It's not that there isn't light at the end of the tunnel, there's always
been. There's just no tunnel. The happy vision of two states, Jewish and
Arab, living in peace, security and economic and political cooperation goes
way back - at least to the Peel Commission's report of 1937. One can almost
trace the history of Arab-Israeli relations by the times such a solution has
been proposed but never came to fruition.
There was the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry in 1946; the partition of
the British mandate approved by the United Nations in 1947; the Madrid
Conference of 1991 and all its failed progeny, from the Oslo Declaration of
Principles in 1993 to the Camp David Summit of 2000 and the Bush Road Map of
2003. And that's to mention only some of the wreckage along the road to
peace that, again and again, has led to war.
Now we're in the middle of still another empty diplomatic exercise, which
promises to produce a paper peace at best. To borrow a phrase from Israel's
Abba Eban, who had a gift for pithy sayings, Palestinian leaders from Haj
Amin al-Husseini to Yasser Arafat never missed an opportunity to miss an
opportunity.
There comes a time to recognize that, however bleak the prospects for a
happy ending to this long, long conflict, things could be worse, and have
been. Regularly. See the Six Day War of 1967 and the Yom Kippur War of 1973,
both of which dragged in the entire Arab world and, to an alarming extent,
the great powers, too, with their nuclear arsenals.
If the goal were more modest in the Mideast, like just containing the
current brush fires, it might be achievable. Instead, we get talk of a
comprehensive peace treaty by the end of 2008. But the lower the
expectations, the more real the achievements might be.
Yes, such counsel sounds almost un-American. For when we Americans perceive
a problem, our first impulse is to fix it - now, completely and forever, at
least on paper. When it would really be a great step forward just to
ameliorate the danger of war.
Conclusion: Instead of unrealistic promises and cloud-cuckoo timetables, a
little understatement, even a little salutary neglect, would not be out of
order. There are worse things than the status quo, unsatisfying as it is.
For there is nothing so bad it couldn't be made worse by the kind of airy
speechifying that has no basis in reality - and leads only to more
disappointment and more distrust.
|