Editor's Note: This piece contains graphic content.
Erie Country District Attorney John Flynn on Saturday announced charges against Robert McCabe and Aaron Torgalski, the two Buffalo police officers caught on camera pushing 75-year-old Martin Gugino who failed to back up during a sweep of Niagara Square, near city hall. Gugino argued with McCabe and Torgalski, at which point they pushed him, causing him to stumble and fall. When Gugino fell back, he hit his head on the cement, where blood can be seen flowing from his head.
Warning: GRAPHIC CONTENT
WARNING: GRAPHIC CONTENT Video shows two police officers in Buffalo, New York, shoving a 75-year-old man to the ground. The sound of a crack is heard and blood trickles from the man’s head https://t.co/JOGKvPOjoD pic.twitter.com/TBqs4gelmi
— Reuters (@Reuters) June 5, 2020
One department officials received a copy of the video, both officers were placed on unpaid leave.
Flynn stated the two officers have been charged with second-degree assault. Both McCabe and Torgalski plead not guilty, were arraigned and released without bail. They are due to appear in court on July 20, The Hill reported.
Flynn told a local reporter he has an obligation to charge the two officers.
#UPDATE: @DAErieCountyNY John Flynn says he’s not choosing sides. He’s prosecuting 39 protestors in addition to suspended Buffalo police officers Robert McCabe and Aaron Torgalski. “My job is to prosecute those who break the law. Plain and simple,” Flynn says.
— Dave Greber (@DaveGreber4) June 6, 2020
#MORE: NYS law makes the assault charge a felony if the victim is 65 years old or older, and the perpetrator is at least 10 years younger, Flynn says. (Martin Gugino is 75.) “I can’t disregard that. I gotta do my job.”
— Dave Greber (@DaveGreber4) June 6, 2020
“This is the last thing I want to do here, to prosecute a teammate,” Flynn says.
— Dave Greber (@DaveGreber4) June 6, 2020
Recommended
#MORE: Flynn to question about what should have happened Thursday w/ Gugino: “You arrest him. You don’t take a baton and shove him, along with the officer next to him, and shove him. You properly arrest him, if he was committing a crime.”
— Dave Greber (@DaveGreber4) June 6, 2020
“This is the last thing I want to do here, to prosecute a teammate,” Flynn says.
— Dave Greber (@DaveGreber4) June 6, 2020
#MORE: Flynn to question about what should have happened Thursday w/ Gugino: “You arrest him. You don’t take a baton and shove him, along with the officer next to him, and shove him. You properly arrest him, if he was committing a crime.”
— Dave Greber (@DaveGreber4) June 6, 2020
When the officers left the DA's office, cheers erupted.
#UPDATE: Cheers erupt as suspended Buffalo police officers Robert McCabe and Aaron Torgalski leave the @DAErieCountyNY office after being arraigned on one count each of second degree assault. @news4buffalo pic.twitter.com/ima8KxyoZP
— Dave Greber (@DaveGreber4) June 6, 2020
Those in Buffalo appear to be at odds with one another over the incident. Mayor Byron Brown said the footage "was very difficult to watch" but it didn't provide all information. According to Brown, the police department has a first-aid protocol in place. Officers on the front lines are supposed to allow trained medics on the force to handle all first aid needs.
"So the officers in the front are not supposed to render assistance because right behind them, right by them, are others who are medics who are trained medically to provide assistance, and that is what happened," Byron said. "Assistance was provided to the gentleman that was pushed and fell, by others that were embedded with that grouping of officers that were right behind them. I don't think the cameras picked that up well."
After the two officers were put on unpaid leave, all 57 members of the Buffalo Police Department Emergency Response Team resigned. They did so in support of McCabe and Torgalski.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member