VIP

So Who Flushed the Toilet During Supreme Court Oral Arguments?

|
|
Posted: May 07, 2020 7:30 AM
So Who Flushed the Toilet During Supreme Court Oral Arguments?

Source: S.F. Shannon Real Estate Management LLC via AP

During the Wuhan coronavirus pandemic, the Supreme Court decided to conduct oral arguments via telephone; a safe and convenient way for the highest court in the land to conduct their business, but perhaps a little too convenient for one participant who decided to conduct his or her personal business during the phone call. 

While the Supreme Court made history for this new setting of oral arguments, history was also made on Wednesday when one unidentified lawyer, perhaps a justice, flushed a toilet without first hitting the mute button. 

So who was the culprit? This much we know: A lawyer in the case, reportedly Roman Martinez, was presenting arguments when the flush occurred. According to guidance issued by the court about the conference call, as reported by CNN, once a lawyer finished presenting his or her arguments, the system would mute that lawyer's phone line. Only the lawyer speaking would have his or her phone unmuted. It stands to reason, then, that the flush may have come from Martinez's line, but the lawyer seemed completely unfazed by the sound of the flush. Was that because Martinez was expecting it? Is it possible the flush came from one of the justices' phone lines? These are questions to which the American people deserve answers.