One of the problems in trying to select a leader for any large
organization or institution is the tendency to start out looking for
Superman, passing up many good people who fail to meet that standard,
and eventually ending up settling for a warm body.
Some Republicans seem to be longing for another Ronald Reagan.
Good luck on that one, unless you are prepared to wait for several
generations. Moreover, even Ronald Reagan himself did not always act
like Ronald Reagan.
The current outbreak of "gotcha" attacks on Texas Governor Rick
Perry show one of the other pitfalls for those who are trying to pick a
national leader. The three big sound-bite issues used against him during
the TV "debates" have involved Social Security, immigration and a
vaccine against cervical cancer.
Where these three issues have been discussed at length, whether
in a few media accounts or in Governor Perry's own more extended
discussions in an interview on Sean Hannity's program, his position was
far more reasonable than it appeared to be in either his opponents'
sound bites or even in his own abbreviated accounts during the limited
time available in the TV "debate" format.
On Social Security, Governor Perry was not only right to call it
a "Ponzi scheme," but was also right to point out that this did not mean
welshing on the government's obligation to continue paying retirees what
they had been promised.
Even those of us who still disagree with particular decisions
made by Governor Perry can see some of those decisions as simply the
errors of a decent man who realized that he was faced not with a theory
but with a situation.
For example, the ability to save young people from cervical
cancer with a stroke of a pen was a temptation that any decent and
humane individual would find hard to resist, even if Governor Perry
himself now admits to second thoughts about how it was done.
Many of us can agree with Congresswoman Michele Bachmann's
contention that it should have been done differently. But it reflects no
credit on her to have tried to scare people with claims about the
dangers of vaccination. Such scares have already cost the lives of
children who have died on both sides of the Atlantic from diseases that
vaccination would have prevented.
The biggest mischaracterization of Governor Perry's position has
been on immigration. The fact that he has more confidence in putting
"boots on the ground" along the border, instead of relying on a fence
that can be climbed over or tunneled under where there is no one around,
is a logistical judgment, not a question of being against border
control.