Opinion

Does Alec Baldwin Deserve Decency?

|
Posted: Oct 27, 2021 12:01 AM
The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.
Does Alec Baldwin Deserve Decency?

Source: AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall, File

It was probably the worst day of Alec Baldwin's life when he accidentally shot and killed cinematographer Halyna Hutchins on the set of the movie "Rust" on Oct. 21. It's a time to feel terrible about a 42-year-old woman with a husband and a young son.

Then, CNN's Jake Tapper used it in one of his commentaries to denounce the entire Republican Party for making this tragedy an occasion for jokes. "There's something about our politics right now that is driving people away from our shared humanity."

Tapper was upset that Rep. Lauren Boebert recalled a tweet from Dec. 5, 2014, where Baldwin wrote, "I'm going to make bright, banana yellow t-shirts that read 'My hands are up. Please don't shoot me.' Who wants one?" This was about the false claim that Michael Brown said "Hands up, don't shoot" in Ferguson, Missouri in August 2014, when, in reality, Brown was reaching for a policeman's gun.

But Baldwin's commentary on shootings is much worse than that. In a Feb. 17, 2006, blog post on The Huffington Post about Vice President Dick Cheney accidentally shooting his friend (nonfatally) during a hunting trip, Baldwin had no decency. "Cheney is a terrorist. He terrorizes our enemies abroad and innocent citizens here at home indiscriminately. Who ever thought Harry Whittington would be the answer to America's prayers. (?) Finally, someone who might get that lying, thieving Cheney into a courtroom to answer some direct questions."

That wasn't the only passage that reads extra-terribly now. He had to make a joke about shooting Scooter Libby. "Cheney's the guy who told Libby to out Valerie Plame. The rumor I heard is that someone yelled, 'Look out! Shooter!' and Cheney thought he said Scooter and fired in that general direction."

A few days later, after hearing complaints, Baldwin insincerely apologized: "How about something more measured, then? How about... a lying, thieving Oil Whore. Or, a murderer of the U.S. Constitution?"

In our decency, we would hope Baldwin doesn't have to go to court for this shooting. But the subtitle of Baldwin's 2006 opus was, "Will Cheney and Whittington go to court? I would imagine if a guy with a few beers in him shoots you in the face... "

This isn't the only Cheney-and-death "humor" Baldwin composed for Arianna Huffington. On the Fourth of July, 2006, Baldwin cooked up a double-murder fantasy in which he dispatched Osama bin Laden with a box-cutter: "I gather up the body of the world's most notorious terrorist and hurl it over the balcony. Then, in the final stroke of luck, bin Laden lands on Dick Cheney. God bless America."

(Weird note: The byline on these articles now is "zak plus 1 from MT," as is every Alec Baldwin article in today's HuffPost archive.)

Tapper made almost no attempt to factor in Baldwin's well-known penchant for hate speech beyond this: "Baldwin is, of course, not only a progressive but very aggressive and outspoken about liberal issues, including gun control."

He even brought up Liz Cheney as the example of the "decency Republican" in contrast to bomb-throwing Marjorie Taylor Greene. But he couldn't recall 2006!

Tapper's thunderous editorial concluded with some anonymous Republican messaging him that "being a horrible person is now actually a job requirement in this party," and added, "I hope to God that that Republican official was wrong."

Does Baldwin deserve decency now? In the spirit of Christian charity or "shared humanity," yes. But armed with the memory of Baldwin's long record of indecency, that would be extremely kind and merciful.

Tim Graham is director of media analysis at the Media Research Center and executive editor of the blog NewsBusters.org.

Recommended Townhall Video