Robert Murphy

When it comes to vilifying big evil corporations, the accusations made about oil companies never disappoint.  The latest controversy centers on whether the government should allow more drilling for oil and natural gas on federal lands.  A widely cited report (pdf) from the congressional Committee of Natural Resources gives all manner of statistics showing that oil companies aren’t using the land they already have under lease, and so don’t deserve any more favors.  But a quick analysis shows that these claims are ludicrous.

According to the report,

Between 1999 and 2007, the number of drilling permits issued for development of public lands increased by more than 361%, yet gasoline prices have also risen dramatically[,]contradicting the argument that more drilling means lower gasoline prices. There is simply no correlation between the two.

This is a bit like challenging the notion that doctors help reduce sickness, since hospitals have 361% more doctors than the average building, and yet hospitals have many more sick people too!  Adopting the logic of the above quote, we could declare that there is simply no correlation between health and doctors.

In the case of drilling, what happened is that the skyrocketing price caused oil companies to apply for more permits on the land currently permissible for development.  Tracts that were unprofitable to explore at $30 per barrel became lucrative prospects at $100+.  That is why the number of drilling permits skyrocketed along with the price of oil and gasoline.

What is especially ironic about the leftist refusal to believe in the law of demand—that more product can only be sold at lower prices, other things equal—is that critics of the Bush Administration had no problem with the concept when it came to the Strategic Petroleum Reserve.  During that debate, even members of Congress grasped the point that putting more barrels on the market tends to lower oil prices.

Let us return to the document:

Even if increased domestic drilling activity could affect the price of gasoline, there is yet no justification to open additional federal lands…

Combined, oil and gas companies hold leases to nearly 68 million acres of federal land and waters that they are not producing oil and gas… Oil and gas companies would not buy leases to this land without believing oil and gas can be produced there, yet these same companies are not producing oil or gas from these areas already under their control.

Robert Murphy

Robert Murphy has a Ph.D. in economics and is the author of The Politically Incorrect Guide to Capitalism (Regnery 2007).

Be the first to read Robert Murphy's column. Sign up today and receive delivered each morning to your inbox.