Did Joe Biden Fall Asleep at a Memorial Day Ceremony?
These Dems Were Too Busy Coddling Terrorists to Know What Memorial Day Means
Here's What Jason Kelce Told His Wife When She Was Venting About Harrison...
Taiwan's New President Is Taking a Page From the Reagan Playbook
(Corporate) Charity Cases
Oregon Movement to Join 'Greater Idaho' Picks up Steam
Recognizing Palestine
Here's How the Biden Administration Is Reportedly Handling Iran Nuclear Deal
Here's What Squad Members Think Memorial Day Is About
Pete Hegseth Reveals the Stakes, Need to 'Save' the Pentagon After Military Labeled...
How Do New Yorkers Feel About Pro-Hamas Campus Chaos? Here's What a New...
Newsom Signs Radical Pro-Abortion Legislation in Response to Arizona’s Pro-Life Law
There's Been Some Real Red Flags About How the Bidens Are Handling Hunter's...
Jack Smith Files Gag Order Request Against Trump for Lashing Out Over 'Deadly...
Biden Campaign Gets Dismantled by Tim Scott for Dishonest Ad

Gay benefits case appealed to Supreme Court

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.
WASHINGTON (BP) -- Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer is asking the U.S. Supreme Court to decide next term whether the Grand Canyon State will be forced to offer spousal benefits to the same-sex partners of state employees -- adding to the growing list of cases that could force the court to define marriage for the country.

The case stems from 2009, when Arizona -- seeking ways to cut state spending and close a $1.6 billion budget hole -- passed a law cutting the benefits for non-spouses of state employees. Gay activists sued, saying that because they cannot marry in Arizona, the new law discriminates against them.

Since then, it's been blocked as legal proceedings have gone forward. Both a federal district court judge and a three-judge panel of the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the state must continue offering the benefits to domestic partners of gay state employees. In April, the Ninth Circuit denied the state a re-hearing by a full 11-judge panel, prompting Brewer's appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Judge Diarmuid O'Scannlain disagreed with his colleagues at the Ninth, writing in a scathing dissent that they "all but expressly held that opposite-sex-only marriage rules are unconstitutional -- indeed, that such rules are irrational per se because they can rest only on a 'bare desire to harm a politically unpopular group.' … The panel concluded -- in a way that is veiled but unmistakable -- that rules benefiting only traditional marriage serve no conceivable rational purpose."

John Eastman, a lawyer with the National Organization for Marriage, told FoxNews.com that the state wasn't discriminating against anyone, since the benefits package in question didn't just go to same-sex domestic partners, but anyone maintaining a financial relationship with another person with whom he or she had been living for at least a year, including opposite-gender roommates. Only about seven percent of the people receiving the benefits were in homosexual relationships with state employees.


The court will decide whether to take the case when it reconvenes this autumn. But given the number of marriage cases piling up on its doorstep, it's likely the justices could make a pivotal ruling with far-reaching implications by next June.

In addition to Arizona's domestic-partner benefits case, two challenges to a major portion of the federal Defense of Marriage Act have been rolled into one and appealed to the high court. Meanwhile, the Ninth Circuit's decision striking down California Prop 8 -- which defines marriage as the union of one man and one woman -- is expected to be appealed to the Supreme Court in the next few weeks.

"The next Supreme Court term seems to be all about gay marriage," said CitizenLink Judicial Issues Analyst Bruce Hausknecht, "if the Court picks up any or all of these cases."

Compiled by staff of World News Service, where this story first appeared.

Copyright (c) 2012 Southern Baptist Convention, Baptist Press www.BPNews.net

Join the conversation as a VIP Member


Trending on Townhall Videos