You'd think I would have known better than to write an editorial on the
basis of those oh-so-reliable polls. After all, they'd failed to detect
Barack Obama's wide lead in Iowa, and soon enough they'd vastly
underestimate how well he'd actually do in South Carolina.
The same expert pollsters overestimated John Edwards' support in Nevada,
putting it at four or five times the vote he actually got, and
underestimated John McCain's support in South Carolina, just as they had
Mike Huckabee's in Iowa. If the polls this year were a stock, the savvy
investor would sell, sell, sell.
It may not be clear by dawn's early light this morning which candidates won
all those 24 primaries, caucuses, district races, and what-have-yous
yesterday, but the big loser this election year is clear: the polls. I
always said I'd never trust them, which of course I'd promptly proceeded to
do in New Hampshire. But the results there made a believer of me. Or rather
a disbeliever.
By now the pollsters have produced a variety of explanations for their less
than exact projections. They always do. Remember their plentiful excuses
after reporting all those exit polls anticipating President Kerry's
landslide victory in '04?
This season, we're told, the polls were skewed by all the new voters who
showed up to cast their ballots, or by the sheer number of voters who waited
till the last days or even last minutes to make up their minds, or by the
unanticipated number of older women who voted for Hillary Clinton in New
Hampshire, or the number of young, black, and/or well-educated voters who
materialized to cast their ballots for Barack Obama in South Carolina and
elsewhere, or well, you name it. Me, I suspect the pollsters were thrown
off their stride by global warming. Or maybe the moon and tides.
The science/art/guesswork of modern public opinion polling is really quite
good - at making excuses. Me, I don't even have an excuse for that editorial
which never appeared. Just a smile. Because like most Americans, I'm pleased
when the voters don't meekly follow the polls and pundits. It restores my
faith in we the unpredictable people.
|