Economist Kevin Hassett, an adviser to Republican presidential candidate John McCain, described the proposed $145 billion economic stimulus package being negotiated by President Bush and the Democrat-led Congress as I write this column, this way: "It's like borrowing money from the Chinese that we can then drop from a helicopter." (That quote comes from Chronicle staff writer Carolyn Lochhead.) McCain is a long-road kind of guy and his stimulus package essentially involves making the Bush tax cuts permanent and reducing the corporate tax rate to create jobs.
It's not clear what the Bush/Democrats package will hold. Yes, there will be checks of up to $800 for taxpayers. In addition, Democrats are pushing for an extension of unemployment benefits and an increase in food stamps; Republicans want cuts in business taxes to spur job growth.
Edward Lazear, chairman of the president's Council of Economic Advisers, noted, "I find it surprising that people use words like recession" when the nation's unemployment rate is at 5 percent. On the left, Chad Stone, chief economist for the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, noted, "We don't know [if] we're in a recession or not. We're in a weakening economy compared to the middle of last year when growth was 3 or 4 percent."
You know what that means: Even when the left and the right aren't sure if there is a recession, they can always get together on a plan to give away money -- especially in an election year.
I can't say they're wrong. And because they're going to do it anyway, I hope they're right.
Stone supports a stimulus package that sends checks to low-income workers who do not pay federal income taxes, extends unemployment benefits and increases food stamps. If the economy is slowing, Stone argued, such a stimulus package would prompt families living from paycheck to paycheck to spend more -- and that should boost confidence in the market.
But when Stone talks about giving so-called rebates to workers who do not pay federal income taxes -- well, that's an overly generous use of money the federal government does not have. Also, it seems insane to extend unemployment benefits when the unemployment rate is at 5 percent. (The administration is likely to argue that if there is a benefit extension, it would be targeted only at high-unemployment states.)
To my concern that the stimulus package is more deficit spending, Stone has a good answer: This is a one-time shot that won't keep adding to the deficit. And: "Stimulus is triage. You worry about the long-term health of the nation; you do things you wouldn't do to a healthy nation."
Biden to #BostonStrong Survivors: “You’re Living Proof that America Can Never, Never be Defeated” | Daniel Doherty