WASHINGTON - Former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney estimates
the federal tax rate he pays on most of his income is about 15 percent
because it comes from his past investments.
That may sound shockingly low to many middle income Americans who
pay tax rates of 25 percent to 28 percent or higher, but the 15
percent is in the federal tax code for a good reason: to encourage
capital investment which is the mother's milk of a growing economy.
Romney, who said he will release his tax returns about April,
pays the same tax rate anyone else does on income from capital gains
from the sale of stocks, bonds, or from dividends and other securities.
While Romney is a millionaire, any American who buys a share of
stock and sells it for a profit, or is paid dividends from that stock
or other investment, or sells a home would would pay the same rate
Romney does.
Investments that pay a return in long term or short term capital
gains or dividends, is not just for the wealthy. Tens of millions of
workers who invest in 401(k), IRA or Roth savings plans, or through
their mutual funds, or stock portfolios, receive the same tax break
and that income is taxed at 15 percent.
If you were to buy stock in Verizon, which is about $39 a share,
it would pay you a yearly dividend of $2. That's an effective yield on
your investment of 5.1 percent -- not bad at a time when most banks
are paying less than 1 percent.
Buy some AT&T stock at $30.38 and it would pay you $1.76 per
share, an annual yield of 5.8 percent. Where can you get that in
today's economy?
But the federal tax on that income would be 15 percent, too.
President Obama, who wants to raise income taxes on big
corporations, small businesses who file as individual taxpayers,
investors and almost anyone who makes big money, thinks the 15 percent
tax is too low.
He's fond of relating billionaire stock investor Warren Buffet's
complaint that his private secretary at Berkshire Hathaway pays a
higher income tax rate than Buffet does. The reason: virtually all of
Buffet's income is from capital gains and other forms of investment,
so he pays 15 percent, too.
You never read in the newspapers that his secretary is also an
investor and income from her investments is also tax at the 15 percent
rate. Earned income is taxed at the regular rates between 10 percent
at the bottom and 35 percent at the top.
For the past four years, Obama has been beating up rich people,
saying they are not "paying their fair share" in income taxes when, in
fact, they pay most of the income taxes that flows into the U.S.
Treasury.