Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Thursday, February 19, 2009
Mona Charen :: Townhall.com Columnist
Mysterious Khmer
by Mona Charen
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


You wouldn't have thought it possible. But then, you underestimate the ingenuity of the New York Times.

The house organ of the liberal church in America, the Times covered opening day of the trial of one of the worst killers in 20th century history without mentioning the "c" word even once.

What technique! The 18-paragraph story certainly made clear that the reporter, Seth Mydans, was none too pleased with the defendant. That much was clear. Kaing Guek Eav (known as Duch) had been commandant of the Tuol Sleng prison camp in Cambodia under the Khmer Rouge. Who were they? Well, according to the story, they presided over a "fanatical . . . government between 1975 and 1979." That they certainly did. But they were communist fanatics, and the Times managed to elide that detail. It's odd because in other contexts the Times is not shy about characterizing governments' political tilt. The Times put the words "right-wing" together with the Pinochet regime in Chile so often you'd have thought it was part of the title. "The Right-Wing Regime of Augusto Pinochet." It was the same with the "right-wing" government of El Salvador when the FMLN communist movement was attempting to overthrow it. The Times has even used the term "conservative" to describe the mullahs in Iran and the Taliban in Afghanistan.

"In Tuol Sleng," Mydans writes, "a prisoner was not only presumed guilty but also tortured until he offered whatever was demanded It was a prison where Duch's word was final and an order like 'kill them all' was a death sentence." Well, yes.

Mydans tells us that hundreds of "diplomats, journalists, human rights workers, and other victims of the Khmer Rouge" attended the trial and quotes one survivor about the horrors he suffered. "When I was in jail, I could get three spoons of porridge a day and both my legs were put in shackles." The reporter also mentions that the Khmer Rouge are thought to have murdered as many 1.7 million Cambodians during their short reign.

But this spare account hardly does justice to the story. One cannot understand the catastrophe that befell Cambodia without knowing that the people who engineered this gruesome slaughter were intellectuals who dreamed of a better world. Nearly all of the Khmer Rouge leaders had studied abroad, in Paris, where they became drunk on tales of the French Revolution and learned their craft from the French Communist party. "We are making a unique revolution," boasted one official at the time. "Is there any other country that would dare abolish money and markets the way we have? We are much better than the Chinese, who look up to us. We are a good model for the whole world." Pol Pot himself said "only a few thousand Cambodians have died as a result of the application of our policy of bringing abundance to the people."

Abundance to the people. A model for the world. The Khmer Rouge modeled themselves on Mao and Lenin and then shifted into overdrive. They emptied the cities of their inhabitants and force-marched everyone -- the elderly, the sick, pregnant women, children -- in the tropical heat to the countryside where there were no facilities, little drinking water, scarce food, no medicine, and no shelter except thatched huts. There they were starved and enslaved when they weren't shot on the spot for some minor infraction. Anyone who had any connection to the West or to modernity itself was suspect. People who spoke other languages, owned a typewriter or eyeglasses, or any forbidden book could be shot. Failure to make sufficiently abject apologies for ideological errors was enough to merit a bullet between the eyes.

As the Black Book of Communism records, "Democratic Kampuchea was a place with no values or stable points of reference. It really was a nightmare world on the other side of the mirror. The first article of faith was a radical dismissal of the idea that human life had any value. 'Losing you is not a loss, and keeping you is no specific gain' went one terrifying official slogan that recurs time and again in statements by witnesses." Khmer leaders talked of a radiant future, in which agricultural production, in obedience to Pol Pot's Four-Year Plan, would double or quintuple. Instead, the starving, displaced, and thoroughly terrorized Cambodian people saw crop production cut in half in just two years. While they watched their children die in their arms they were herded off to "self-criticism" sessions where their every facial twitch was carefully monitored by gun-wielding Khmer Rouge. The Black Book also records that "Everyone ran the risk of denunciation following a chance encounter with an old friend, colleague, or student ..."

It may be that the evil done in the name of revolution exceeds all other manmade disasters. Certainly one cannot begin to confront Cambodia's grisly history without acknowledging that communists committed this atrocity.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Mona Charen is a syndicated columnist, political analyst and author of Do-Gooders: How Liberals Hurt Those They Claim to Help .
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Mona Charen's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate
4 years living in holes

A Cambodian woman working at a friend’s home in the early 1980's told me how she and others escaped “the killing fields” of the Khmer Rouge by hiding in the forest for 4 years eating roots. She lived in a hole for several days before moving on to dig another hole. She lost all her hair from starvation which proved a good thing since it concealed that she was a woman and kept her safe from rape. She eventually made it to freedom by crossing a river. One of her sisters was able to return to their affluent family home in Phnom Penh and discovered it had been taken over by the communist Khmer Rouge. Their family home was filled with filing cabinets of the Khmer Rouge. The Cambodian woman, once in medical school in Phnom Penh, lost her dream and her home with the communist aggression of the Khmer Rouge. She was able to recover it in part when she came to America and attended nursing school while working as a nurses aide.

For another firsthand account of "the killing fields," read "A Cambodian Odyssey" by Haing Ngor. This Cambodian doctor played the part of Dith Pran in the outstanding film "The Killing Fields." Ngor writes of his own torture and that of others. Ngor survived, came to America, starred in this award-winning movie, and died by the hand of teen-age Asian gang members in a common robbery.

The name of the NY Times article author Seth Mydans rang a bell. I wondered if he were a relation of Carl Mydans, that great LIFE photographer whose photos of the Japanese POW camp survivors are now iconic. It turns out Seth is Carl Mydans' son.

So right on. . .
Yes indeed, why the Times even exists is beyond me. They will likely prosper in coming years as our population is dumbed down even further. Intelligent life has no need for such nonsense.

The Devil's Arithmetic
Reading this column reminded me of the movie 'The Devil's Arithmetic' staring Kirsten Dunst and Brittany Murphy. I found the movie absolutely riveting.

Lloyd Chesley in his editorial review on Amazon says. "Kirsten Dunst plays Hannah, a modern teen more concerned with trends than history. During the traditional Passover dinner, she zones out as her relatives harp about concentration camps. But then Hannah passes through a portal to the past, where she becomes her own ancestor in Poland during the Nazi persecution of the Jews.

Director Donna Deitch provides an infinite library of Holocaust detail, re-creating the period with minute dedication. Haunting images, every costume, every hair, every light and shadow conspire to maintain a sense of desolate desperation. Suspense pervades as escapes fail and mothers with newborns are taken away. Only the magical context of the story, taken from the original children's novel by Jane Yolen, allows for a life-affirming ending. The performances may not be multifaceted but, considering the single-mindedness of the tale, the deep commitment of the actors makes every moment real and meaningful. Dunst seems able to carry a movie herself, and Brittany Murphy is mesmerizing as Hannah's sweet cousin Rivkah.

The message is powerfully direct, but the film avoids extreme violence in deference to young audiences. The theme is enshrined in the Rivkah's words: "We must stay alive to tell everyone what we've been through." Indeed, when Hannah returns to the present, she is a new woman, with a profound love of her culture and a religious respect for the value of all human life."

I'm grateful for our Judeo-Christian heritage. History is too full of the story of the death and destruction that result when that heritage is either moved away from or was never in the life of a nation to begin with.

The Devil's Arithmetic
Reading this column reminded me of the movie 'The Devil's Arithmetic' staring Kirsten Dunst and Brittany Murphy. I found the movie absolutely riveting.

Lloyd Chesley in his editorial review on Amazon says. "Kirsten Dunst plays Hannah, a modern teen more concerned with trends than history. During the traditional Passover dinner, she zones out as her relatives harp about concentration camps. But then Hannah passes through a portal to the past, where she becomes her own ancestor in Poland during the Nazi persecution of the Jews.

Director Donna Deitch provides an infinite library of Holocaust detail, re-creating the period with minute dedication. Haunting images, every costume, every hair, every light and shadow conspire to maintain a sense of desolate desperation. Suspense pervades as escapes fail and mothers with newborns are taken away. Only the magical context of the story, taken from the original children's novel by Jane Yolen, allows for a life-affirming ending. The performances may not be multifaceted but, considering the single-mindedness of the tale, the deep commitment of the actors makes every moment real and meaningful. Dunst seems able to carry a movie herself, and Brittany Murphy is mesmerizing as Hannah's sweet cousin Rivkah.

The message is powerfully direct, but the film avoids extreme violence in deference to young audiences. The theme is enshrined in the Rivkah's words: "We must stay alive to tell everyone what we've been through." Indeed, when Hannah returns to the present, she is a new woman, with a profound love of her culture and a religious respect for the value of all human life."

I'm grateful for our Judeo-Christian heritage. History is too full of the story of the death and destruction that result when that heritage is either moved away from or was never in the life of a nation to begin with.

The NY Times
The Times is nothing more than a propaganda piece for the far left. Any relevance to objective news reporting has vanished a long time ago. They still will not acknowledge that their reporter in the 1930s glorified Stalin's five year plans and lied about the starvation that was taking place.

William
“I'm grateful for our Judeo-Christian heritage. History is too full of the story of the death and destruction that result when that heritage is either moved away from or was never in the life of a nation to begin with.”

How right you are. I too am grateful, but I would add, it is not just culture that keeps Judeo-Christian nations from barbarism, but it is when people have a committed, personal relationship with God. When God can speak to our hearts, we might make mistakes, but we will move in the direction of what is good and right.

Throughout my life, I have had doubts about the teaching of my religion, but one thing keeps me coming back. It is witnessing what happens to individuals and nations when they are separated from God. When they substitute their own will and wisdom for that of God's.

Without God, cruelty cannot be restrained. People will rationalize anything that is convenient for them. Spiraling downward to debauchery is so much easier than an uphill climb toward Godliness.


NY Times hoping for acquittal

The NY Times as well as the entire left wing are praying this guy walks so they can give him tenure at the University of Chicago.

It can happen here
If you think a junta is unthinkable - here in our country - all you have to do is to listen to those Obamawannas who spit on the Constitution. We almost had it stolen several times - FDR tried to ruin the SP (among other things) and Ollie North and L. Giuffrida attempted a coup in the WH basement using Executive Order 11490. The order could still be used - in a state of declared national "emergency."

Who in Cambodia would have believed, prior to it happening?

It could happen here.

No Difference
The Obama administration and his progressive allies throughout our government are identical to the Khmer Rouge. All Americans need to fear our well tailored, eloquently speaking, progressives because they are the worst of the leftist Nazi’s we’ve given dominion over us.

All of the modern tyrants and butchers were well educated intellectuals, technicians and professionals, educators and healers, who revealed their contempt for the common man.

Germany was a nation of technicians, scientists and educated progressives. They used their talents for creativity and management to design and carry out a highly evolved system of eliminating their fellow citizens.

The architect of the butchery in the former Yugoslavia, Radovan Karadžic, was a poet and a psychiatrist.

Lennin and Marx were highly educated. Pol Pot attended catholic school, enrolled in a technical college and obtained a scholarship to go to France and study radio electricity.

Let’s not get fooled by messiahs in fine clothes.

All of the modern tyrants were received as saviors by the gullible masses. Reforms were enacted to please the mobs. But then the people were quietly enslaved and terrorized.

Americans who have not been blinded by our new false prophet are preparing. We do not hear or see them because the media is busy bowing to our Celebrity in Chief, but they are shoring up their lives, getting out of debt, stocking up on necessities, and getting weapons. They do not intend to be rounded up and stuck in the Superdome this time.

Dave
Are you so dense as to not see that failing to mention the "C" word as in Communisim destins us to repeat the horrors that happened in Cambodia?????????
Can't happen here?????????
Have you heard about the detention camps here in this country that are being prepared if/when the anarchy breaks out. This is the problem that the BRIGHT VISION of socialism and communisim project. It Blinds those that refuse to see.

rouge
Gee, what does "rouge" mean in French anyway? I wonder why it was Khmer Rouge, and not "Khmer Bleu." Must just be a coincidence.


Dave
No, she is upset that the NYT is actively covering up for the Khmer Rouge the same way they did with Stalin, and how they have with every other brutual communist dictatorship they have ever covered. They are trying the Roland Burris method of truth telling by leaving out a huge part of the story.

Khmer Rouge
Communist Killings
USSR 20 m 293 m
China 65 m 1.3 b
Vietnam 1 m. 82 m
North Korea 1 m 23 m
Cambodia 2 m 14
Eastern Europe 1 m no number
Latin America 150,000 no number
Africa 1.7 million 767 m
Afghanistan 1.5 million 31 m
Nazi Germany 11 m (6 m Jews) 80 m (some of the killings in other countries
such as Poland)
Nazi's were called right wing, but Nazi comes from National Socialism
They were all collectivists and all were coercive Utopians.
Saddam Hussein was a Baathist. It seemed to take some from the Nazis and some from the Communists. I didn't get look for numbers for Iraq.
Who were the best killers?
Makes the Inquisition and the Crusades look rather tame. Maybe also the European religious wars.

Khmer Rouge
were supported by the communist bloc. They provided the weaponry and logistical support which allowed the Rouge to defeat the army of Lon Nol.

Surprised?
Just another example of the lib MSM double standard.

I have a minor quibble...
Mona Charen pointed out that any little thing could get you shot by the Khmer Rouge. That's not exactly true. The Khmer Rouge were under strict orders not to waste bullets. Therefore, the most common method of execution was by way of mallets, saws, etc. The fact that the NYT is giving their ideological fellow travelers a pass is not a surprise but it is no less disgusting. Bear in mind that the NYT has a history of cheerleading history's mass murderers (Stalin-Duranty, Pol Pot-Schanberg, Castro-Matthews). The fact these clowns have any credibility defies reason.

NYT is on its way out anyway.
Yesterday, the value of a single share of NYT stock was LESS than the price one would pay for one copy of its Sunday issue! There's a good reason for that. In the face of a bad economy generally and the advent of the blogosphere, people are just not reading the NYT any longer which has caused its ad revenues to crater. No one wants to read a continual litany of opinion about how "evil" America is and how wonderful our new regime is. As the economy goes downhill, (Let's remember that it did NOT start downhill until AFTER the Democrats re-assumed control of the nation's pursestrings in 2006 when they retook the House!) NYT simply talks id further down...blaming, of course, the whole thing on Bush--forgetting conveniently that the President doesn't spend a single dime of tax money. CONGRESS does.

The NYT's love affair with communism will be its downfall and I will shed no tears when the time comes.

Bishop Fulton J Sheen . . .
once said that "it is easier for a "educated" person to rationalize evil. Let's look at some of these "educated" people.
Lenin
Stalin
Hitler
Sanger
Singer
Pol Pot
Obama

Valuing human life is the esssence
The first article of faith was a radical dismissal of the idea that human life had any value. 'Losing you is not a loss, and keeping you is no specific gain'

Quoting Bishop Sheen again -
"You can't have a good society without good
people."


A true Patriot of Cambodia, Prince Matak
On April 1, a weeping Lon Nol, crippled by nervous breakdowns and a series of minor strokes, fled Phnom Penh for Hawaii with his family and entourage while Prince Sirik Matak and other Lon Nol supporters remained behind in the hopes of organizing a last-minute peace talks. The Khmer Rouge rejected the talks and pressed further into the capital. US Ambassador to Cambodia John Gunther Dean quickly made plans to evacuate US embassy staff and their families along with key Cambodian government officials, including Sirik Matak, Lon Nol's brother Lon Non, and acting prime minister Long Boret. All three declined the offer. In the hours leading up to the evacuation Sirik Matak responded to Dean's invitation:

Dear Excellency and friend,

I thank you very sincerely for your letter and for your offer to transport me towards freedom. I cannot, alas, leave in such a cowardly fashion.

As for you and in particular for your great country, I never believed for a moment that you would have this sentiment of abandoning a people which has chosen liberty. You have refused us your protection and we can do nothing about it. You leave us and it is my wish that you and your country will find happiness under the sky.

But mark it well that, if I shall die here on the spot and in my country that I love, it is too bad because we are all born and must die one day. I have only committed the mistake of believing in you, the Americans.

Please accept, Excellency, my dear friend, my faithful and friendly sentiments. Sirik Matak.

Prince Sisowath Sirik Matak, former contender for the Cambodian throne and co-conspirator in the Lon Nol coup, would be executed by the Khmer Rouge two weeks later, along with Long Boret, Lon Non, and the other remaining members of the Lon Nol government.

A Good History Lesson
That is peculiar that the NY Times never said they were communist.

I am glad you said something about this. Our American life styles in 2009 are so far from what happened in Cambodia it is like a different planet, but we need to remember how crazy things can get.

I think the Obama administration
is very capable of coming after those of us who disagree with him. And, the earlier comment about the construction of detention facilities is quite true. Proposed by Fla-D. Alcee Hastings, a guy who needs to be incarcerated himself.

I believe it to be sad, but Americans who love their freedom and rights had better be prepared to fight to keep them. Otherwise, welcome to the American Gulag.

Strange
I find it strange that none of the usual liberal posters have commented on this. (I'm not counting the dumb potshot from Dave of VA.)

Could it be they are tired of defending the Lady?

How near or far?
I wonder how close we are to entering a nightmare like that ourselves? There are those among us who want to change so many things about our society. They don't want to hear anything other that what they believe. They state falsehoods as fact and denigrate truth and science that doesn't conform to their beliefs and emotions.

Too Close to Vietnam
The reason that the NYT does not want to use the 'C' word is because it is a reminder to thinking people of the cowardly abandonment of the South Vietnamese by the democratic party. By not providing arms/materials to the South Vietnamese Government as promised, the dems in congress assured communist victory. The South bravely lasted for 3 years, but fell and their fall led directly to the communist takeover and the atrocities that followed.

But the liberal press is very proud of their "victory" in getting the U.S. to abandon Vietnam.

NYT suicide
Please, please , please don't criticize the NYT for its reporting. They are slowly digging their own grave. Doesn't a single Mexican businessman now own about 15% of the company due to lack of revenue? How's that saying go, "Never interupt your enemy when they are busy defeating themselves."?
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.