On Friday, the political media class was abuzz with excitement. President Biden was traveling to Capitol Hill to personally lobby congressional Democrats on his legislative agenda, which had been bogged down amid partisan infighting. Surely this was a sign of meaningful progress, journos reasoned, because why else would the White House agree to put the president's prestige and reputation on the line in such a prominent way? Some Hill Republicans reached the same conclusion ahead of POTUS' visit:
.@RepBrianFitz makes a good point on the @GuyBensonShow: If Biden comes to the Hill and they *can’t* get BIF passed in relatively short order, he looks even weaker. Are they willing to put in him that position—if there’s a risk of failure? Or is this a sign BIF is happening…
— Guy Benson (@guypbenson) October 1, 2021
A number of Democratic leaders were chirping about optimism earlier in the day, and momentum seemed to be building toward some agreement or accommodation on reconciliation that would satisfy enough progressives to push through the bipartisan infrastructure bill ("BIF"). Speaker Pelosi had been unable to wrangle the votes on Thursday, but a Friday success would have amounted to an act of legislative wizardry from a self-described "master legislator." And Biden was lending his efforts to get it done. And then...nothing. Biden came and went in a matter of minutes, his message did not include a clear or strong message in favor of any particular course of action, and he departed with absolutely nothing resolved. If anything, the presidential show of force was actually a show of tepid, unfocused confusion – which, if anything, appeared to make unified action less likely. What was achieved? Anything?
Sent the big guns in, came out with no deadline, no vote, no agreement, and now no momentum? https://t.co/sx9Ozgx7wF
— Mary Katharine Ham (@mkhammer) October 1, 2021
Recommended
Over the weekend, Democrats and journalists marveled at the counter-productive pointlessness of it all:
“The fact that the president came to the Hill and whipped against his own bill is the strangest thing I’ve ever seen.” That late-night observation was just one of many we heard from frustrated lawmakers and senior aides stunned by what happened in the House on Friday. What senior Dems thought was going to happen: President JOE BIDEN was coming to the Hill to support Speaker NANCY PELOSI’s efforts to rally the party behind his historic $1.2 trillion bipartisan infrastructure plan ahead of a Friday vote. What ended up happening instead: Biden told them he wanted to hold off on BIF until there was a reconciliation deal — even if that means delaying the vote for several more days or even weeks. Biden’s move put Pelosi in a tough spot. She’d promised House moderates a vote on BIF this week, but the president himself blew up that timeframe — essentially forcing Pelosi to choose between breaking her promise and defying her president. BUT HERE’S WHERE THINGS GET REALLY INTERESTING: Some progressive Democrats suggested to their colleagues that the White House — at its most senior levels — gave them a green light to tank the BIF vote if Pelosi went ahead with it, we’re told from three congressional sources.
Biden rolled in, didn't support Pelosi's position (apparently to her surprise), and didn't support the immediate passage of his own agenda item – the Senate-passed BIF legislation that he'd helped negotiate and had fully endorsed. Biden himself suggested that the process could play out of the course of weeks, and the Speaker has punted until the end of the month. Consequently, moderate-leaning Democrats are furious that Pelosi violated her ironclad pledge to bring BIF to the floor for a vote last week (a promise that had angered leftists, who'd been promised reconciliation would come first):
The moderates are fuming that Pelosi broke her promise and Biden helped relink the infrastructure and reconciliation bills.
— Lindsey McPherson (@lindsemcpherson) October 2, 2021
Gottheimer: pic.twitter.com/q54p8GORt7
Over in the Senate, Arizona Democrat Kyrsten Sinema is sounding defiant, calling last week's drama "an ineffective stunt to gain leverage over a separate proposal":
“Democratic leaders have made conflicting promises that could not all be kept -- and have, at times, pretended that differences of opinion within our party did not exist, even when those disagreements were repeatedly made clear directly and publicly.”
— Burgess Everett (@burgessev) October 2, 2021
Meanwhile, left-wingers like AOC are digging in on the insane proposition that roughly $1.5 trillion in reconciliation spending (Joe Manchin's top line that Chuck Schumer has known about for months) is effectively "nothing":
— Lawrence B. Jones III (@LawrenceBJones3) October 2, 2021
Wait 'til she hears about this:
NEWS: WH aides planning how to make grueling cuts to Biden agenda to accommodate centrists
— Jeff Stein (@JStein_WaPo) October 2, 2021
Manchin's $1.5T "topline" = ~**60%** cut to Biden's plans
Wrenching choices of what gets left out:
Homelessness or climate?
Seniors or poor?
Hungry or sick?https://t.co/y20zdVH0BM
It's pretty wild to see this framed as spending "cuts," given that the agenda doesn't exist in law. But this is obviously saber-rattling, with the intent of jarring something loose. Deep distrust, toxic recriminations, and flailing mismanagement. Dems in disarray:
Punchbowl News' John Bresnahan: Democrat infighting is "incredibly toxic."
— RNC Research (@RNCResearch) October 3, 2021
Democrats say the White House staffers "don't know what they're doing." pic.twitter.com/jLKKERg3pL
This is also a very strange detail from a very strange presidential gambit:
INSIDE the caucus:
— Sarah Ferris (@sarahnferris) October 1, 2021
At the end of his remarks, BIDEN offered to take questions from members but his staff jumped in.
He didn't take any questions.
But is it really a surprise that a political operation that shields POTUS from taking questions from heavily-Democratic journalists also shields him from taking questions via literal elected Democrats? I'll leave you with these exchanges – c'mon, man:
WATCH: After avoiding questions for 4 days, Joe Biden snaps at reporter who asked, “why has it been so challenging to unite the party?” pic.twitter.com/eSdyPmGmSv
— RNC Research (@RNCResearch) October 1, 2021
gosh, wonder why they shield him from questions https://t.co/wdZuPMoyLB
— Guy Benson (@guypbenson) October 2, 2021
?? @GovChristie on WH strategy to shield Biden from answering sustained (or sometimes any) questions: “He can’t do it — and they are afraid to let him do it…It’s not a strategy. It is a capitulation to reality.” https://t.co/G0k4e6atkG pic.twitter.com/NSxR2SCPGc
— Guy Benson (@guypbenson) October 2, 2021
Join the conversation as a VIP Member