In Violation of Federal Law, Justice Jackson Didn't Disclose a Number of Payments
One Media Campaign Against Trump Appears to Have Failed Spectacularly
MSNBC Host Tests New Talking Point to Prepare for Biden’s Possible Obliteration in...
CNN Steps on a Rake With This Segment About Trump Supporters
Is This the Next FTX?
Germans -- Even During the Hitler Era -- Were a Better People Than...
'Wildest Year Ever in NJ Politics' As Democrat Power Broker Indicted on Racketeering...
Here's Why New York Democrats Are Now Looking to Ban Masks
Former Harris Aide Identifies the One Republican She Believes Would Be the ‘Greatest...
One State Is Taking Action Against Pfizer Over COVID-19 Vaccine
Biden Announces 'Mass Amnesty' for Hundreds of Thousands of Illegal Immigrants
Sorry, Libs, Recent Poll Shows Trump Hush Money Circus Didn't Damage Him
Remember That ‘Trans Woman’ Who Went Topless at the Biden White House? Well…
Let's Talk About That Weird Viral Video of Obama Escorting a 'Frozen' Biden...
Medicare's Drug Price Program Needs to Protect Patients—and Doctors Can Help

A Baby Died at the Abortion Clinic, and This is Supposed To Be News

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of

In Hialeah, Florida, in 2006, a woman walked into an abortion clinic, and the doctor lost the patient. That is, the baby was born. Only then was it deposited in the biohazard bag, where it eventually died.


Oddly enough, people are upset over this abortion-clinic faux pas. Even the greenest new hire of a D&C'er knows, first you kill the child, then you deliver it and put it in the garbage.

The woman, Sycloria Williams, who was 23 weeks pregnant at the time, is now suing the doctor, the staff and the clinic. She had given birth while having to wait for the doctor, Pierre Jean-Jacques Renelique, who wasn't at the clinic. Renelique has had his license revoked and is subject to a criminal investigation.

The Associated Press reports that the case "has shocked people on both sides of the abortion debate." It's hard to understand why. The woman went to the clinic to rid herself of a baby, because that is what the clinic does, and that is what the clinic did. So a couple of steps were reversed; the end result was the same.

If a fire swept through a chamber at Auschwitz just before the insertion of the poison gas, would Heinrich Himmler have lost any sleep, let alone launched inquiries? Abortion advocates are at serious risk of putting procedure over principle here, and how many more patients might be lost if that happens?

So really, why all the fuss? One suspects that the reason might be over something other than a mere technical goof. It could be that the little mistake exposes the abortion movement's big lie: that a baby "isn't a baby" till it's born. 


In abortion doctrine, when a "tumor of the womb" passes through the birth canal into the open air, it suddenly becomes a living child. This Miracle of Transpostvagination is a great mystery and must be, can only be accepted by faith. A true believer cannot allow himself to doubt that life occurs only after birth and not a moment before. Such doubt would lead to a moral crisis of great proportions. A practitioner of abortion who realizes he doesn't know when life begins is in danger of becoming a monster in his own eyes. A doubting advocate faces a similar fate.

This is what makes the Hialeah apostasy so grave: by treating the living in the same grisly fashion they treat supposedly unwanted invasive tissue, they showed that they knew abortion is murder and proceeded with the same rote callousness as always; it was just another day at the office. The accidental birth wasn't hailed as miraculous, it was seen as just exceptionally bad timing. It ended the same way regardless because the victim was the same to them regardless: alive before birth, alive after birth, but too inconvenient to live.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member


Trending on Townhall Videos