
Do Better, Apple
Still Against the 'Dead Consensus'
Shooting the Starting Pistol at Ron DeSantis
DeSantis Leads Biden In Hypothetical Poll While Trump Trails Behind
U.S. Supreme Court to Review Biden's Student Loan Debt 'Forgiveness' Plan, Leaving Program...
Kanye West Was on Alex Jones' Show and It Went Totally Off the...
Kristi Noem Bans TikTok: 'Like Digital Fentanyl'
Katie Hobbs’ Office Threatened County Board With Arrest If They Didn’t Certify Results
House Republicans Vote Against Banning Earmarks: 'Shameful Display of Swamp Politics'
OPINION

What's So Bad about the Reid Plan?

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.
The big sticking points between the House GOP leadership and Sen. Harry Reid’s latest plan are 1) the House wants two debt increases, one this year and one next year (Reid has just one increase) and 2) the House Republicans want a guaranteed balanced-budget-amendment vote. 


Regarding the Reid plan itself, it really looks like a Republican plan: A $2.7 trillion spending cut to raise the debt ceiling by something like $2.5 trillion, and no tax revenues. So, really, what’s so bad about the Reid plan? Increasingly, Wall Street gurus want one debt-ceiling increase, not two. 

The Reid package includes $1.2 trillion in discretionary-spending cuts and a small $100 billion savings in mandatory accounts, apparently from the Biden meetings, although it will not impact either health care or Social Security. 

There are other nicks and knacks from waste, fraud, and abuse, fees on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, revenues from spectrum sales, and some sort of farm-subsidy reform. And there is, of course, a huge $1 trillion piece from winding down the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. But that’s also in the budgets from Paul Ryan and the CBO. Interest savings come to $400 billion. 

Reid’s plan also includes a Mitch McConnell-like joint-congressional committee to find future savings. The committee’s recommendations will be guaranteed an up-or-down Senate vote without amendments by the end of 2011. 


The GOP House plan undoubtedly has more real spending reduction. Plus, the balanced-budget amendment, which makes it consistent with cut, cap, and balance. 

But the Reid no-tax piece is really important in terms of economic growth. At least things may not get worse on the tax front. 

Finally, all these plans hinge on tough enforcement for the spending caps. In particular, first-year 2012 savings, and then sequestration penalties. It just looks like the House and Senate are coming together.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Video