Elisabeth Meinecke
Ending oil and gas subsidies might do very little to affect gas prices at the pump, after the Obama administration sent out a letter Tuesday encouraging congressional leadership to end oil and gas subsidies in the wake of high gas prices that "are weighing on the minds and pocketbooks" of Americans.

"While there is no silver bullet to address rising gas prices in the short term, there are steps we can take to ensure the American people don't fall victim to skyrocketing gas prices over the long term," the letter states.

But Jerry Taylor, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute, said eliminating subsidies for oil and gas will show little effect on either lowering or increasing prices at the pump because of the nature of the U.S.'s role in global prices in the crude oil market. Domestically, Taylor said, there is only so much the United States can do.

The president's budget proposal estimates the government will free up $4 billion dollars by eliminating these tax breaks.

"Based on what we know, you have companies making billions of dollars in profit, $100 million a day in profit, that’s great, okay? That’s good. That’s fine. We should not be taxed. We -- the American taxpayers should not be subsidizing that profit, "said White House Press Secretary Jay Carney during a press briefing Tuesday.

Taylor said however, that any rhetoric that oil and gas companies are getting off easy is hot air. Taylor said they pay 41 percent of their gross revenue to the government, while the S & P 500 average is merely 25.6 percent of gross revenue.

"They pay more than their fair share," Taylor said of the oil and gas industry.

What the White House does think taxpayers should be subsidizing, however, is renewable energy, which it proposes to give $5 billion in new tax credits in its 2012 budget, according to the Novogradac Journal of Tax Credits.

"I am writing to urge you to take immediate action to eliminate unwarranted tax breaks for the oil and gas industry, and to use those dollars to invest in clean energy to reduce our dependency on foreign oil," the president began his letter to congressional leaders.

But Taylor doesn't think any energy companies should be getting government help.

"In a perfect world, what he ought to do is eliminate subsidies to all parties in the energy business," Taylor said.


Elisabeth Meinecke

Elisabeth Meinecke is TOWNHALL MAGAZINE Managing Editor. Follow her on Twitter @lismeinecke.