Biden's Deal for the Devil
Analysis: With 2022 Midterms in Rearview Mirror, Hard and Clear Lessons Emerge for...
Veteran Congressman Reveals Shocking Place One Democrat Stored Her American Flag
Inflation Surges Past Expectations Again
Top Democrat Criticizes Biden's 'Deeply Disturbing' Prisoner Swap Decision
Why Oregon Teachers' Union Has Lost 20 Percent of Its Membership
One State Lowers Teaching Qualifications to Address Teacher Shortages
Critics Notice Something Unusual in Video of Prisoner Exchange That Freed Griner
Kyrsten Sinema Has Left the Democratic Party
Really, Guys? Liberal Outlet Gets Ghoulish About COVID, GOP, and the 2022 Elections.
Here's a Thought: Let's NOT Hand Democrats Exactly What They Want
How Republicans Can Regain the Initiative
A Broken Trade Litigation Forum Threatens Important Technologies for Seniors
A Credible Conservative Warrior Emerges to Lead the RNC
Biden Policies Are Endangering Maine Lobstermen and Right Whales

What Can Conservatives "Be Happy With" On SCOTUS?

Former Reagan administration official Charles Fried had some kind words to say about one of the front-runners for the open Supreme Court slot created by Justice Stevens' retirement in an article subtitled "
Why Elena Kagan has earned the respect of conservatives, like me."

The media like to pin a one-word--or if they are more nuanced, one-phrase--epithet on public figures, as Homer would on his gods and heroes (grey-eyed Athena, wily Odysseus). They have decided to attach the term "conservative" (or for the more subtle: "relatively conservative") to solicitor general and former Harvard Law School Dean Elena Kagan. A lot of people--myself included--have described Kagan's many remarkable qualities in many places. Here I want only to explain how she got this dubious sobriquet, one that is unlikely to do her much good.

Does this all mean that she is some kind of crypto-Republican who would shift the Court to the right? And what does her behavior as dean tell us about her ideology? My clear answers are no and nothing. I do not doubt that her heart beats on the left.

What can conservatives be happy with from an Obama nominee? I wrote last week that we'll have to be satisfied with a nominee who has a discernible judicial philosophy and a fidelity to the Constitution. With Kagan, Diane Wood and Merrick Garland having emerged as frontrunners, the worst option for conservatives seems to be Wood. Garland probably is too "moderate" for Obama's left-wing base, but Kagan may be the best that we can hope for.

This doesn't mean that conservatives won't be rightly justified with every criticism that we make of whichever left-wing nominee comes out of the Obama administration. It just means we need to have realistic expectations.

Hat tip Reason

Join the conversation as a VIP Member


Trending on Townhall Video